Unique Broadway-themed & rotating cookies, incl. funfetti & corn flavors. Great for late-night treats!
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Schmackary's, a Hell's Kitchen bakery famed for its Broadway-themed and rotating cookie flavors, highlighting their late hours and "Classic" chocolate chip cookie.
Schmackary's, born from a Broadway actor's passion for cookies, has become a beloved Hell's Kitchen bakery. Known for its extensive and creative menu, featuring Broadway-themed and constantly rotating flavors, it's a go-to for unique sweet treats. While the classic chocolate chip might not be groundbreaking, their specialty cookies, like the Funfetti or Corn cookie, and infused soft-serve ice cream, are highly praised.
Schmackary's offers a wide array of cookies with a focus on unique and rotating flavors, often themed around Broadway shows. While their standard chocolate chip cookie is noted as not particularly special, other options like the Funfetti cookie, Corn cookie, and Cookies and Cream cookie receive high praise. They also offer infused soft-serve ice cream.
"The Funfetti cookie and the Corn cookie are specifically called out as must-tries. Many also recommend exploring their wide variety of rotating and "crazy" cookie flavors."
Customers generally praise Schmackary's for its creative and diverse cookie offerings, with many highlighting specific unique flavors. While the standard chocolate chip cookie receives mixed reviews, the overall sentiment is positive, with many fond memories and recommendations for their more adventurous options.
Important Note
The standard chocolate chip cookie might not be the most exciting option, and some users believe their frosted cookies or soft-serve are more noteworthy.
"This commenter finds the corn cookies at Schmackary's to be amazing."
Positive"This commenter finds the corn cookies at Schmackary's to be amazing."
Positive"This user rates Schmackary's chocolate chip cookie at 8.3 out of 10."
Positive"This user rates Schmackary's chocolate chip cookie at 8.3 out of 10."
Positive"This user states that Schmackary's is better known for their frosted cookies and their infused soft-serve."
Neutral"This user states that Schmackary's is better known for their frosted cookies and their infused soft-serve."
Neutral"The author rates Schmackary's chocolate chip cookie as 7.4 out of 10, according to the Beli app. They note they have many other places to try."
Positive"The author rates Schmackary's chocolate chip cookie as 7.4 out of 10, according to the Beli app. They note they have many other places to try."
Positive"Schmackary's is mentioned as a good place for desserts."
Neutral"Schmackary's cookies are mentioned as being pretty good, though not necessarily offering an experience for 'the better part of an hour'."
Positive"This user suggested Schmackery's Cookies and Cream cookie as a potential alternative to the cookies in the original post, noting it was closer in flavor."
Neutral"This user suggested trying Schmackary's for millionaire's shortbread."
Neutral"This user recommended checking with Schmackary's for millionaire's shortbread."
Neutral"This user recommended Schmackery's and also suggested Huascar and Co in Hell's Kitchen for those willing to travel further."
Positive"Schmackary's offers decent cookies with rotating specials. Other dessert spots like Dim Sum Sam, I'm donut?, and Angelina Bakery are also mentioned."
Neutral"Schmackary's Cookies are specifically mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"Schmackary's is recommended."
Positive
