NYC's original fine dining institution. Upscale American steakhouse w/ historic charm & iconic dishes like Delmonico steak & Baked Alaska.
Visit Delmonico's in the Financial District, America's first fine dining restaurant, for a taste of old New York with its pristine seafood and top cuts of steak.
Amber Sutherland-Namako reviews Delmonico's, an iconic New York steakhouse. Despite minor initial issues, the restaurant offers a refined dining experience with excellent steaks and classic cocktails in a beautifully restored setting.
This iconic American steakhouse, established in 1837, is renowned as America's first fine dining establishment. It offers a refined experience with a focus on high-quality steaks and classic dishes, all served in an elegant, historic setting. Delmonico's is celebrated for its contributions to culinary history, including the invention of the Delmonico steak, Lobster Newberg, and Baked Alaska.
Delmonico's is a classic American steakhouse celebrated for its high-quality steaks, with the dry-aged bone-in rib-eye and filet mignon frequently highlighted. The restaurant also boasts a history of iconic dishes like Lobster Newberg and Baked Alaska, though opinions on the latter are mixed. Appetizers like jumbo prawns and crab cakes receive praise, as do sides such as creamed spinach and mashed potatoes. Some diners have found specific dishes, like the newer version of Lobster Newburg or the Baked Alaska, to be not worth the price or simply 'meh'.
"The dry-aged bone-in rib-eye and filet mignon are frequently praised. Other highly recommended items include the Caesar salad, crab cakes, mashed potatoes ('Pomme Puree'), and the bread and butter. The 'Delmonico' cut ribeye is also noted as a good option."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Delmonico's, praising its steaks, classic cocktails, and historic ambiance. While some experiences note minor service inconsistencies or find certain dishes like the Baked Alaska overrated, the overall consensus points to a solid and enjoyable dining experience.
Important Note
Some diners have found the service inconsistent or noted that certain dishes, like the Baked Alaska, are not worth the extra cost. There are also mixed reviews on the current iteration of Lobster Newburg compared to its historical version.
"In response to a negative review of Delmonico's price, this user stated Delmonico's is expensive and suggested Keen's for its King's cut prime rib as a better value."
Neutral"This user found Delmonico's to be disappointing and expensive, feeling the food quality did not justify the price and that better steakhouses exist in the city at a similar price point."
Negative"This user stated they put themselves on a waitlist for Delmonico's."
Neutral"This comment agreed with the recommendation for Delmonico's for a special occasion and suggested arriving early to get a seat at the bar."
Positive"The user strongly recommended Delmonico's, stating the food is absolutely amazing."
Positive"Delmonico's is characterized as a fancy steakhouse that feels more upscale than Gallagher's Steakhouse."
Neutral"Prefers Delmonico's for steak over Keens."
Positive"Considers Delmonico's their favorite steak in the city."
Positive"Recommends Del Friscos for fantastic steak, a seafood tower, and service."
Positive"Delmonico's is suggested as a dining option."
Positive"Delmonico's is suggested as a dining option."
Positive"Has not yet made it to Delmonico's but lists it as a potential option."
Neutral"Found Delmonico's to be significantly better for steak compared to Keens."
Positive"DelMonico's was suggested as a dinner option with open reservations for a date night. The commenter also shared personal experience about feeling too exhausted after exams to go out."
Neutral"A diner found the Baked Alaska at Delmonico's to be a bit disappointing and it did not meet their expectations."
Negative"This comment recommends Delmonico's for its Baked Alaska."
Positive"Restaurant Week can be hit or miss, but steakhouses like Delmonico's offer good value. Their signature steak, normally $86, is part of an $89 Restaurant Week deal that includes an appetizer and dessert."
Positive"Delmonico's restaurant week menu is described as unbeatable and is priced at $60."
Positive"The user recommended Delmonico's and mentioned having dined in their board room. They also noted that other private rooms might be available."
Neutral"Correction: Delmonico’s now only offers lunch. My apologies."
Neutral
