TLDR
Upscale FiDi classic featuring elite dry-aged steaks and an intimate, dark, luxurious atmosphere. Ideal for professional entertaining and serious martini fans.
Reddit Sentiment for HARRY'S / ULYSSES'(based on 16 Reddit opinions)
Details
Located in the heart of the Financial District, this upscale steakhouse offers an intimate, dark, and luxurious atmosphere perfect for professional dinners or special occasions [2], [11]. Known primarily for its elite, dry-aged steaks, the restaurant consistently earns high praise for its classic American fare and exceptional cocktails [2], [11], [13]. While the majority of guests appreciate the sophisticated environment, some diners find the service to be somewhat impersonal [11].
Food Overview
The menu is centered around high-quality American steakhouse fare, with the ribeye, filet, and 28-day dry-aged porterhouse being particularly standout dishes [6], [11], [12]. Diners also highly recommend the tableside caesar salad, polenta fries, and the beef wellington [4], [11]. While the steak is widely considered some of the best in New York City, some patrons have found other menu items like the bolognese to be disappointing [8], [11].
Highlights / Recommended
"The dry-aged steaks, specifically the ribeye and porterhouse, are frequently cited as elite, alongside the tableside caesar and polenta fries [11], [12], [13]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •beef wellington(2)
- •filet(2)
- •ribeye(2)
Customer Sentiment
Overall sentiment is highly positive, with guests frequently praising the restaurant's immaculate vibes and top-tier steak quality [2], [11], [13]. While most experiences are seamless, some diners have noted impersonal service or occasional inconsistency with non-steak menu items [11], [12].
Caveats
The restaurant is generally not recommended for those seeking a well-done steak, and the atmosphere is described as quite dark and quiet, which may not suit every group's preference [11], [14].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About HARRY'S / ULYSSES'
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Steakhousesteak Recommendations For Visitors Who
"The user advises against going here if one wants a well-done steak, despite recommending other dishes."
NegativeFrom post: Anybody Try The 26 Lobster Deal Ulysses Bar Fidi
"Mentioned as the establishment sharing a kitchen with Ulysses Bar, implying high quality."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Recommendations For Cocktailfocused
"Recommended for having a great martini."
PositiveFrom post: Heres How Strip House Carne Mare Harrys Compare
"The commenter agreed that Harry's serves an elite steak, potentially the best in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Heres How Strip House Carne Mare Harrys Compare
"The commenter stated that Harry's dry-aged steaks are excellent, but found most other dishes to be mediocre."
NegativeFrom post: Heres How Strip House Carne Mare Harrys Compare
"The reviewer visited Harry's for their birthday in December. They described the ribeye and filet as top-notch and their Old Fashioned as the best they'd had in the city. The tableside caesar and polenta fries were highlights, with other classic sides being very good. The atmosphere was intimate, classic, quiet, dark, and luxurious, with polite but impersonal service. Pros were the steak and sides, and classic atmosphere, while cons were the dark ambiance and impersonal service."
NegativeFrom post: Harrys Fidi 28day Dryaged Porterhouse For Two
"In response to a question about recommendations for a birthday dinner, this user suggests Harry's and also mentions checking out Hawksmoor for a potentially better birthday vibe."
PositiveFrom post: Harrys Fidi 28day Dryaged Porterhouse For Two
"Replying to a question about the porterhouse at Harry's, this user states it was 'Phenomenal'. They also mention that for a birthday, Hawksmoor might be a good alternative."
PositiveFrom post: Harrys Fidi 28day Dryaged Porterhouse For Two
"In response to a question about the price of the porterhouse at Harry's, this user states it costs $195."
NeutralFrom post: Harrys Fidi 28day Dryaged Porterhouse For Two
"In response to a comment about Harry's, this user states that their brunch is underrated."
PositiveFrom post: Harrys Fidi 28day Dryaged Porterhouse For Two
"This user recalls eating a 'great' and 'yummy' beef Wellington at Harry's."
PositiveFrom post: Harrys Fidi 28day Dryaged Porterhouse For Two
"This user mentions that Harry's is one of their favorites in the Financial District, along with Delmonico's and Capitol Grill. They have never been disappointed with the food or service there."
PositiveFrom post: Harrys Fidi 28day Dryaged Porterhouse For Two
"This user asks about the quality of Harry's, as they were previously disgusted by the bolognese and have not returned."
NegativeFrom post: Harrys Fidi 28day Dryaged Porterhouse For Two
"A long-time resident of FiDi shares that Harry's has immaculate vibes, great cocktails, and good to really good food. It's a great place for entertaining clients when the firm is paying."
PositiveFrom post: Best Walkins In Lower Manhattan
"The user recommends Harry's as a restaurant in the Financial District that should be fine to walk into during weekdays."
PositiveFrom post: Celebrating Birthday Alone In Manhattan Good
"This restaurant offers large steaks but also a hanger steak sized for one person. The commenter also confirms it's acceptable to take leftovers home."
Positive