Vibrant, stylish dining w/ creative, delicious food. Must-try Gruyère fritters & sticky toffee pudding. Feast for the senses!
This New American restaurant in a historic Art Deco building offers a vibrant dining experience with a stylish modern dining room and lively bar. The food is creatively prepared and delicious, featuring standout dishes like Gruyère fritters, seasonal salads, roasted short rib, and a sticky toffee pudding dessert. It's a feast for the senses, providing both an atmospheric and culinary delight.
The cuisine is New American, with many reviewers highlighting creative and delicious dishes. Standout recommendations include Gruyère fritters, citrus chicken, short rib, and sticky toffee pudding. Some negative feedback exists regarding portion sizes, perceived value, and occasional inconsistencies in quality.
"Highly recommended dishes include the Gruyère fritters, sticky toffee pudding, and the grilled citrus-marinated chicken. The free bread and butter are also frequently praised, and the cocktails, particularly the white Negroni, receive high marks."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, praising the creative and delicious food, vibrant atmosphere, and excellent cocktails. Some have noted a decline in quality or value over time, while others remain loyal patrons.
Important Note
Some diners have experienced a decline in food quality or perceived value over time, with mentions of small portions being overpriced. There are also mixed opinions on whether the food is consistently outstanding enough to justify its Michelin status.
"A brief acknowledgement of the previous comment."
Neutral"The commenter adds that pairing a visit to Crown Shy with a pre-dinner drink at Overstory (especially if joining the waitlist and mentioning Crown Shy) offers great views."
Positive"Crown Shy is recommended for its cool vibe, non-stuffy atmosphere, and excellent food."
Positive"This user recalls Crown Shy as a restaurant with loud music, when discussing quieter dining options."
Negative"If desserts are the deciding factor, Crown Shy is recommended."
Positive"A brief comment suggesting Crown Shy, while acknowledging both options are great."
Positive"The user was not impressed with Crown Shy when they visited years ago."
Negative"Crown Shy is described as a mid-tier experience with a soulless atmosphere, contrasting with Gramercy Tavern's classic feel and warm service."
Negative"When checking in for a reservation at Crown Shy, guests can request an Overstory reservation for a nightcap."
Neutral"Crown Shy has reportedly declined in quality over the past couple of years, changing from exceptional food to a mediocre experience."
Negative"Crown Shy is described as a New American restaurant with appetizers around $25 and entrees around $50. The grilled chicken dish is recommended as a signature item. Reservations are generally available the day of for Friday nights. The average bill is estimated at $100 per person without alcohol."
Positive"This comment clarifies that Overstory is on the 64th floor."
Neutral"This user found Crown Shy to be a letdown, with food that was just 'ok' and nothing particularly outstanding, and noted mediocre service on their visit."
Negative"The user found Crown Shy's food to be 'standard' fine dining, good in the moment but not memorable, contrasting with Gramercy Tavern's exceptional service."
Neutral"Crown Shy has immaculate vibes and great service, but the food was found to be surprisingly oily and underwhelming."
Negative"Crown Shy was a significant disappointment, with underwhelming food and lackluster interior decor."
Negative"The user celebrated their birthday at Crown Shy and found the carrot cake ice cream to be heavenly."
Positive"The user liked Crown Shy but wasn't blown away and suggests Gramercy Tavern."
Neutral"While Gramercy Tavern is a favorite, the user enjoys Crown Shy, especially for those under 60. They also recommend visiting Overstory for drinks and potentially Saga for a splurge."
Positive"To access Overstory for a drink after a meal at Crown Shy, it's advised to coordinate with the host and mention your post-meal drink intention."
Neutral
