Critically acclaimed Chinese eatery known for its innovative dim sum, especially the "bomb" Katz pastrami eggroll and highly debated Peking duck.
Red Farm, a Chinese eatery, has garnered mixed reviews since its reopening. Many patrons praise its "amazing duck" and unique "Katz pastrami eggroll" as standout dishes. However, a segment of diners express disappointment, particularly concerning the authenticity and preparation of their Peking duck, with some describing it as a "fancified" take on the classic. Despite some debate on authenticity, the restaurant is frequently recommended for its dim sum and crispy beef. It's noted as a popular, though not fine-dining, option conveniently located for pre-show meals in the Upper West Side.
Red Farm offers Chinese cuisine with a focus on dishes like Peking duck, duck, and dim sum. While some customers rave about their duck and eggrolls, others debate the authenticity of their Peking duck, with some finding it to be a 'fancified' American-Chinese version. The crispy beef is also highlighted as a must-try.
"The Katz pastrami eggroll and crispy beef are highly recommended, along with their duck and dim sum. Some also suggest trying their dumplings and soup."
Customers have mixed feelings about Red Farm. While some praise it as a great re-opened restaurant with amazing duck and a standout Katz pastrami eggroll, others find it disappointing and overpriced, particularly regarding the Peking duck's authenticity and preparation.
Important Note
Some diners find the Peking duck preparation to be inauthentic and the restaurant to be overpriced.
"The author found Red Farm to be poor, in contrast to their recommendation for Pinch Chinese."
Negative"Red Farm was suggested as a possible option, noting its convenience to the 1 train for returning downtown."
Neutral"The original poster mentioned RedFarm as a restaurant they enjoy."
Neutral"This user clarifies their point about authenticity by comparing it to pizza and ramen, stating that authentic Peking duck is primarily about the skin's rendering and crispiness."
Negative"This user defends RedFarm's Peking duck, questioning the definition of authenticity for ramen and duck dishes."
Neutral"This user disputes that RedFarm serves authentic Peking duck, stating it resembles a good roast duck but not the real dish, comparing it to calling all noodle soup 'ramen'."
Negative"This user states that RedFarm is mediocre and overpriced."
Negative"This user comments that RedFarm is American Chinese food, and while delicious and having the best Peking duck in the city, it's not authentic."
Neutral"This user states that RedFarm is American Chinese food and did not see many Asians there."
Negative"RedFarm is recommended as a dining option."
Positive"The user states they last went to Red Farm many years ago and would trust the previous commenter's opinion."
Neutral"Red Farm is not considered very good for Peking duck."
Negative"Red Farm is mentioned as another recommendation for Peking duck."
Neutral"This user found their experience at the Redfarm along the UWS to be really disappointing, especially when compared to their positive past experiences with Decoy's duck."
Negative"The commenter mentions their obsession with crispy beef began after trying the dish at Red Farm, implying a positive experience with the restaurant."
Positive"The commenter agrees that Red Farm is an excellent choice for a meal before a show at The Beacon, calling it the 'best' option."
Positive"Red Farm is a popular choice, though not fine dining, located a short walk from The Beacon. It is always packed and offers many good options aside from red meat."
Positive"Red Farm is suggested as a place that might be 'vaguely inspired' by the old-school American-Chinese genre (which includes Boston-style), offering a 'fancified version'. This suggestion was not well-received by other users in the thread."
Neutral"Suggests Red Farm for a fun, high-end Chinese dining experience, suitable for a special occasion."
Positive"The author highly recommends Red Farm, specifically praising their amazing duck and 'bomb' Katz pastrami eggroll."
Positive
