TLDR
Classic American-style buttercream cakes featuring a unique, signature crème fraîche tang. A go-to for indulgent chocolate layers, delightful Swiss rolls, and reliable custom creations.
Details
Renowned for their classic American-style buttercream cakes, this bakery is a staple for those seeking moist, high-quality desserts with a signature tangy twist from the use of crème fraîche [1], [2]. From decadent Black Forest and Brooklyn Blackout cakes to fan-favorite Swiss rolls and lemon bars, the menu consistently delivers reliable, well-executed treats [3], [4], [5]. While generally praised for both flavor and custom design capabilities, some patrons have encountered isolated issues regarding order accuracy and service responsiveness [6].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic American bakery staples, with high praise for cakes that balance rich Belgian chocolate ganache or buttercream with a tangy crème fraîche-based cake layer [2], [5]. Customers frequently rave about the Black Forest and Brooklyn Blackout cakes, while the Swiss rolls, lemon bars, and "Twix" bars are cited as standout snackable options [3], [4], [5]. High-quality gluten-free cakes and cupcakes are also available and well-regarded [5].
Patrons overwhelmingly view this bakery as a top-tier destination for traditional American desserts, frequently highlighting the exceptional quality and consistent moisture of their cakes [1], [5]. While the vast majority of feedback is glowing, there have been rare reports of dissatisfaction concerning custom decoration accuracy and staff assistance [6].
Caveats
While the bakery is widely celebrated for its traditional flavors, some visitors have noted that the menu leans towards reliable, classic profiles rather than highly innovative or experimental ones [5]. Additionally, there have been isolated reports of frustration regarding incorrect custom cake decorations and lack of support from staff during resolution attempts [6].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EMPIRE CAKE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For The Best Black White Cookie In Nyc
"A brief recommendation for this bakery."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Black White Cookie In Nyc
"The user suggests Empire Cake as an option for black and white cookies."
PositiveFrom post: If You Could Only Pick One What Is Your Favorite
"The user highlights them for American-style cakes and excellent black and white cookies."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Bakery With Great Flourless Chocolate
"The bakery is a reliable office go-to that offers delivery and solid classic cakes, though the flavors are not particularly innovative."
PositiveFrom post: Searching For Best Peanut Butter Sweets For A
"Currently offering a peanut butter chocolate swiss roll."
Positive