NYC's oldest family-run bar serving up some of the city's best no-fuss burgers & crispy tater tots in a classic neighborhood pub setting.
This Chelsea institution has been a family-run fixture since 1936, offering a genuine neighborhood pub experience. It's known for its unpretentious atmosphere and classic American comfort food, with a particular emphasis on their highly-regarded burgers. The spot also boasts crispy tater tots and a hearty chili, making it a go-to for a no-fuss, satisfying meal.
The food here is classic American pub fare, with a strong emphasis on burgers, which are frequently recommended. Crispy tater tots and a meaty chili are also highlighted as popular and satisfying options. While overwhelmingly positive, one opinion suggested the food might be a bit heavy.
"The 'pop pop burger' is frequently recommended, often paired with crispy tater tots. Other praised items include classic burgers and chili."
Overall, customers have a very positive sentiment towards this establishment, frequently praising its burgers and classic pub fare. Some consider it a must-visit for its authentic atmosphere and consistently good food.
Important Note
Some users feel this establishment is not suitable for first-time visitors to NYC and is a 'horrible dive bar' that is not particularly upscale.
"This user consistently names Peter McManus as their answer for a frequented restaurant, highlighting the medium-rare burger with tots."
Positive"The commenter suggests the Pop Pop burger at McManus with tots and a Miller Lite, recommending to go on Sunday to see Oscar."
Positive"A commenter recommended Peter McManus Cafe, specifically mentioning the 'pop pop burger' and tater tots as favorites, and praising the bar's atmosphere."
Positive"McManus is a favorite spot for the user, who enjoys its burger and the lively atmosphere with a diverse crowd and fun bartenders, specifically mentioning Oscar as the best."
Positive"In response to criticism, the original recommender stated Pete McManus has always been a dive bar and is a firefighter hangout, which they personally like."
Neutral"This commenter strongly advised against Pete McManus, stating it has become a horrible dive bar."
Negative"Pete McManus on 7th Ave and 19th St was mentioned as a true speakeasy but not particularly upscale."
Neutral"Peter McManus Cafe is recommended as a potential spot."
Positive"This user stated that Peter McManus is great and recommended hanging out at the bar."
Positive"Peter McManus was suggested as another spot for a 'pop pop burger'."
Positive"This establishment was mentioned as a potential dinner option for first-time visitors to NYC, located near Hell's Kitchen/Hudson Yards. The user is considering it among other places."
Neutral"The user agrees with previous comments that the initially listed restaurants, such as Peter McManus Cafe, are not good options and suggests exploring other places."
Negative"The user strongly advises against the restaurants mentioned, including Peter McManus Cafe, stating they are not good and are often promoted through discount platforms like Groupon because they lack appeal."
Negative"The user suggests that the listed restaurants, including Peter McManus Cafe, will likely leave a visitor unimpressed with NYC's culinary scene and advises against them."
Negative"While agreeing with the suggestion of Peter McManus, there's a humorous concern about the potential health impact of the meal, implying it might be heavy."
Neutral"This is a suggestion for Peter McManus, located at 19th St and 7th Ave."
Neutral"This user enthusiastically recommends "POP POP" at McManus."
Positive"McManus is recommended for a burger."
Positive
