Indulge in hearty American comfort food, from giant French dips to a legendary 24-layer cake. A go-to for decadent rolls & mac and cheese.
This American comfort food spot, sister to Jacob's Pickles, is a family-friendly destination on the Upper West Side. Known for its hearty dishes, it offers satisfying options like patty melts, pull-apart cinnamon buns, and French toast topped with hot honey chicken cutlets. It's a great place for a fulfilling meal.
This American restaurant is celebrated for its comfort food, with particular highlights including the French dip sandwich, appetizer rolls, mac and cheese, and an exceptionally popular 24-layer cake. While many rave about the decadent flavors and large portions, a few critics find the food to be mediocre or not living up to the hype.
"The French dip sandwich is frequently recommended, as are the appetizer rolls, mac and cheese, and particularly the highly praised 24-layer cake."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, often praising the indulgent food and generous portions. However, some find the restaurant to be mediocre or overrated.
Important Note
Some customers find the restaurant to be mediocre or overrated, and there are dissenting opinions regarding the quality and authenticity of certain dishes like the French dip.
"Maison Pickle is listed as a frequently visited restaurant."
Positive"Maison Pickle is listed as a frequently visited restaurant."
Positive"The user highlights the honey butter "break bread" from Maison pickle as a standout item."
Positive"The user states that Maison Pickle is "worse" than Jacob's Pickles, implying an even more negative experience or quality compared to the already criticized restaurant."
Negative"The user listed Maison Pickle as one of the places they enjoy for chocolate cake."
Positive"The chocolate cake at Maison Pickle is ridiculously moist and very large."
Positive"The user states that Maison Pickle's 24-layer cake is legitimate."
Positive
