Stunning ESB views from a lively rooftop. Great for tourists, but opinions on drinks vary.
Boasting unparalleled rooftop views of the Empire State Building, this popular American establishment offers a vibrant atmosphere. While some patrons praise the stunning vistas and lively ambiance, others caution that it can lean towards being a tourist hotspot with mixed reviews on drink quality.
The American cuisine here is secondary to the main attraction: the spectacular views of the Empire State Building. While some find the food and drinks decent, others strongly advise against the cocktails, labeling them as poor quality and suggesting it's more of a tourist destination than a culinary one.
Customer sentiment is divided, with many appreciating the iconic views and atmosphere, while others criticize the drinks and consider it a tourist trap.
Important Note
The venue is frequently described as a tourist trap with poor drink quality. It's also noted that it might not be ideal for those over 25, and weekend visits are discouraged.
"This user responds to the age clarification by stating that 30 is a good age and questions why the other user is bothered by her opinion."
Neutral"This user states they are 30 years old."
Neutral"This user questions if having an opinion is 'salty' and asks about the other user's age."
Neutral"This user visited two weeks ago and defends their positive experience, suggesting places can change over time."
Positive"This user questions the other's experience, stating they were there about a year ago and have never met anyone over 25 who likes the place."
Negative"This user had a fun birthday experience at the venue recently, disputing a previous negative opinion."
Positive"This user considers the establishment to be 'objectively terrible' and not suitable for those over 25, despite acknowledging the view."
Negative"This place offers a good view of the Empire State Building and has decent food and great drinks, though rooftop service in December might be an issue."
Neutral"230 Fifth Rooftop Bar in Herald Square is recommended for excellent rooftop views and is located near the Empire State Building."
Positive"The original commenter, identifying as a tourist, disputes the positive view of 230 Fifth, stating it's 'bad' and the view is 'mediocre'."
Negative"Despite a negative review, this commenter suggests 230 Fifth is not bad for tourists because of its great view."
Neutral"230 Fifth is considered the least favorite rooftop bar due to bad drinks and a crowd of young people making TikToks. The commenter advises skipping it."
Negative"A commenter strongly advises against visiting 230 Fifth, calling it a tourist trap with terrible drinks that doesn't fit the vibe of the other places on the list."
Negative"Suggested as a rooftop bar option, but the commenter advised against going on a weekend."
Neutral
