Next.js logo

CARMINE'S PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (718) 782-9659

Address: 358 GRAHAM AVENUE 11211

TLDR

A beloved, unhyped neighborhood pizza joint, serving up classic Italian-American slices & pies with a spacious, accessible vibe.

Reddit Sentiment for CARMINE'S PIZZA(based on 7 Reddit opinions)

71% Positive14% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Tags

italian 9italian-american 6american 3pizza 8italian 2sfincione 2View All

Neighborhoods

Williamsburg

Details

Carmine's Pizzeria, a second-generation Italian-owned establishment, is a beloved neighborhood gem known for its exceptional pizza. It's praised for its spacious atmosphere and accessibility, making it a reliable spot for a classic slice or a full pie. Customers often highlight it as a great utility pizza option and a preferred, off-the-radar choice for authentic Italian-American fare.

Food Overview

This pizzeria is celebrated for its excellent pizza, with specific mentions of its 'bar pie' and 'onion slice' which some believe to be a spiritual successor to sfincione. It's described as a great utility pizza and a go-to spot for reliable Italian-American cuisine.

Highlights / Recommended

"Customers specifically praise the pizza, including the 'bar pie' and 'onion slice,' with some suggesting it's a great option for a classic slice or a full pie."

Customer Sentiment

Customers highly recommend this Italian-American pizzeria, praising its classic pizza and authentic atmosphere.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About CARMINE'S PIZZA

Carmine's Pizzeria in Williamsburg is highlighted as a 2nd generation Italian-owned spot with an amazing selection of pizza slices, often considered an off-the-radar gem.
In a discussion about great neighborhood pizzerias, Carmine's in Williamsburg was praised as a 'Great utility pizza!' option.
A commenter mentions Carmine's in Williamsburg for its good sfincione, later clarifying that their favorite onion slice might be a spiritual successor to sfincione.
Another commenter expressed their fondness for Carmine's on Graham Ave.
Carmine's bar pie in Brooklyn is recommended, though with the caveat that it's best considered as a full pie.
Carmine's is described as a place with great, inexpensive American Italian food and sports bar vibes, suitable for all ages.
This spot on Graham Ave in Williamsburg is consistently good for red sauce Italian, with loyal staff suggesting good management.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: A Sfincione Quest Bens Soho Amuni Bay Ridge

"Clarifying a previous comment, this user believes their favorite onion slice at Carmine's might be a spiritual successor to sfincione, though they aren't always sure if it's available."

Positive
Mar 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: A Sfincione Quest Bens Soho Amuni Bay Ridge

"This user states that Carmine's in Williamsburg makes good sfincione."

Positive
Mar 27, 2026View Comment →

From post: Sports Restaurants That Will Allow Underaged

"Carmine's, located a short subway ride into Brooklyn, is described as a restaurant with great, inexpensive American Italian food and sports bar vibes, suitable for all ages."

Positive
Feb 1, 2026View Comment →

From post: Red Sauce Italian

"Carmine's on Graham Ave in Williamsburg is consistently good for red sauce Italian, with loyal staff indicating good management."

Positive
Jan 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: My 2week Nyc List Thoughts

"Carmine's on Graham Ave is recommended to be added to the pizza list."

Negative
Jul 6, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Pizza Intransfer Lgajfk

"Carmine's Pizzeria in Williamsburg is praised as a 2nd generation Italian-owned spot with an incredible slice selection and a preferred off-the-radar spot, also noting its spaciousness and accessibility for travelers."

Positive
May 21, 2025View Comment →

From post: What Are Cool Spots For A Teenager

"The original poster is already considering Bernie's and Carmine's in Williamsburg."

Neutral
Apr 23, 2025View Comment →