TLDR
Indulgent stoner-heaven featuring massive, creative comfort food mashups and elite seasonal desserts. A must-visit for hearty, inventive American eats in Queens and the LES.
Details
Renowned as a haven for indulgent, high-calorie American comfort food, this spot has become a local staple in Astoria and the Lower East Side [12], [42]. The menu is defined by its constant creative experimentation, ranging from innovative Thanksgiving-themed specials like egg rolls to rotating seasonal bread puddings [10], [11], [12], [49]. Diners frequently celebrate the massive portion sizes and bold flavor profiles that make the establishment a go-to for those seeking a heavy, satisfying meal [14], [41], [42], [51].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on elevated American comfort food, with standout items including high-quality chicken sandwiches, indulgent chopped cheese empanadas, and unique Thanksgiving-themed specials [6], [12], [14], [42]. Customers frequently rave about the desserts, specifically the rainbow cookie crumb cake, malted vanilla shakes, and their highly acclaimed Dole Whip, which has been compared favorably to the original version from Hawaii [2], [7], [8], [38], [39], [43]. While the food is generally beloved, some diners have noted that certain specialty items are rotating specials and may not always be available [10], [36].
Highlights / Recommended
Mentioned Dishes:
- •dole whip(4)
- •chopped cheese empanadas(2)
- •fruity pebble item(2)
- •rainbow cookie crumb cake(2)
- •rainbow cookie coffee cake(2)
- •thanksgiving sandwich(2)
Customer Sentiment
Overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with visitors consistently praising the restaurant for its massive, filling portions and creative menu innovations [14], [42], [51]. While the vast majority of diners are enthusiastic, some occasional feedback notes that the presentation of certain experimental dishes may not be visually appealing to everyone [26], [27].
Caveats
The restaurant is generally not recommended for those with low appetites due to the sheer size of the meals, and many of the most famous dishes are rotating specials that are not guaranteed to be on the menu during every visit [10], [36], [42].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About COMFORTLAND
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Most Unusual Food I Can Eat Late At Night In The
"Recommended for weekend late-night food."
PositiveFrom post: Anywhere To Find A Stuffed Pretzel Sweet Or Savory
"The restaurant sometimes features pretzel pockets that can be sweet or savory."
PositiveFrom post: Fried Chicken Sandwich In The City Any
"Recommends anything from here."
PositiveFrom post: Fried Chicken Sandwich In The City Any
"Agrees the food is amazing and portion sizes are massive."
PositiveFrom post: Fried Chicken Sandwich In The City Any
"Recommends their fried chicken biscuit buddy, noting the biscuit itself is elite."
PositiveFrom post: I Kept Hearing About Pies N Thighs Finally To Be
"The commenter suggests trying Comfortland for a good biscuit instead of Pies n Thighs."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Bread Pudding In
"The commenter notes that they offer great seasonal bread pudding varieties."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter suggested Comfortland if the user is 'feeling crazy', implying it offers unique or indulgent sandwich options."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"This user recommended Comfortland in Astoria specifically for their malted vanilla shake."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"This user recommended Comfortland."
PositiveFrom post: Where Do You Order In From In The City When Youre
"Comfortland in Astoria is described as perfect comfort food/stoner heaven, with their chopped cheese empanadas being a favorite. However, it's noted as not ideal for low appetites. A new location on the Lower East Side is also mentioned."
PositiveFrom post: Are There Any Shops That Have Dole Whip In
"Responding to a linked thread about Dole Whip, this user stated that Comfortland's Dole Whip is the closest to the one they had at the Dole Plantation on Oahu. They mentioned the Queens location has had it recently and were unsure about the Manhattan location."
PositiveFrom post: Are There Any Shops That Have Dole Whip In
"This user suggested Comfortland on the LES might have Dole Whip, noting that their Astoria location does."
NeutralFrom post: Are There Any Shops That Have Dole Whip In
"This user suggested Comfortland in Astoria for Dole Whip."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user recommended Comfortland for large meals."
PositiveFrom post: I Am Craving Chicken Salad Sandwich Where In The
"This user recommended Comfortland and Spitfire Provisions."
PositiveFrom post: What Is Your Most Frequented Restaurant
"Comfortland is listed as a frequently visited restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Wild Chilaquiles
"In response to the mention of Comfortland's chilaquiles crunch wrap, the user expresses strong interest and a desire to try it."
PositiveFrom post: Wild Chilaquiles
"The user mentions that Comfortland used to offer a chilaquiles crunch wrap as a special, but it may no longer be available."
NeutralFrom post: Thanksgiving Egg Roll From Comfortland
"After seeing the post, this user visited Comfortland and confirmed that the Thanksgiving egg rolls with cranberry sauce were 'fire'."
Positive