TLDR
Classic NYC institution known for legendary donuts and 24/7 accessibility. An essential, high-quality bakery experience that locals consider an absolute gem.
Instagram Posts References
This establishment is recommended as part of the GoCity New York Mini Guide for its delicious donuts.
Details
An iconic New York City staple, this legendary bakery is widely celebrated as an unsung gem for its classic American treats [1]. Known for being a reliable destination for everything from late-night cravings to early morning indulgences, it is a favorite for locals and visitors alike [2], [3]. The shop is also highly regarded for its inclusive menu, offering excellent tree nut and peanut-free options, as well as a variety of vegan donuts [4].
Food Overview
This bakery specializes in traditional American donuts, with fan favorites including Boston cream, glazed, jelly, pumpkin spice cake, and blueberry cake varieties [1], [5]. Customers also speak highly of the black and white cookies and the fresh french crullers [2], [4]. While the classic donuts are generally beloved, the croissant donuts have received mixed reviews for being too dense [5].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended items include the pumpkin spice cake donuts, blueberry cake donuts, and the classic Boston cream donuts [1], [5]. The black and white cookies and fresh-made french crullers are also standout choices for frequent visitors [2], [4]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •st. john's donuts(2)
Caveats
Some visitors have noted that certain specialty items, such as the croissant donut, may not meet everyone's textural preferences [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE DONUT PUB
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Recent Trip Allergenfriendly Dining Report Egg
"This commenter expresses positive sentiment about The Donut Pub being mentioned, sharing a personal history of relying on their affordable sandwiches and coffee when living nearby. They fondly recall catching the fresh french crullers made around 3 AM."
PositiveFrom post: Recent Trip Allergenfriendly Dining Report Egg
"This is a tree nut and peanut-free donut shop with a variety of vegan options, ensuring everyone in the group could find something suitable without issues. It's described as a great place with very tasty offerings."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite 24 Hour Eateries
"This user praised Donut Pub as an all-time great, especially tempting for early morning treats."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite 24 Hour Eateries
"This user praised Donut Pub as an all-time great, especially tempting for early morning treats."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite 24 Hour Eateries
"This user specifically mentioned enjoying the St. John's donuts from Donut Pub."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite 24 Hour Eateries
"This user specifically mentioned enjoying the St. John's donuts from Donut Pub."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite 24 Hour Eateries
"This user expressed their love for Donut Pub."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite 24 Hour Eateries
"This user expressed their love for Donut Pub."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite 24 Hour Eateries
"This user recommended Donut Pub."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite 24 Hour Eateries
"This user recommended Donut Pub."
PositiveFrom post: Donuts Or Doughnuts Tour
"This user simply recommended trying The Donut Pub."
PositiveFrom post: Donuts Or Doughnuts Tour
"This user simply recommended trying The Donut Pub."
PositiveFrom post: Donuts Or Doughnuts Tour
"This user responded to a defensive comment by stating 'you first', implying the other user should reconsider their own taste."
NeutralFrom post: Donuts Or Doughnuts Tour
"This user responded to a defensive comment by stating 'you first', implying the other user should reconsider their own taste."
NeutralFrom post: Donuts Or Doughnuts Tour
"This user defended The Donut Pub against a negative review, suggesting the other user seek medical attention for their taste buds."
NeutralFrom post: Donuts Or Doughnuts Tour
"This user defended The Donut Pub against a negative review, suggesting the other user seek medical attention for their taste buds."
NeutralFrom post: Donuts Or Doughnuts Tour
"This user holds a very negative opinion of The Donut Pub, calling it one of the worst donut shops in NYC."
NegativeFrom post: Donuts Or Doughnuts Tour
"This user holds a very negative opinion of The Donut Pub, calling it one of the worst donut shops in NYC."
NegativeFrom post: Donuts Or Doughnuts Tour
"This user defended their negative experience with The Donut Pub's croissant donut, stating it was their genuine opinion."
NeutralFrom post: Donuts Or Doughnuts Tour
"This user defended their negative experience with The Donut Pub's croissant donut, stating it was their genuine opinion."
Neutral