TLDR
Astoria's go-to for hearty American comfort food and towering, bold burgers. A local staple that keeps it real while serving up massive portions.
Details
Located in Astoria, this local favorite offers a diverse menu of American comfort food that earns high praise from long-time fans [10], [11]. While the quality of the food is frequently celebrated, the establishment has sparked significant online debate regarding its extravagant and often impractical burger presentations [2], [21]. Diners are encouraged to look past the viral-style plating to enjoy a solid local establishment that avoids the common pitfalls of trend-chasing eateries [9].
Food Overview
The menu features a wide variety of options including smash burgers, bison burgers, the 'Firehouse' burger, and creative items like the donut burger [12]. Sides are well-regarded, particularly the waffle fries, onion rings, and short rib fries [12], [18], [19]. While burgers are the primary draw, customers also recommend the chicken sandwiches, chicken fingers, and banana chocolate milkshakes [12], [13], [44]. A recurring point of contention is the use of brioche buns, which some customers find structurally inadequate or overused [3], [4], [7].
Caveats
The extreme size and height of the burgers can be difficult to manage, often requiring guests to squish the sandwich down or cut it into pieces to eat comfortably [15], [17], [24]. Some reports suggest potential inconsistency in food preparation, such as issues with meat temperature or bun quality [32], [33].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BURGER CLUB
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Why Are Gyros So Much More Expensive When They
"The author notes that a Greek gyro is currently more expensive than a cheeseburger at this establishment."
NeutralFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Expresses interest in the banana chocolate milkshake at Burger Club."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Recommends the Burger Club in Astoria for a great banana chocolate milkshake if you are in the area."
PositiveFrom post: Astoria Recs For Family
"Burger Club is highly praised for its burgers and also noted for a surprisingly good chicken caesar wrap, making it a family-friendly option."
PositiveFrom post: Astoria Recs For Family
"Burger Club is listed as a recommended restaurant in Astoria."
PositiveFrom post: Queens Burger Joints
"Burger Club in Astoria was listed as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Queens Burger Joints
"Burger Club was mentioned as a place with 'smash burgers'."
NeutralFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"This user expresses eagerness to try the chicken fingers with sweet habanero sauce based on the previous recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"This commenter jokes that they would need to unhinge their jaw like a snake to eat the burger without squishing it."
NeutralFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"This comment praises local food but criticizes overly tall sandwiches, suggesting the sausage should be better integrated into the burger."
NegativeFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"This user details their favorites at Burger Club, including the Firehouse burger, bison burger, donut burger, chicken sandwich, hanger steak, and smash burgers. They also praise the variety of fries and onion rings, and mention off-menu chicken fingers."
PositiveFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"This user asks for clarification on what the top burger choices would be."
NeutralFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"This user confirms that squishing the burger down made it easier to eat."
NeutralFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"This user comments on the excessive height of the burger."
NegativeFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"This user vouches for Burger Club's quality, stating they are legitimately very good with fantastic burgers and fries, and mentions hearing good things about their chicken sandwiches."
PositiveFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"Responding to a top recommendation, this user expresses surprise, placing Burger Club as very good but not their absolute favorite."
NeutralFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"This user inquires about the appropriate use of brioche buns, expressing a preference for potato buns."
NeutralFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"This commenter expresses that the burger's size and composition would likely cause them physical distress."
NegativeFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"A brief, humorous comment stating that the brioche bun insists on its presence."
NeutralFrom post: Burger Club In Astoria Queens
"This comment uses a poop emoji to express an immediate and strong aversion to the burger's presentation."
Negative