Indulgent American comfort food & decadent cakes, especially the 24-layer. Known for a standout French dip and generous portions.
Maison Pickle on the Upper West Side offers a decadent take on American comfort food, earning a reputation for its generous portions and rich flavors. Diners frequently rave about their indulgent offerings, with the French dip standing out as a particularly popular dish, often drawing comparisons to other well-regarded establishments. Sweet tooths will rejoice at the sight of their towering multi-layer cakes, especially the highly acclaimed 24-layer cake, which some have declared the best in the city. Other favorites include their appetizer rolls and creamy mac and cheese, making it a go-to spot for a satisfying and celebratory meal. While the majority of feedback is overwhelmingly positive, a few dissenting voices find the restaurant to be just 'mid' or suggest alternatives, but for most, Maison Pickle delivers a memorable, indulgent dining experience.
Maison Pickle is praised for its American comfort food, with a strong emphasis on indulgent options. The French dip is a popular choice, often compared favorably to other establishments. The restaurant is also renowned for its decadent cakes, especially the 24-layer cake, which several customers describe as exceptional. Other recommended items include appetizer rolls and mac and cheese. While most feedback is positive, a few reviewers found the food to be mediocre or unimpressive, with one noting the French dip was a bit too rare.
"The French dip and the multi-layer cakes, particularly the 24-layer cake, are highly recommended. Appetizer rolls and mac and cheese are also mentioned as favorites."
Customer sentiment for Maison Pickle is largely positive, with many users recommending it for its indulgent comfort food and impressive desserts. The French dip and the multi-layer cakes, particularly the 24-layer cake, are frequently highlighted as must-try items. Some users find the portions generous, while a minority consider the restaurant to be mediocre or not worth traveling for. There are some comparisons made to Jacob's Pickles, with opinions divided on which is superior.
Important Note
Some users find the restaurant to be mediocre or suggest it's not worth traveling for, with one user comparing it unfavorably to Jacob's Pickles. There's also a mention of potential issues with ownership and restaurant safety hazards, though this is from a comment discussing the French dip.
"The user highlights the honey butter "break bread" from Maison pickle as a standout item."
Positive"The user states that Maison Pickle is "worse" than Jacob's Pickles, implying an even more negative experience or quality compared to the already criticized restaurant."
Negative"The user listed Maison Pickle as one of the places they enjoy for chocolate cake."
Positive"The chocolate cake at Maison Pickle is ridiculously moist and very large."
Positive"The user states that Maison Pickle's 24-layer cake is legitimate."
Positive"The author recommends Maison Pickle as a good dining option on the UWS."
Positive"The original poster, looking for UWS birthday delivery, found Maison Pickle to be a promising suggestion that could 'fit the bill' for a celebratory meal."
Positive"Commenter onekate suggested Maison Pickle for a birthday delivery to the UWS, highlighting their rolls and mac and cheese as favorite items for a celebratory meal."
Positive"The author declares Maison Pickle's 24-layer cake as 'hands down the best cake in the city.' They also express skepticism about Claud's high praise, attributing it to influencer hype."
Positive"The author simply lists 'Maison Pickle' as a recommendation for chocolate cake."
Positive"Confirms Maison Pickle serves a classic French dip, though mentions issues with ownership and restaurant safety hazards. Suggests the previous commenter might have ordered a variation."
Neutral"Having tried both recently, finds Hillstone’s French dip way better than Maison Pickle's and highly recommends Hillstone."
Negative"The user replies to a comment about Maison Pickle, adding that their French dip is also excellent."
Positive"The user recommends Maison Pickle on the UWS for French onion soup."
Positive"Expresses doubt about what Maison Pickle serves, stating it's not a French Dip."
Negative"Recommends Maison Pickle, noting the French dip is a ginormous meal and they have great cocktails."
Positive"Gives Maison Pickle a thumbs up."
Positive"Rates Maison Pickle's French dip as good, but considers Hillstone's to be perfect and superior."
Positive"Finds the French dip at Maison Pickle a little on the raw side but would still recommend it."
Positive"Lists Maison Pickle as a recommended spot for French dip."
Positive"Recommends Maison Pickle for a good French dip and cocktail, comparing it favorably to Minetta Tavern. Also suggests getting chocolate cake and amaro."
Positive"Recommends Maison Pickle for French dip."
Positive"Expresses love for Maison Pickle and doesn't understand the criticism it receives. Their only complaint is that the portion sizes are too large."
Positive"Expresses interest in visiting Maison Pickle specifically for their 24-layer cake slice, which they note looks amazing."
Positive"Agrees with skipping Maison Pickle, considering it a weird choice to travel to the Upper West Side for given the other available options."
Negative"Suggests replacing Maison Pickle with Jacob’s Pickles, stating Jacob's Pickles is much better."
Negative"Describes Maison Pickle as "trash" and analogous to a "Fancy Cheesecake Factory for midwestern transplants.""
Negative"Advises skipping Maison Pickle, calling it "mid" (mediocre) and noting that friends who have gone share the same opinion."
Negative"Listed as a recommended spot in the UWS, mentioned alongside Jacob's Pickles."
Positive"Recommends Maison Pickle for an indulgent meal, highlighting their appetizer rolls with various toppings and their impressive 20-layer cake."
Positive"Chic bathroom with a fancy candle and all black wall tiles."
Positive
