TLDR
Dive bar vibes, killer sandwich counter. Don't miss the classic Italian-style tuna sandwich [1]. Daytime sandwiches are a 10/10 [2].
Details
This Manhattan tavern is celebrated for its surprisingly excellent sandwich counter, a delightful contrast to its dive bar ambiance [1]. Known for classic Italian-style tuna sandwiches [2], the food here often exceeds expectations, with some users describing the sandwiches as a 10/10 offering during daytime hours [3]. While some recall earlier times when food options were limited, the current sandwich game is a strong draw for many [4].
Food Overview
Puffy's Tavern offers a surprisingly robust sandwich selection, most notably its classic Italian-style tuna sandwich [1]. The sandwiches, often sourced from Alidoro, are a standout and are described as 10/10 during the day [2]. Some patrons recall a time when food was not a primary focus, but the current offerings have garnered significant positive attention.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PUFFY'S TAVERN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Wheres A Forlorn Gal Taking Herself Out To Dinner
"The commenter inquired if Puffy's Tavern serves food during dinner hours, as they were familiar with their sandwiches being a lunch-only offering."
NeutralFrom post: Wheres A Forlorn Gal Taking Herself Out To Dinner
"This commenter listed Puffy's Tavern as a recommendation in the Tribeca area."
NeutralFrom post: Im Staying At The Roxy In Tribeca Im Looking For
"Recalled that the food at Puffys was microwave pizza the last time they were there."
NegativeFrom post: Im Staying At The Roxy In Tribeca Im Looking For
"Commented that everything changed when Puffys became diddys."
NeutralFrom post: Im Staying At The Roxy In Tribeca Im Looking For
"Recalled working at Puffys years ago when they didn't have food and questioned where a kitchen would fit."
Neutral