TLDR
Burgers that are delicious and satisfyingly messy. Some noted dairy in buns, but dairy-free options available.
Details
Shake Shack is a popular spot renowned for its delicious and satisfyingly messy burgers [1]. While many rave about the quality, some have noted concerns regarding dairy in their buns, although dairy-free options are available [7]. The chain also offers a variety of other items, and has historically had unique concrete flavors [6].
Food Overview
Shake Shack is lauded for its delicious and satisfyingly messy burgers [1]. Specific recommendations include the 'Double Shackburger' and the 'Smoke Shack' for those preferring a spicier option [3], [4]. While the standard buns contain dairy, a dairy-free option is available [7]. Customers also recall fondly Shake Shack's past monthly specials for concretes, which sometimes included a full slice of pie [6]. There are also mentions of a discontinued peanut butter sauce, though some believe it may still be available on a secret menu [9], [10], [11], [12].
Highlights / Recommended
"The 'Double Shackburger' and the 'Smoke Shack' (for a spicier option) are highly recommended. Customers also have fond memories of past concrete specials, often featuring unique mix-ins."
Customer Sentiment
Customers overwhelmingly praise Shake Shack's burgers, highlighting their deliciousness and satisfying, messy quality. However, some users noted issues with dairy in the standard buns and the discontinuation of a popular peanut butter sauce, impacting specific dietary needs or preferences [2].
Caveats
The standard buns at Shake Shack contain dairy, but a dairy-free option is available. A popular peanut butter sauce for ice cream toppings has been discontinued, although some users believe it may still be accessible via a secret menu.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SHAKE SHACK
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Midtown Lunch Options That Publish Caloriemacro
"Shake Shack was included in a list of restaurants that publish calorie and macro information."
NeutralFrom post: Peanut Butter Burger Does Any Restaurant Have A
"This comment claims Shake Shack still has a peanut butter option on their secret menu."
PositiveFrom post: Peanut Butter Burger Does Any Restaurant Have A
"This commenter states that Shake Shack's secret menu has a peanut sauce that is amazing."
PositiveFrom post: Peanut Butter Burger Does Any Restaurant Have A
"In response to Shake Shack discontinuing a peanut butter topping, this user hopes they bring it back as a special."
NeutralFrom post: Peanut Butter Burger Does Any Restaurant Have A
"This user mentions that they used to get a peanut butter sauce as an ice cream topping from Shake Shack, but it has been discontinued."
NegativeFrom post: Good Burgers For Dairy Egg Allergy
"Responding to a recommendation for Shake Shack, this user noted that their buns contain dairy, although they do offer a dairy-free bun option. This information is relevant to the original poster's allergy concerns."
NegativeFrom post: Good Burgers For Dairy Egg Allergy
"This user recommended Shake Shack as a place for burgers. The comment does not provide specific details about allergy accommodations."
NeutralFrom post: Blend In Ice Cream Nyc
"The commenter misses Shake Shack's past monthly specials for concretes, noting they were generally good and sometimes included a full slice of pie mixed in."
NeutralFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"Shake Shack is recommended, especially the 'Smoke Shack' if a spicier preference exists, for a homemade-style smashburger."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"Shake Shack is recommended for a good, fun burger that is delicious and satisfyingly messy."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"The 'Double Shackburger' from Shake Shack is suggested as a suitable option."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"Despite not eating beef for over 30 years, the smell of Shake Shack burgers is intoxicating, and family members who are foodies love their burgers."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurant Recs Near Hudson Yards
"This chain restaurant is mentioned, seemingly humorously, in response to a request for restaurant recommendations."
Negative