Brooklyn's hidden gem for authentic Italian-American classics & exceptional pizza, a beloved neighborhood spot with a welcoming vibe.
This Brooklyn pizzeria offers a genuine taste of Italian-American comfort food, with many praising its classic red sauce dishes. It's a family-friendly spot with a relaxed sports bar atmosphere, making it a great neighborhood gem. The bar pie is noted as a good option if you're considering a whole pie.
Carmine's Pizzeria is celebrated for its classic Italian-American fare, with a strong emphasis on pizza. The 'bar pie' is specifically mentioned as a good choice for a whole pie. Customers appreciate the traditional red sauce dishes and the overall comforting and authentic taste of the food.
"The bar pie is a recommended dish, particularly if you are looking to order a whole pie."
Customers rave about the authentic Italian-American cuisine, particularly the pizza and red sauce dishes. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff contribute to a positive overall experience.
Important Note
The bar pie is recommended only if considering a whole pie.
"Carmine's, located a short subway ride into Brooklyn, is described as a restaurant with great, inexpensive American Italian food and sports bar vibes, suitable for all ages."
Positive"Carmine's on Graham Ave in Williamsburg is consistently good for red sauce Italian, with loyal staff indicating good management."
Positive"Carmine's on Graham Ave is recommended to be added to the pizza list."
Negative"Carmine's Pizzeria in Williamsburg is praised as a 2nd generation Italian-owned spot with an incredible slice selection and a preferred off-the-radar spot, also noting its spaciousness and accessibility for travelers."
Positive"The original poster is already considering Bernie's and Carmine's in Williamsburg."
Neutral"Recommends Carmines bar pie in Brooklyn, but only if considering a full pie."
Positive"A commenter expressed their love for Carmines on Graham Ave."
Positive"A commenter praised Carmines in Williamsburg as 'Great utility pizza!'"
Positive"Mentioning Rome To Brooklyn, a commenter noted other great pizzerias nearby, including Carmine's."
Positive
