Historic NYC steakhouse, America's first fine dining est. 1837. Known for iconic dishes & classic ambiance.
Visit Delmonico's in the Financial District, America's first fine dining restaurant, for a taste of old New York with its pristine seafood and top cuts of steak.
Amber Sutherland-Namako reviews Delmonico's, an iconic New York steakhouse. Despite minor initial issues, the restaurant offers a refined dining experience with excellent steaks and classic cocktails in a beautifully restored setting.
Delmonico's, a historic New York steakhouse established in 1837, is celebrated as America's first fine dining restaurant. It offers a refined experience with expertly prepared steaks, classic cocktails, and a rich culinary heritage, having originated iconic dishes like the Delmonico steak and Baked Alaska. While some minor disorganization was noted upon its recent reopening, the overall consensus points to a pleasant and classic steakhouse experience.
Delmonico's is renowned for its high-quality American steakhouse fare, with steaks, particularly the dry-aged rib-eye and filet mignon, being frequently recommended. The restaurant is also credited with inventing iconic dishes such as the Delmonico steak, Lobster Newberg, and Baked Alaska, some of which remain on the menu. While most feedback on food is positive, a few reviewers found certain dishes like the signature Delmonico steak or Baked Alaska to be less impressive than expected, and one negative review cited a lack of flavor in their steaks.
Customers generally have a positive view of Delmonico's, praising its classic steakhouse experience and historical significance. While some mention minor service or organizational issues, the quality of steaks and overall ambiance are frequently highlighted.
"Delmonico's was described as 'elite' and recommended as a dining option."
Positive"This restaurant was noted as a place where children have been seen, suggesting it might be family-friendly."
Neutral"The commenter questioned the original negative review, pointing out that the prix fixe menu price should have been known and that the issues raised about the table and food were not necessarily unique to the reviewer's ethnicity and were standard for a prix fixe holiday meal."
Neutral"The commenter had a negative experience last year, citing poor table assignment despite arriving early, small portions of Delmonico and ribeye steaks lacking flavor, and feeling it was a tourist trap, particularly noting perceived differential treatment as an Asian diner in NYC."
Negative"The commenter found the experience amazing last year but noted that the house wine was very expensive at $33 per glass."
Neutral"The commenter stated that the turkey at Delmonico's was also good."
Positive"The commenter provided pricing details for the Thanksgiving prix fixe at Delmonico's: $150 per person, with a $180 per person upcharge for the ribeye, and linked to the menu."
Neutral"The commenter visited Delmonico's after it reopened and was pleasantly surprised by how much they enjoyed it."
Positive"The commenter expressed a preference for the Delmonico's rib eye over turkey."
Positive"The commenter suggested that people working on Thanksgiving deserve a hefty tip, acknowledging the holiday pricing."
Neutral"The commenter had a similar meal and was displeased with a $40 credit card fee for a group of four, leading to a total bill of $1074."
Neutral"The commenter expressed enthusiasm about visiting Delmonico's in February after hearing about the delicious-sounding meal."
Positive"The commenter described the Thanksgiving prix fixe meal as very good and perfectly cooked, mentioning peppercorn sauce, mashed potatoes, stuffing, roasted carrots, and mushrooms."
Positive"Delmonico's is recommended as a suitable choice for a special meal."
Positive"This user suggests Delmonico's, stating that they invented the wedge salad."
Positive"Delmonico's is suggested as a potential dining choice."
Positive"The commenter agrees with the 'Shining' comparison for Delmonico's bar."
Negative"The bar vibe at Delmonico's is compared to a set from 'The Shining'."
Negative"Delmonico's is an excellent but pricey option, with potential difficulty getting a table on weekdays."
Positive"Delmonico's was listed as a dining recommendation."
Neutral
