Historic NYC tavern dating to 1762 w/ George Washington ties. Offers a trip back in time, with some dishes praised & others deemed average. Great for history buffs & drinks.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Fraunces Tavern, a historic Financial District institution dating back to 1762, noting its George Washington connections and reliable, albeit unexceptional and pricey, pub fare.
Step back in time at Fraunces Tavern, NYC's oldest bar, steeped in Revolutionary War history and frequented by George Washington himself. While the ambiance transports you to another era, the food is a mixed bag, with some dishes like the chicken pot pie and burgers receiving praise, while others are described as unexceptional or even bad. It's a place to soak in history and enjoy a drink, perhaps more than a culinary destination.
Fraunces Tavern offers American and pub fare, with some dishes like the New England Clam Chowder, Irish Breakfast, and Chicken Pot Pie receiving positive mentions. However, multiple reviews suggest the food quality can be inconsistent, with some diners finding it unexceptional, bland, or even 'very bad.' The Tavern Burger and its sweet potato fries are noted as being good, while the Lobster Mac & Cheese is described as somewhat bland. The establishment is often recommended more for its historical atmosphere and drinks than for a standout culinary experience.
"The chicken pot pie is frequently recommended, especially for colder weather. The Tavern Burger with its sweet potato fries also receives positive mentions, as does the New England Clam Chowder and the Irish Breakfast."
Customer feedback on Fraunces Tavern is divided, with many highlighting its immense historical significance and appealing ambiance. However, opinions on the food range from praise for specific dishes like chicken pot pie and burgers to criticism that the food is unmemorable, bland, or overpriced.
Important Note
While the historical significance and ambiance are highly praised, multiple reviews suggest that the food quality can be inconsistent and is often considered unexceptional or overpriced. Some diners have had negative experiences with specific dishes like burgers.
"The food at Fraunces Tavern is described as very good."
Positive"Fraunces Tavern in Fidi is recommended for its Irish short rib porter pie, which is described as fantastic. The owners are Irish and several Irish menu items are available."
Positive"Although not a local, the commenter found Fraunces to be a fun experience."
Positive"Fraunces is considered good for its historical aspect but not for its food."
Neutral"Fraunces is noted as being less stuffy than Harry's and offering better value, suitable for a snack."
Neutral"Fraunces is described as having great food and a casual atmosphere, fitting within a $100 budget, and is a good option for a drink after work."
Positive"Fraunces is preferred over Harry's due to its food quality, despite Harry's potentially being more visually appealing."
Positive"The commenter agrees that Fraunces is a fun and historical place for a drink, even if not a primary dining destination."
Neutral"While Fraunces has interesting menu items like Scotch eggs, the food itself is considered lackluster, making it more of a touristy spot for ambiance and a drink rather than a meal."
Neutral"Fraunces is suggested for history and a bite, fitting into a plan that includes other nearby historical and musical venues."
Neutral"For an out-of-towner, Fraunces is recommended for its historical significance and a bite to eat, offering a different experience than Harry's."
Neutral"A place called London & Martin, described as similar to a London pub but possibly a sports bar, is mentioned as being near Fraunces Tavern. The Winslow is also recommended for its extensive gin selection and British bar food."
Neutral"The Clocktower is mentioned, which may or may not have Scotch eggs."
Neutral"The piano bar upstairs at Fraunces Tavern is recommended for solo diners as it offers walk-in seats."
Positive"Commenter recommended Fraunces Tavern for its excellent whiskey collection and a special whiskey room that offers a fancy vibe."
Positive"Fraunces Tavern was mentioned as a place to try for group vibes on a birthday."
Positive"This user expressed happiness that Fraunces Tavern was mentioned early in the comments."
Positive"This user asked if Fraunces Tavern was a recommendation."
Neutral"This user thought a photo might be of Fraunces Tavern and loves the place."
Positive"This user agreed that the tavern and its surroundings at Fraunces Tavern are great for Christmas coziness, noting the photo might be of Fraunces."
Positive
