Stunning skyline views meet a controversial reputation, known for its rooftop vistas but criticized for its drinks and tourist-heavy atmosphere.
This rooftop bar is known for its stunning views of the Manhattan skyline, particularly the Empire State Building. However, many visitors find it to be an overpriced tourist trap with subpar drinks and a scene that doesn't appeal to everyone. While some suggest it's a decent spot for tourists due to the view, locals often advise against it, citing a negative atmosphere and poor beverage quality.
While specific food items are not detailed, customer feedback primarily focuses on the drinks, which are generally described as bad. The primary draw appears to be the rooftop view, though even this is debated.
Customer feedback is largely negative, with many labeling the establishment a tourist trap with poor drink quality and an undesirable atmosphere.
Important Note
Widely considered a tourist trap with poor quality drinks and a scene that may not appeal to everyone. Some advise against visiting on weekends.
"230 Fifth Rooftop Bar in Herald Square is recommended for excellent rooftop views and is located near the Empire State Building."
Positive"The original commenter, identifying as a tourist, disputes the positive view of 230 Fifth, stating it's 'bad' and the view is 'mediocre'."
Negative"Despite a negative review, this commenter suggests 230 Fifth is not bad for tourists because of its great view."
Neutral"230 Fifth is considered the least favorite rooftop bar due to bad drinks and a crowd of young people making TikToks. The commenter advises skipping it."
Negative"A commenter strongly advises against visiting 230 Fifth, calling it a tourist trap with terrible drinks that doesn't fit the vibe of the other places on the list."
Negative"Suggested as a rooftop bar option, but the commenter advised against going on a weekend."
Neutral
