Authentic homemade Italian w/ great wine selection. Known for incredible pasta & seafood dishes. Some say decor could be improved.
Discover Celeste, a beloved Italian gem nestled in Manhattan's Upper West Side. This restaurant is lauded for its authentic, homemade Italian fare and impressive wine selection, making it a top choice for many locals. While often praised for its delicious pasta and seafood dishes, some patrons have noted that the interior decor could be more inviting.
This Italian restaurant is highly recommended for its authentic, homemade dishes, particularly pasta and seafood. The extensive wine selection is also a highlight. While most feedback is positive, one user noted aggressive review solicitation and another described a very poor dining experience.
"While specific dishes aren't frequently mentioned, customers rave about the homemade pasta and seafood options."
Customer feedback is largely positive, with many praising the authentic homemade Italian food and wine selection. However, a few comments mention that the interior decor is lacking.
Important Note
One reviewer mentioned aggressive review solicitation and another strongly disliked the restaurant, calling it the worst meal in years.
"This user gave a negative mention to Celeste, citing aggressive review solicitation."
Negative"This user strongly disliked Celeste, calling it the worst restaurant meal they've had in years and accusing them of harvesting good reviews."
Negative"This user stated that Celeste is excellent and Chef Carmine is a gem."
Positive"Celeste is mentioned as one of the commenter's top ten most frequented spots in the area."
Positive"Celeste is listed as a place to eat."
Neutral"Celeste was highly recommended for its incredible homemade Italian food and great wine selection."
Positive"Celeste is suggested as an Italian option for breakfast on Day 5, if the user wants to deviate from bagels."
Neutral"Recommends Celeste as a personal favorite that could meet the diners' needs. However, the author notes that the interior decor is lacking."
Positive"A user suggested Celeste as an alternative option for Italian seafood."
Positive
