TLDR
Gargantuan American comfort food known for decadent 24-layer chocolate cake and massive French dip portions. A reliable UWS staple for big, crowd-pleasing meals.
Instagram Posts References
Maison Pickle is highlighted for its distinctive glassware, accompanying its drinks. The visual suggests an enjoyable and aesthetically pleasing beverage experience.
Details
Famous for its gargantuan portion sizes and indulgent comfort food, this Upper West Side institution has become a local staple [1], [2]. Patrons often flock here for their signature French dip sandwiches and an extravagant 24-layer chocolate cake [2], [3]. It is widely regarded as a reliable, family-friendly destination for both holiday gatherings and casual dining [4], [5].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on hearty American comfort food, characterized by comically large portions like the French toast and savory items like the Patty Melt [1], [2]. While the French dip is a signature, opinions on its quality vary; however, the chocolate cake—a 24-layer masterpiece—is consistently highlighted as a standout dessert [2], [3], [5].
The 24-layer chocolate cake is a fan favorite, and many diners also recommend the massive French dip sandwiches and the comically large French toast [2], [3].
Overall feedback is strongly positive, with diners frequently citing the restaurant as a repeat-visit favorite for its lively vibe and consistent quality [3], [4], [6]. While the French dip can be divisive compared to specialized competitors, the generous portions and indulgent desserts generally win over the crowd [2], [3].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01french dip9 mentions
- 02chocolate cake5 mentions
Caveats
Reservations are considered essential, especially for busy holiday periods like Thanksgiving [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MAISON PICKLE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Restaurants You Keep Going Back To Any
"A former favorite."
PositiveFrom post: Best Food Around Columbia Universitylooking For
"A suggested restaurant near Columbia University."
NeutralFrom post: What Do You All Think Is The Per Se Of Nyc Sports
"A user enthusiastically praises their french dip sandwich."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurant Week Where Have You Gone And Was It
"The diner considers this a repeat and very good Restaurant Week choice."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Good Restaurant Recommendations Near
"Recommended as part of a list of local dining options."
Positive