Vibrant art deco setting w/ stylish modern dining room. Creatively prepared, delicious New American fare & standout sticky toffee pudding.
Nestled in a historic Art Deco building, Crown Shy offers a vibrant and stylish dining experience with a lively bar and upbeat music. The menu features creatively prepared and delicious dishes, ranging from Gruyère fritters and seasonal salads to roasted short rib and a standout sticky toffee pudding. It's a place that engages all the senses, providing a feast for both the eyes and the palate.
Crown Shy offers New American cuisine with a focus on creative and delicious dishes. Standout items include Gruyère fritters, citrus chicken, and a highly recommended sticky toffee pudding. Some diners found certain dishes like branzino and crudo less appealing, while others experienced the food as overpriced for small portions. There's a notable mention of a highly-rated patty melt available at the bar.
"Highly recommended dishes include the Gruyère fritters, citrus chicken, and sticky toffee pudding. The bar menu's patty melt and the bread service (especially pistachio bread) are also frequently praised. While generally positive, some found the branzino and crudo less appealing."
Customers generally praise Crown Shy for its vibrant atmosphere and delicious, creatively prepared food, with many highlighting specific dishes. However, some reviews mention a decline in quality or value over time, with a few finding it overpriced for the portions.
Important Note
Some diners have reported a decline in food quality and value over time, with portions being considered small for the price by a few. Service has also been described as 'meh' by some.
"Crown Shy was listed as a potential restaurant for the occasion."
Positive"Crown Shy is noted as being available on Resy for the requested dates."
Positive"The user mentioned Crown Shy as a fine dining spot in the Financial District that might require reservations and is likely not an easy walk-in."
Negative"The commenter visited Crown Shy, a Michelin-star restaurant located on the bottom floor of the same building as Overstory and Saga, for a drink at the bar. They noted that the restaurant had a good menu and offered a happy hour on drinks and bites."
Positive"Crown Shy was listed as a restaurant suggestion."
Positive"A commenter felt Crown Shy was not worth the money, noting that while the pork and chicken were good, the service was terrible."
Negative"This commenter agreed that Crown Shy had a fun and upscale atmosphere but was not impressed with the food."
Negative"A commenter found Crown Shy to be delicious, fun, and upscale."
Positive"Crown Shy is mentioned as a restaurant that is not under the radar but easy to get into."
Positive"Crown Shy was recommended for its private dining room, and the commenter shared a positive experience hosting an event there for 10 people which cost around $4k."
Positive"A brief acknowledgement of the previous comment."
Neutral"The commenter adds that pairing a visit to Crown Shy with a pre-dinner drink at Overstory (especially if joining the waitlist and mentioning Crown Shy) offers great views."
Positive"Crown Shy is recommended for its cool vibe, non-stuffy atmosphere, and excellent food."
Positive"This user recalls Crown Shy as a restaurant with loud music, when discussing quieter dining options."
Negative"If desserts are the deciding factor, Crown Shy is recommended."
Positive"A brief comment suggesting Crown Shy, while acknowledging both options are great."
Positive"The user was not impressed with Crown Shy when they visited years ago."
Negative"Crown Shy is described as a mid-tier experience with a soulless atmosphere, contrasting with Gramercy Tavern's classic feel and warm service."
Negative"When checking in for a reservation at Crown Shy, guests can request an Overstory reservation for a nightcap."
Neutral"Crown Shy has reportedly declined in quality over the past couple of years, changing from exceptional food to a mediocre experience."
Negative
