TLDR
An underrated Manhattan gem serving exceptional classic donuts, cookies, and late-night treats without the long lines.
Details
Renowned as an unsung gem in Manhattan, this establishment is a go-to destination for high-quality, classic donuts and standout Black & White cookies [1]. While some patrons appreciate the reliable late-night availability and nostalgic appeal of treats like french crullers, others remain critical of newer offerings like the croissant donut [2], [3]. Overall, it maintains a strong reputation as an essential spot for traditional baked goods that frequently impresses with its friendly staff [1], [4].
Food Overview
This bakery specializes in American-style baked goods, earning high praise for its Boston creme, glazed, and jelly donuts [1]. The menu is notably inclusive, offering tree nut-free and vegan options [5], while popular choices include the pumpkin and blueberry cake donuts [2]. Critics have expressed mixed opinions on the density of their croissant donuts and the overall quality of certain specialty items like the apple fritter [2], [3].
Patrons frequently highlight the Black & White cookies [1], fresh french crullers [5], and the variety of pumpkin and blueberry cake donuts as top choices [2].
Feedback is largely positive, with many patrons celebrating the shop as an 'all-time great' and an essential local staple [1], [4]. While some debates arise over personal taste regarding newer menu additions, most visitors report a consistently satisfying experience [2], [3].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01st. john's donuts2 mentions
- 02donuts2 mentions
Caveats
Some users have observed that the shop has shifted away from its traditional old-school atmosphere, leading to mixed sentiment regarding its modern identity [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE DONUT PUB
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For The Best Black White Cookie In Nyc
"Recommended as a spot for cookies."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Black White Cookie In Nyc
"The commenter notes they keep getting distracted by the donuts when trying to buy a cookie here."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Black White Cookie In Nyc
"The bakery is mentioned as a recommendation for black and white cookies."
PositiveFrom post: Traveling To Nyc This Weekend And My Sister Has
"Dedicated nut-free donut shop."
PositiveFrom post: Apple Fritter Where Can I One Like The One From
"The shop was suggested as a place to find doughnuts, though one user found their apple fritter just okay."
Neutral