Next.js logo

UNDERGROUND PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (212) 425-4442

Address: 2 WILLIAM STREET 10004

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Authentic NY pizza, no frills. Get the Sicilian Everything slice!

Reddit Sentiment for UNDERGROUND PIZZA(based on 2 Reddit opinions)

100% Positive

Tags

italian 3pizza 3View All

Neighborhoods

Financial District

Details

Nestled in the heart of FiDi, this pizza joint is a must-visit for authentic New York-style slices. Critics rave about their no-frills approach, highlighting the classic NY slices and their much-loved Sicilian Everything pizza. It's a spot where quality ingredients and traditional techniques shine, offering a true taste of NYC.

Food Overview

This establishment specializes in classic New York-style pizza, receiving high praise for its authentic flavors and quality. The Sicilian Everything pizza is frequently recommended as a standout dish, embodying the restaurant's no-nonsense approach to delicious pizza.

Highlights / Recommended

"The 'Sicilian Everything' pizza is highly recommended as a top-tier supreme pizza choice."

Customer Sentiment

Customers consistently praise the authentic New York-style pizza, with a particular highlight being the Sicilian Everything slice.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About UNDERGROUND PIZZA

/r/FoodNYC/comments/1jiqn7n/shoutout_to_the_unhyped_independent_neighborhood/
A Reddit user specifically rated Underground Pizza in FiDi a perfect '10/10', suggesting a highly positive experience.
Best supreme combo pizza slice in NYC?
A user highly recommends the 'Sicilian Everything' pizza at Underground Pizza in FiDi, calling it their favorite supreme pizza.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1jo96cr/financial_district_best_spots/
Underground Pizza is recommended for its classic New York pizza slices, with an explicit mention of their straightforward approach and 'no truffle BS'.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Best Supreme Combo Pizza Slice In Nyc

"This user's favorite supreme pizza is the Sicilian Everything at Underground Pizza in Fidi, which they find to be really good."

Positive
Mar 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Financial District Best Spots

"Recommended for classic NY pizza slices, explicitly mentioning "no truffle BS"."

Positive
Mar 31, 2025View Comment →

More in Financial District

See all

More italian in NYC

See all