Iconic NYC bakery known for its HUGE, gooey cookies - a choc chip walnut or oatmeal raisin is a must-try treat!
Indulge in the legendary cookies of Levain Bakery, famed for their thick, gooey, and generously portioned creations. Each cookie is a substantial treat, often described as a meal in itself, with rave reviews for their chocolate chip walnut, oatmeal raisin, and dark chocolate peanut butter varieties. While some debate the texture, many find the underbaked, rich interior to be a delightful contrast to the slightly crisp exterior, making them a must-try NYC bakery experience.
Levain Bakery is renowned for its massive, underbaked cookies that are rich and gooey on the inside with a slightly crisp exterior. Popular choices include the classic Chocolate Chip Walnut, Oatmeal Raisin, and Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip cookies. While many adore this distinctive texture, a minority find them too dense, sweet, or heavy. The bakery also offers other baked goods like scones and cakes, with the Oatmeal Raisin Scone being noted as particularly excellent by some.
"The Chocolate Chip Walnut cookie, Oatmeal Raisin cookie, and Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip cookie are consistently recommended as must-tries. The Oatmeal Raisin Scone is also singled out as an excellent item."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the cookies for their unique texture and generous size, though some find them too rich or dense. The oatmeal raisin and chocolate chip varieties are frequently highlighted as favorites.
Important Note
Some customers find the cookies to be too rich, dense, or sweet, and there's a recurring debate about whether they are underbaked or simply have a specific intended texture. Quality consistency across different locations or over time has also been mentioned.
"Levain cookies were suggested as traveling well."
Neutral"Levain cookies were recommended."
Neutral"Jacques Torres cookie kits were recommended, with a note that Levain cookies are also good but heavy."
Neutral"Levain cookies or breads and babka were suggested as potential gifts, though the user later acknowledged the week-long shelf life might be an issue for non-chocolate items."
Neutral"Considered nothing special, the cookies were found to be just big. The lemon white chip cookie was liked, but the carrot cake cookie was dry and underwhelming, resulting in a low rating of 6.3."
Negative"Levain is suggested as a place to get chocolate chip cookies."
Positive"Further elaborating on their dislike, this user states Levain cookies are not good, being stodgy, overly sweet, and made with cheap-tasting chocolate."
Negative"This commenter was disappointed with Levain's chocolate chip cookie, finding it too chocolatey, large, and heavy. They prefer smaller, less intense cookies."
Negative"This user finds Levain's cookies fun but a bit much to eat and terrible when stale. They prefer homemade cookies or those from Edith's."
Neutral"This user strongly dislikes Levain's chocolate chip cookie, finding it floury and uninteresting, despite its appearance."
Negative"This user considers Levain's cookie to be their favorite so far and plans to try Crumbl Cookies as well."
Positive"This user simply states 'Levain' as a favorite."
Positive"For those seeking a warm, gooey cookie, Levain is this user's go-to."
Positive"This user finds Levain's chocolate chip cookies to be too much of a monotone 'hockey puck' and their least favorite among the city's options."
Negative"This user finds Levain Bakery's chocolate chip walnut cookie to be quite good."
Positive"This user finds Levain's cookies to be dry and tough, stating that their thickness makes them difficult to eat, even when fresh and gooey."
Negative"This user rates Levain's cookie highly, placing it in a tie for their favorite. However, they also highly recommend a temporary cookie from Tailpoppy."
Positive"This commenter strongly dislikes Levain's chocolate chip cookies, finding them overly sweet, unevenly baked, and dense, comparing them to a hockey puck. They prefer other items from the bakery like the baguette and pastries."
Negative"This user names Funny Face Bakery as the answer for the best cookie, implying it is superior to Levain."
Neutral"The author lists Levain Bakery's chocolate chip cookie as their fourth favorite with a score of 8.7 out of 10, according to the Beli app. They have many other places to try."
Positive
