Next.js logo

OTTO'S SHRUNKEN HEAD

Updated

Phone: (212) 228-2240

Address: 538 EAST 14 STREET 10009

TLDR

Sticky floors, beer-scented air, and tiki drinks that are "only sort of on fire." An East Village dive bar for those who love the theme, even if it's a bit rough around the edges.

Reddit Sentiment for OTTO'S SHRUNKEN HEAD(based on 7 Reddit opinions)

29% Positive14% Neutral43% Negative

Tags

american 3cocktail 3bar 3tiki drink 3View All

Neighborhoods

East Village

Recent Articles

Details

Established in 2002, this East Village institution is a beloved tiki bar known for its commitment to theme, despite its dive bar charm. It offers a sticky, beer-scented atmosphere and a piña colada that's "only sort of on fire." While some find it "terrible," its dedicated following appreciates its authentic, no-frills tiki experience.

Food Overview

The food menu isn't specified, but the restaurant is primarily known for its tiki drinks, particularly the piña colada which is noted as being 'only sort of on fire.' While some recommend the tiki drinks, others find them to be outright bad.

Highlights / Recommended

"The restaurant is recommended for its tiki drinks, with the scorpion bowl and piña colada being specifically mentioned. While some find the drinks to be a highlight, others have had negative experiences."

Customer Sentiment

Customer feedback is mixed, with some enjoying the unique tiki drinks and lively atmosphere, while others find the drinks to be subpar and the establishment to be a 'terrible' dive bar.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About OTTO'S SHRUNKEN HEAD

This post recommends Otto's Shrunken Head for scorpion bowls, noting it's the closest to a New England-style experience and satisfies the craving, though it may not be as cheap as some Chinese spots. Other comments also mention Otto's for its tiki drinks.
Otto's Shrunken Head is mentioned for its delicious and interesting Tiki drinks, which generally have a base of fruit juice and contribute to a lively vibe.
Otto's Shrunken Head is recommended as an addition to a bar crawl in the East Village.
Multiple commenters express negative opinions about Otto's Shrunken Head's tiki drinks, with one comparing it unfavorably to other tiki bars and another stating the drinks are 'outright bad.' Another commenter describes it as a 'tiki-flavored dive bar' with prices not significantly cheaper than more upscale options.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Where To Find A Good Scorpion Bowl In The City

"Otto's Shrunken Head is recommended as the closest to a New England-style Scorpion Bowl in the city. While not as cheap as some Chinese spots, it satisfies the craving."

Positive
Apr 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where To Find A Good Scorpion Bowl In The City

"This is a short confirmation for Otto's Shrunken Head."

Neutral
Apr 10, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where To Find A Good Scorpion Bowl In The City

"This is a recommendation for Otto's Shrunken Head in the East Village for scorpion bowls."

Positive
Apr 10, 2026View Comment →

From post: Threeday Food Itinerary Any Duds

"The commenter asserts that Otto's tiki drinks are outright bad."

Negative
May 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Threeday Food Itinerary Any Duds

"Otto's is characterized as essentially a tiki-flavored dive bar, noting that its prices are not significantly cheaper than more upscale tiki establishments."

Negative
May 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Threeday Food Itinerary Any Duds

"The commenter expresses a preference for Paradise Lost over Otto's and Sunken Harbor Club for tiki drinks."

Negative
May 22, 2025View Comment →