TLDR
Historic "Sturgeon King" on the Upper West Side serving legendary smoked fish and Jewish deli classics in a nostalgic, time-capsule setting.
Reddit Sentiment for BARNEY GREENGRASS(based on 95 Reddit opinions)
Barney Greengrass explores modern branding through limited-edition apparel, as the third-generation owner balances expansion goals with the need to maintain tradition.
Will Hartman reviews Barney Greengrass, a New York institution on the Upper West Side famed for its "Sturgeon King" title and classic Jewish appetizing fare. Experience the bustling atmosphere and delicious smoked fish.
Details
Established in 1908, this quintessential New York institution is celebrated as the "Sturgeon King," offering an authentic, nostalgic experience that feels like a time capsule [1]. The menu centers on exceptional smoked fish, including sturgeon and Nova, which are frequently cited as the best in the city [2], [3]. While the atmosphere is often praised, some patrons note that the experience can be brisk and prices for items like bagels and lox are on the higher side [4], [5].
Food Overview
The restaurant is renowned for its superior smoked fish, particularly sturgeon, whitefish salad, and Nova [1]. Customers highly recommend the latkes, chopped liver, and scrambled eggs with sturgeon and onions [1], [5], [7]. While some reviewers find the bagels average, they emphasize that the high-quality fish toppings make the meal worthwhile [5].
Overall sentiment remains highly positive, with many diners viewing it as an essential, high-quality New York institution [3], [4]. Some customers express concerns about the high price points for standard items, and a small subset of long-time visitors have noted a potential dip in quality [5], [6].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BARNEY GREENGRASS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Im Traveling From For The Weekend And Need Food
"Mentioned as worth trying for Ashkenazi/Jewish food."
PositiveFrom post: Im Traveling From For The Weekend And Need Food
"A strong recommendation for smoked fish, other Jewish foods, and the latkes."
PositiveFrom post: Im Traveling From For The Weekend And Need Food
"Recommended as a great choice for classic NYC Jewish food."
PositiveFrom post: Im Traveling From For The Weekend And Need Food
"Highly recommended Jewish deli where the pastrami is considered better than Katz's, with amazing sturgeon and latkes."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Eat Liver In Nyc Pate Mousse Terrine Etc
"The chopped liver at this location is described as delicious."
Positive