NYC's best thin, chewy chocolate chip cookies & exceptional pastries. A must-try bakery w/ unique flavor combos.
Will Hartman reviews The Pastry Box, an East Village bakery renowned for its thin chocolate chip cookies, describing them as a must-try for cookie enthusiasts.
This East Village bakery is a haven for cookie lovers, particularly those who appreciate a thinner, chewier style. Praised as potentially the best in NYC, their chocolate chip cookies are a standout, boasting a perfect balance of chocolate and salt. Beyond cookies, they also offer delightful pastries and loaf cakes, making it a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth.
This bakery specializes in baked goods, with a strong emphasis on cookies, particularly chocolate chip. Customers rave about the thin and chewy texture of their cookies, often citing them as the best in New York City. Other popular items include black and white cookies, cinnamon rolls with a unique citrus note, and moist loaf cakes. The establishment is also noted as being Black-owned and nut-free.
"The chocolate chip cookie is overwhelmingly recommended, often called the best in NYC for its thin, chewy texture, balance of chocolate and salt, and rich flavor. The black and white cookie and cinnamon rolls are also highly praised."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the bakery for its exceptional cookies, with many declaring them the best in NYC. The quality, texture, and balance of flavors in their baked goods are consistently highlighted as outstanding.
Important Note
One user found the black and white cookie to be too sweet and the frosting hard, suggesting it's skippable if you prefer less sweet options. Another found their offerings 'just ok' across multiple visits.
"This commenter shares that The Pastry Box's Double Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe is available online on Food52 and has yielded great results when made at home."
Positive"This commenter shares that The Pastry Box's Double Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe is available online on Food52 and has yielded great results when made at home."
Positive"This commenter shares that The Pastry Box's Double Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe is available online on Food52 and has yielded great results when made at home."
Positive"For dessert on their last day in NYC, the commenter suggests the chocolate chip cookies from The Pastry Box in Manhattan."
Positive"As a fan of chewy yet thinner cookies, this user considers The Pastry Box's cookie their absolute favorite."
Positive"As a fan of chewy yet thinner cookies, this user considers The Pastry Box's cookie their absolute favorite."
Positive"As a fan of chewy yet thinner cookies, this user considers The Pastry Box's cookie their absolute favorite."
Positive"This user lists The Pastry Box as one of their top cookie recommendations."
Positive"This user lists The Pastry Box as one of their top cookie recommendations."
Positive"This user lists The Pastry Box as one of their top cookie recommendations."
Positive"This commenter identifies The Pastry Box as their favorite cookie spot and notes that the owner is very sweet."
Positive"This commenter identifies The Pastry Box as their favorite cookie spot and notes that the owner is very sweet."
Positive"This commenter identifies The Pastry Box as their favorite cookie spot and notes that the owner is very sweet."
Positive"This user declares The Pastry Box as the best bakery in the world."
Positive"Many users seem to agree that The Pastry Box is a top choice."
Neutral"This user declares The Pastry Box as the best bakery in the world."
Positive"Many users seem to agree that The Pastry Box is a top choice."
Neutral"This user declares The Pastry Box as the best bakery in the world."
Positive"Many users seem to agree that The Pastry Box is a top choice."
Neutral"This user states that The Pastry Box has the best chocolate chip cookies."
Positive
