NYC's oldest ale house, since 1854. Historic charm & strong beer. A true East Village legend.
Step back in time at this iconic East Village establishment, a legendary ale house since 1854. It's a quintessential New York experience, lauded for its historic ambiance and classic pub fare. While the food receives mixed reviews, the enduring charm and strong beer selection keep patrons coming back.
The food at this establishment receives mixed reviews, with some patrons recommending the cheese plate and chili, while others are less impressed with items like the burger, describing it as 'standard' or even 'terrible.' The liverwurst sandwich and fish and chips are also mentioned as alternatives.
"The cheese plate, chili, and dark ale are frequently recommended by patrons. Some also suggest the liverwurst sandwich or fish and chips."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards the historic ambiance and the beer selection, with some mixed feelings about the food.
Important Note
Some patrons advise against visiting on weekend nights due to crowds. There's also a sentiment that while the beer is good, the food can be hit-or-miss.
"McSorley's is listed for its light and dark beer."
Positive"Mcsorley's was listed as a potential place for chili."
Positive"The author has eaten at McSorley's three times and enjoyed it each time, describing it as 'old school New York type shit'."
Positive"Despite a previous comment advising against eating at McSorley's, this user states that the cheese plate is very good."
Positive"This commenter advises against eating at McSorley's but suggests getting a couple of beers there."
Negative"The commenter mentioned McSorley's because the stove was burning there this week, implying it would be warm."
Positive"McSorley's is mentioned as a restaurant."
Neutral"Mcsorley's was mentioned in the context of discussing quality restaurants."
Positive"This commenter adds that McSorley's is essentially an old bar in its own right, rather than trying to replicate the role of a pub in Ireland."
Neutral"This user agrees that McSorley's is a unique establishment and not a generic pseudo-Irish bar."
Positive"Responding to a comment about McSorley's, this user describes it as the quintessential New York Irish-American bar, noting that it doesn't closely resemble an actual Irish pub."
Neutral"This user questions why the article is bringing up the topic of "new Irish pubs" when McSorley's has apparently been doing something similar for a long time."
Neutral"McSorley's is mentioned, possibly as a casual option."
Neutral"The original poster usually takes first-time guests to McSorley's but noted it's not suitable for this group with kids."
Neutral"A commenter expressed happiness to see McSorely's mentioned, as they have many memories there."
Positive"The author tried the dark beer at McSorely's."
Neutral"This user notes that the hot dogs at McSorley's are not bad."
Positive"This user noted that Fish & Chips is the Friday special at McSorley's."
Neutral"McSorley's is suggested as a place to visit on a weeknight."
Positive"A suggestion to eat a liverwurst and onion sandwich at McSorley's for sustenance."
Neutral
