TLDR
Quintessential UWS institution famed for iconic smoked fish and old-school deli vibes. A must-visit for classic Jewish comfort food and a true NYC experience.
Reddit Sentiment for BARNEY GREENGRASS(based on 100 Reddit opinions)
Will Hartman reviews Barney Greengrass, a New York institution on the Upper West Side famed for its "Sturgeon King" title and classic Jewish appetizing fare. Experience the bustling atmosphere and delicious smoked fish.
Details
Established in 1908, this Upper West Side institution is affectionately known as "The Sturgeon King" and serves as a quintessential New York City deli experience [1]. Known for its unique, bustling atmosphere, the establishment offers a menu deeply rooted in classic Jewish comfort food, featuring standout smoked fish and traditional breakfast items [1], [2]. While the dining experience can be fast-paced, its historical significance and quality ensure it remains a beloved, recurring favorite for many [1], [3].
Food Overview
This deli is celebrated for its exceptional smoked fish, particularly sturgeon, whitefish salad, and nova [1]. While many guests rave about the scrambled eggs with sturgeon and onions or the off-menu latkes [1], [6], others suggest that the quality of the bagels themselves does not always reach the same high standard as the fish [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BARNEY GREENGRASS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: 96th And Broadway To Columbus Circle A Walk With
"Noted for serving latkes and smoked fish."
PositiveFrom post: 96th And Broadway To Columbus Circle A Walk With
"Confirms this is an excellent choice for this specific area."
PositiveFrom post: 96th And Broadway To Columbus Circle A Walk With
"Mentioned as a restaurant choice in the thread."
NeutralFrom post: 96th And Broadway To Columbus Circle A Walk With
"Recommended specifically for their smoked fish."
PositiveFrom post: Gotos For Cheesecake In The Upper East Sideupper
"Suggested as an obvious choice for cheesecake."
PositiveFrom post: Best Restaurant In Nyc You Can Find A Table On
"Recommended for appetizing food."
PositiveFrom post: Lazer Wolf Bartolo Or Gusi Vibe And Food
"Recommended for a classic experience."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Take Someone If They Could Only
"Recommended as the best place for fish."
PositiveFrom post: What Are The Best Quick Bites Along These Route
"Listed as a suggestion."
NeutralFrom post: Solo Dining Recommendations In Upper West Side
"The user has been a few times and felt disappointed, noting the quality seems to have slipped."
NegativeFrom post: Solo Dining Recommendations In Upper West Side
"Recommended for breakfast."
PositiveFrom post: Reccs For Someone Who Loves Sarges Lazarras Old
"Agrees it feels like a time capsule."
PositiveFrom post: Reccs For Someone Who Loves Sarges Lazarras Old
"The user notes that this place has the right 'vibe' for someone looking for old-school establishments."
PositiveFrom post: Best Bagel And Lox I Had So Far Apollo Bagels In
"The user considers this the best place for a top-notch bagel with smoked fish, despite the higher price point."
PositiveFrom post: Barney Greengrass 27 Lox Bagel Is It Worth
"The commenter suggests that for a similar experience, one could buy lox from Zabar's, get fresh bagels, and assemble the sandwich at home, implying it's a more cost-effective approach for those not seeking the full 'tourist' experience."
NegativeFrom post: Barney Greengrass 27 Lox Bagel Is It Worth
"The commenter believes a $27 breakfast bagel is never worth the cost."
NegativeFrom post: Barney Greengrass 27 Lox Bagel Is It Worth
"The sturgeon and egg sandwich is considered worth the price."
PositiveFrom post: Barney Greengrass 27 Lox Bagel Is It Worth
"The sturgeon is highlighted as a fantastic option, though expensive."
PositiveFrom post: Barney Greengrass 27 Lox Bagel Is It Worth
"The high price is attributed to the establishment's status as an institution, even if it's not necessarily better than a homemade version."
NeutralFrom post: Barney Greengrass 27 Lox Bagel Is It Worth
"While acknowledging the high price, the commenter suggests it's better to make a lox bagel at home using ingredients from Acme."
Negative