TLDR
Historic NYC landmark since 1854 with sawdust floors and iconic house-made light or dark beer. A quintessential, old-school pub experience.
Reddit Sentiment for MCSORLEY'S OLD ALE HOUSE(based on 51 Reddit opinions)
Details
Operating since 1854, this legendary East Village establishment remains a staple of New York City history, known for its sawdust-covered floors and timeless decor [1][2]. Guests can enjoy a simple, classic experience featuring only house-made light or dark beer alongside a straightforward menu [1][2]. It is widely considered a quintessential, authentic New York spot that offers a unique atmosphere rather than a traditional Irish pub experience [1].
Highlights / Recommended
"The house-made light or dark beer is a staple, frequently paired with the classic cheese plate served with raw onions [1]. The hot dogs, often served with a potent mustard, are also a popular choice [2]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •cheese plate(9)
- •burger(3)
- •roast pork(3)
- •liverwurst sandwich(2)
- •chili(2)
- •cheese and crackers with onions(2)
Caveats
The establishment is cash-only [2], can become very crowded [1][2], and is generally not considered suitable for visitors with children.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MCSORLEY'S OLD ALE HOUSE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Drink Looking For Authentic Nyc Bars Ideas In
"The user has shortlisted this bar as it matches their image of an old-fashioned establishment."
PositiveFrom post: Drink Looking For Authentic Nyc Bars Ideas In
"The author personally enjoys visiting this spot, especially when going alone."
PositiveFrom post: Drink Looking For Authentic Nyc Bars Ideas In
"Suggested as a potential "crazy throwback bar" for someone seeking an authentic atmosphere."
PositiveFrom post: Solo Lunch Recommendations For Birthday On A
"A suggestion to have a hot dog and beer at McSorley's."
PositiveFrom post: Dinner Spots For Taking Out Visiting Parents In
"McSorley's is suggested for the East Village."
PositiveFrom post: Good Apps And Quick Bites In The East Village
"The original poster acknowledged McSorley's as a classic recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Good Apps And Quick Bites In The East Village
"A classic spot, McSorley's, was recommended."
NeutralFrom post: Iconic Foods In Nyc
"Mentions McSorley's Old Ale House as one of the city's oldest bars that also serves a great hot dog, warning about its potent mustard."
PositiveFrom post: Iconic Foods In Nyc
"Mentions McSorley's Old Ale House as one of the city's oldest bars that also serves a great hot dog, warning about its potent mustard."
PositiveFrom post: Day Drinking Itinerary West Villageles
"This user recommended McSorley's, noting it is cash only, and suggested visiting the East Village for more variety."
NeutralFrom post: Day Drinking Itinerary West Villageles
"McSorley's was listed as a day drinking option."
NeutralFrom post: East Village Recommendations
"This user simply listed McSorley's as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: East Villagebowery Posthype Spots
"This user commented on the decor at McSorley's Old Ale House, stating it is timeless."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favorite Go To Restaurant That Doesnt Break
"Mentions McSorley's."
NeutralFrom post: East Villagebowery Posthype Spots
"This user commented that the cheese plate at McSorley's Old Ale House is timeless."
PositiveFrom post: East Villagebowery Posthype Spots
"This user mentioned McSorley's Old Ale House."
NeutralFrom post: Iso The Cheapest Pint And Glass Of Wine In The
"A warning is given not to go to McSorley's on the current day, possibly due to crowds or an event."
NegativeFrom post: Iso The Cheapest Pint And Glass Of Wine In The
"The user estimates drinks at McSorley's are around $8 and is unsure about wine options, but still considers it a must-visit at least once."
PositiveFrom post: Iso The Cheapest Pint And Glass Of Wine In The
"McSorley's is suggested as an experience in itself for affordable drinks. The user notes they haven't visited since around 2014."
PositiveFrom post: Visiting Nyc Looking For Hyper Specific Recs
"This user commented that the cheese and onion sandwich at McSorley's is good."
Positive