Home of NYC's best Italian meatballs & red sauce classics. Cozy Italian ambiance perfect for any occasion.
POLPETTE 71 is a beloved Italian eatery known for its comforting red sauce dishes and its claim to having the best meatballs in the city. Reviewers frequently praise their American-Italian style meatballs, noting that they are a standout item that lives up to the hype. The restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere suitable for various occasions, from casual dinners to anniversaries.
This Italian restaurant is particularly celebrated for its American-Italian style red sauce meatballs, with many customers agreeing they are among the best in the city. Other recommended dishes include pasta and seafood, contributing to a menu that offers satisfying and authentic Italian flavors.
"The standout recommended dish is their American-Italian red sauce meatballs, which many consider to be the best in the city. Pasta and seafood are also mentioned as good options."
Customers consistently rave about the restaurant's excellent meatballs and classic Italian dishes, highlighting the cozy atmosphere and friendly service.
"Il Polpette on the UWS is recommended for its Italian food, specifically noting that they don't burn their sauce and their claim for best Italian meatballs in the city holds true."
Positive"This user stated that Polpette has better meatballs compared to Carmines, and if open to a different style, The Owl's Tail offers good meatballs in a lemony broth."
Positive"The commenter recommended Polpette for its excellent meatballs, pasta, and seafood, noting its cozy Italian atmosphere with a mix of couples and groups, and comfortable table spacing."
Positive"Polpette 71 is recommended for its American-Italian red sauce style meatballs."
Positive"Polpette 71 serves decent old-school Italian dishes but is not considered a fine dining experience."
Neutral"Polpette 71 is a restaurant that the commenter enjoys."
Positive
