Old-school NYC diner, real vintage vibe, right by the High Line. Generous breakfast combos.
This old-school diner, situated conveniently near the High Line, offers a genuine, uncrowded slice of classic New York. While the ambiance is praised for its authentic diner feel, the food is described as fitting the style, with a particularly recommended generously portioned breakfast combo.
The diner offers classic American diner food. The breakfast combo is a recommended, generously portioned option. While the food is generally considered average and fitting the diner aesthetic, it's not the primary draw for many.
"The breakfast combo, featuring eggs, sausages, and French toast, is highlighted as a generously portioned and shareable option that provides good value."
Customers appreciate the authentic, uncrowded old-school diner atmosphere and the generous breakfast combo. However, the food quality is noted as being average, fitting the diner style.
Important Note
One commenter expressed concern about the diner potentially closing.
"Star on 18 is mentioned as a diner, alongside the now-closed Ritz (Tramway diner)."
Positive"Mentioned that Star on 18 serves their waffles thin, similar to the style in the post."
Positive"Star On 18 offers a quintessential diner experience with an old ambiance, though the food quality is described as 'exquisitely mid' (meaning average/mediocre but fitting the diner style)."
Neutral"Star On 18 is a great old-school diner next to the High Line, offering a substantial and shareable breakfast combo for $15.99."
Positive"The commenter recommends Star on 18, highlighting its location at 10th Ave. and 18th St. and describing it as a real old-school diner with no crowds, though expressing fear of its potential closure."
Positive
