TLDR
Unsung Manhattan gem for classic donuts and cookies. Beloved for being affordable, allergy-friendly, and almost always line-free.
Instagram Posts References
This establishment is recommended as part of the GoCity New York Mini Guide for its delicious donuts.
Details
Renowned as an underrated Manhattan gem, this establishment is consistently celebrated for its high-quality donuts and classic treats like Black & White cookies [1]. Patrons frequently highlight the exceptional service and the convenience of avoiding long lines, making it a reliable spot for sweet cravings [1]. The menu caters to diverse needs, offering notable allergy-friendly and vegan options [2]. Beyond donuts, it is also cherished for nostalgic staples like affordable sandwiches, coffee, and fresh-made French crullers [3].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American-style bakery items, with high praise for their Boston creme, glazed, jelly, and various cake donuts [5]. Customers specifically enjoy the pumpkin spice, blueberry, and St. John's donuts, while the Black & White cookies are widely considered outstanding [1], [4]. The shop is also recognized for its tree nut-free and vegan options, as well as classic comfort items like coffee rolls, sandwiches, and fresh French crullers [2], [3], [6].
Customer Sentiment
Overall sentiment is highly positive, with customers praising the shop as an 'all-time great' and an essential local destination [1]. While a small number of critics have debated the quality of specific experimental items like the croissant donut, the consensus remains overwhelmingly favorable [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE DONUT PUB
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Iso Traditional Bear Claw Donut Near Nyc
"Suggested as a place to check for bear claws."
NeutralFrom post: Iso Traditional Bear Claw Donut Near Nyc
"Suggested as a place to potentially find what the user is looking for."
NeutralFrom post: Iso Traditional Bear Claw Donut Near Nyc
"Doesn't consider them a traditional old-school donut shop anymore."
NeutralFrom post: Best Old Fashioned In Nyc Looking For Recs Before
"Mentioned as the only place known for old fashioneds, though the sentiment is neutral to slightly negative regarding the premise."
NeutralFrom post: Where To Find The Best Coffee Roll In Nyc Not
"Mentioned as an option for finding coffee rolls."
Positive