TLDR
Astoria's go-to for hearty American comfort food and towering, bold burgers. A local staple that keeps it real while serving up massive portions.
Details
Located in Astoria, this local favorite offers a diverse menu of American comfort food that earns high praise from long-time fans [10], [11]. While the quality of the food is frequently celebrated, the establishment has sparked significant online debate regarding its extravagant and often impractical burger presentations [2], [21]. Diners are encouraged to look past the viral-style plating to enjoy a solid local establishment that avoids the common pitfalls of trend-chasing eateries [9].
Food Overview
The menu features a wide variety of options including smash burgers, bison burgers, the 'Firehouse' burger, and creative items like the donut burger [12]. Sides are well-regarded, particularly the waffle fries, onion rings, and short rib fries [12], [18], [19]. While burgers are the primary draw, customers also recommend the chicken sandwiches, chicken fingers, and banana chocolate milkshakes [12], [13], [44]. A recurring point of contention is the use of brioche buns, which some customers find structurally inadequate or overused [3], [4], [7].
Caveats
The extreme size and height of the burgers can be difficult to manage, often requiring guests to squish the sandwich down or cut it into pieces to eat comfortably [15], [17], [24]. Some reports suggest potential inconsistency in food preparation, such as issues with meat temperature or bun quality [32], [33].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BURGER CLUB
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Why Are Gyros So Much More Expensive When They
"The author notes that a Greek gyro is currently more expensive than a cheeseburger at this establishment."
NeutralFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Expresses interest in the banana chocolate milkshake at Burger Club."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Recommends the Burger Club in Astoria for a great banana chocolate milkshake if you are in the area."
PositiveFrom post: Astoria Recs For Family
"Burger Club is highly praised for its burgers and also noted for a surprisingly good chicken caesar wrap, making it a family-friendly option."
PositiveFrom post: Astoria Recs For Family
"Burger Club is listed as a recommended restaurant in Astoria."
Positive