Broadway-themed cookies & 100+ rotating flavors. Late-night treats that hit the spot.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Schmackary's, a Hell's Kitchen bakery famed for its Broadway-themed and rotating cookie flavors, highlighting their late hours and "Classic" chocolate chip cookie.
Schmackary's is a unique bakery in Hell's Kitchen that offers a delightful array of cookies, with a special nod to Broadway. They boast around 100 rotating flavors, ensuring there's always something new to try, alongside their consistent "Classic" chocolate chip cookie. The bakery's late operating hours make it a perfect spot for a post-theater treat.
This bakery is a haven for cookie lovers, offering a vast selection of unique and rotating flavors, often inspired by Broadway. While many find their "crazy" and specialty cookies to be a highlight, some reviews suggest the standard chocolate chip cookie may not be as exceptional. Despite this, the overall sentiment points towards a satisfying baked goods experience.
"Schmackary's is highly recommended for its creative and varied cookie flavors, with past mentions of a good cookie dough cookie and a funfetti cookie."
Customers generally appreciate the wide variety of creative cookie flavors and the convenience of late hours, although the standard chocolate chip cookie might not be for everyone.
Important Note
While known for variety, the standard chocolate chip cookie may not meet everyone's expectations.
"Schmackary's is mentioned as a good place for desserts."
Neutral"Schmackary's cookies are mentioned as being pretty good, though not necessarily offering an experience for 'the better part of an hour'."
Positive"This user suggested Schmackery's Cookies and Cream cookie as a potential alternative to the cookies in the original post, noting it was closer in flavor."
Neutral"This user suggested trying Schmackary's for millionaire's shortbread."
Neutral"This user recommended checking with Schmackary's for millionaire's shortbread."
Neutral"This user recommended Schmackery's and also suggested Huascar and Co in Hell's Kitchen for those willing to travel further."
Positive"Schmackary's offers decent cookies with rotating specials. Other dessert spots like Dim Sum Sam, I'm donut?, and Angelina Bakery are also mentioned."
Neutral"Schmackary's Cookies are specifically mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"Schmackary's is recommended."
Positive"Schmackary's, opened by a Broadway actor, started by making cookies for fellow cast members and friends."
Neutral"Used to get Schmackarys' funfetti cookie weekly and loves the place."
Positive"Simply names Schmackarys."
Positive"Commenter points out that Schmackary's was forgotten in the original list."
Neutral"Still remembers a great cookie dough cookie from Schmackary's years ago and hopes to find it again."
Positive"Finds Schmackery's solid and has never had a problem with them."
Positive"Notes Schmackarys has great variety, but their standard chocolate chip cookie isn't special."
Neutral"Simply names Schmackary's."
Positive"Recommends Schmackarys for more "crazy" flavors."
Positive"Simply names Schmackerys."
Positive
