TLDR
Massive American comfort food classics served in a bustling, high-vibe atmosphere. Renowned for over-the-top desserts and oversized brunch portions.
Details
A staple of the Upper West Side, this American comfort food destination is famous for its gargantuan portions and indulgent menu [10], [19]. The establishment is frequently recognized for its show-stopping desserts, including a legendary 24-layer chocolate cake [2], [11], [36]. While the menu is generally well-regarded, some patrons find specific offerings like the French dip to be divisive compared to other city standouts [4], [5], [26].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on indulgent American comfort food, with standout dishes like comically large French toast, savory patty melts, and an iconic 24-layer chocolate cake [10], [11], [19], [27]. While their French dip is a frequently discussed menu item, reviews vary from high praise to suggestions that it is merely average [3], [4], [6], [26].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended items include the 24-layer chocolate cake, the massive French toast, and the savory patty melt [11], [19], [27]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •french dip(9)
- •chocolate cake(5)
Customer Sentiment
Overall feedback is generally positive, with diners frequently citing the restaurant as a go-to for hearty meals and a memorable atmosphere [1], [9], [29]. While the experience is largely praised, some guests have expressed mixed feelings regarding the consistency of their signature sandwiches [4], [5], [26].
Caveats
Diners should be prepared for gargantuan portion sizes that can be difficult to finish alone [10], [19]. Additionally, consensus on the French dip is split, with some frequenters preferring alternatives at other restaurants [4], [5], [26].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MAISON PICKLE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Restaurant Week Where Have You Gone And Was It
"The diner considers this a repeat and very good Restaurant Week choice."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Good Restaurant Recommendations Near
"Recommended as part of a list of local dining options."
PositiveFrom post: Tasting And Ranking Of Seven Chocolate Cakes In
"Prefers the Oreo icebox cake over their chocolate layer cake."
NeutralFrom post: Tasting And Ranking Of Seven Chocolate Cakes In
"Heard good things about the chocolate cake."
PositiveFrom post: Traditional Thanksgiving Dinner In New York City
"The author's neighbors frequently choose this location for Thanksgiving; reservations are necessary via Resy."
Positive