TLDR
Iconic NYC rooftop views and a family-friendly atmosphere, perfect for sightseers looking for an easy-access high-rise experience.
Details
Known for its iconic NYC skyline views, this rooftop destination remains a popular fixture for visitors seeking a classic high-rise atmosphere [1]. While widely regarded as family-friendly and accessible [1], the establishment faces frequent criticism for high pricing and subpar drink quality [2], [3]. It serves as a go-to spot for those prioritizing scenery over culinary or cocktail excellence [3].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American fare and cocktails, though feedback is consistently negative regarding beverage quality. Guests have specifically critiqued the pina colada for tasting like watered-down milk and noted the mango margarita is poorly mixed [2]. Additionally, historical feedback highlighted that classic cocktails like the old fashioned were considered significantly overpriced [3].
Caveats
Be aware that the establishment is often criticized for high prices and drinks that some patrons describe as watery or poorly mixed [2], [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About 230 FIFTH
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: I Visited Over 30 Bars On My Nyc Trip Heres A
"Users collectively criticize the establishment, suggesting it is a tourist trap known for poor drinks and high prices, with the view being its only redeeming quality."
NegativeFrom post: I Visited Over 30 Bars On My Nyc Trip Heres A
"The visitor enjoyed the rooftop vibes and views, but criticized the quality of the drinks, calling them poorly mixed and watery."
NeutralFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"This person expressed strong dislike for the rooftop bar, finding it overpriced and the views to be only average."
NegativeFrom post: High Rise Nonfancy Bars With A View That Are Ok
"The commenter believes it's unlikely to be too crowded or have a waitlist at 230 Fifth Rooftop Bar on a Sunday late afternoon, as it's towards the end of the rooftop season."
PositiveFrom post: High Rise Nonfancy Bars With A View That Are Ok
"The user is asking if 230 Fifth Rooftop Bar would be too crowded or have a waitlist on a Sunday late afternoon (5-6 PM)."
Neutral