Next.js logo

CARMINE'S PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (718) 782-9659

Address: 358 GRAHAM AVENUE 11211

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Lively Brooklyn pizza joint w/ great, inexpensive American Italian food & loyal staff. Sports bar vibes, suitable for all ages.

Reddit Sentiment for CARMINE'S PIZZA(based on 6 Reddit opinions)

83% Positive

Achievements and Accolades

Achievement logo

Tags

italian 3italian-american 3american 2pizza 4sfincione 2View All

Neighborhoods

Williamsburg

Details

Carmine's on Graham Ave is a highly recommended pizza spot in Brooklyn, praised for its great and inexpensive American Italian food. The restaurant offers a lively atmosphere, suitable for all ages, and is known for consistently good red sauce Italian dishes. Loyal staff and good management contribute to its positive reputation.

Food Overview

Carmine's is celebrated for its great pizzas and chicken parm [1]. It's also noted for being consistently good for red sauce Italian dishes, with some users specifically recommending their onion slice, which they suggest might be a spiritual successor to sfincione [2], [3].

Highlights / Recommended

"The pizzas and chicken parm at Carmine's are highlighted as great options. Additionally, their onion slice is noted as a potential standout, with some comparing it favorably to sfincione [1], [2]."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive view of Carmine's, highlighting the quality of its American Italian food and the welcoming atmosphere suitable for all ages.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About CARMINE'S PIZZA

/r/FoodNYC/comments/1tx16jf/looking_for_the_best_restaurants_that_would_show/
This user highlights Carmine's for its great pizzas and chicken parm, also mentioning its electric atmosphere suitable for watching games.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1ls7i6q/my_2week_nyc_list_thoughts/
Carmine's on Graham Ave is recommended to be added to a list of pizza places.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1s5dmot/a_sfincione_quest_bens_soho_amuni_bay_ridge/
A user praises Carmine's for its onion slice, suggesting it's similar to sfincione and is a consistently good Italian-American option.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1qokib4/red_sauce_italian/
Carmine's is consistently good for red sauce Italian, with loyal staff suggesting good management.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1qs68zh/sports_restaurants_that_will_allow_underaged/
Described as having great, inexpensive American Italian food and sports bar vibes, Carmine's is suitable for all ages.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Looking For The Best Restaurants That Would Show

"Carmine's in Williamsburg offers great pizzas and chicken parm, providing more than just bar food options. The atmosphere is described as electric, making it a good place to watch games."

Positive
Jun 4, 2026View Comment →

From post: A Sfincione Quest Bens Soho Amuni Bay Ridge

"Clarifying a previous comment, this user believes their favorite onion slice at Carmine's might be a spiritual successor to sfincione, though they aren't always sure if it's available."

Positive
Mar 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: A Sfincione Quest Bens Soho Amuni Bay Ridge

"This user states that Carmine's in Williamsburg makes good sfincione."

Positive
Mar 27, 2026View Comment →

From post: Sports Restaurants That Will Allow Underaged

"Carmine's, located a short subway ride into Brooklyn, is described as a restaurant with great, inexpensive American Italian food and sports bar vibes, suitable for all ages."

Positive
Feb 1, 2026View Comment →

From post: Red Sauce Italian

"Carmine's on Graham Ave in Williamsburg is consistently good for red sauce Italian, with loyal staff indicating good management."

Positive
Jan 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: My 2week Nyc List Thoughts

"Carmine's on Graham Ave is recommended to be added to the pizza list."

Negative
Jul 6, 2025View Comment →