Broadway-themed cookies & unique flavors, open late for your sweet tooth fix.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Schmackary's, a Hell's Kitchen bakery famed for its Broadway-themed and rotating cookie flavors, highlighting their late hours and "Classic" chocolate chip cookie.
This Hell's Kitchen bakery is a must-visit for cookie enthusiasts, famous for its innovative and often Broadway-themed flavors. With a vast selection of rotating options, it's easy to find something new and exciting with every visit. While the classic chocolate chip cookie is a solid staple, the real draw is the adventurous flavor combinations that keep customers coming back.
This establishment specializes in cookies, offering a wide array of unique and Broadway-themed flavors alongside more traditional options. While the 'Classic' chocolate chip cookie receives mixed reviews, other unique flavors like funfetti and cookie dough are highly praised. The bakery is known for its creative, rotating specials.
"Customers have specifically enjoyed the 'funfetti cookie' and 'cookie dough cookie', with one user recalling a positive past experience with the latter."
Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, frequently recommending it for its unique and varied cookie flavors. While the standard chocolate chip cookie may not be universally praised, the establishment is often cited for its creative offerings and a positive past experience with specific flavors.
Important Note
The 'Classic' chocolate chip cookie might not be the most standout item, but the variety of other creative flavors compensates for this.
"This user suggested trying Schmackary's for millionaire's shortbread."
Neutral"This user recommended checking with Schmackary's for millionaire's shortbread."
Neutral"This user recommended Schmackery's and also suggested Huascar and Co in Hell's Kitchen for those willing to travel further."
Positive"Schmackary's offers decent cookies with rotating specials. Other dessert spots like Dim Sum Sam, I'm donut?, and Angelina Bakery are also mentioned."
Neutral"Schmackary's Cookies are specifically mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"Schmackary's is recommended."
Positive"Schmackary's, opened by a Broadway actor, started by making cookies for fellow cast members and friends."
Neutral"Used to get Schmackarys' funfetti cookie weekly and loves the place."
Positive"Simply names Schmackarys."
Positive"Commenter points out that Schmackary's was forgotten in the original list."
Neutral"Still remembers a great cookie dough cookie from Schmackary's years ago and hopes to find it again."
Positive"Finds Schmackery's solid and has never had a problem with them."
Positive"Notes Schmackarys has great variety, but their standard chocolate chip cookie isn't special."
Neutral"Simply names Schmackary's."
Positive"Recommends Schmackarys for more "crazy" flavors."
Positive"Simply names Schmackerys."
Positive
