TLDR
Highly acclaimed oyster bar and seafood spot with a legendary happy hour and a consistently reliable, crowd-pleasing menu.
Details
Renowned for its vibrant atmosphere and excellent seafood, this Columbus Avenue staple is widely considered a go-to destination for both visitors and locals [20], [21]. Patrons frequently praise the establishment for its high-quality oysters and well-regarded happy hour offerings [2], [14]. Beyond its reputable raw bar, the menu is noted for being consistently solid and versatile, ensuring there is something to satisfy everyone in any dining party [20].
Food Overview
This seafood-focused venue is best known for its exceptional raw bar, with patrons specifically seeking out the $1 oysters, clams, and shrimp cocktails [2], [14]. The happy hour menu is a significant draw, featuring a variety of well-regarded small plates including fish tacos, crab cakes, sliders, and crispy Old Bay fries [3], [14]. Diners also frequently commend the quality of the martinis [10].
Feedback for the restaurant is overwhelmingly positive, with diners frequently highlighting its welcoming nature, efficiency, and status as a reliable choice for any occasion [1], [6], [20]. Guests particularly value the consistent quality of the food and the excellent value provided during happy hour sessions [14], [22].
Caveats
For larger gatherings, such as groups of 20, the restaurant requires the submission of an event form to coordinate the visit [15].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE MERMAID INN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Can Two Foodies Find An Amazing Dinner With
"Recommended for families if visiting during lunch hours."
NeutralFrom post: What Are Good Restaurant Recommendations Near
"Described as very solid with a menu that has something for everyone."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Good Restaurant Recommendations Near
"Recommended as a great option on Columbus Avenue."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Good Restaurant Recommendations Near
"Recommended for visitors."
PositiveFrom post: Solo Dining Recommendations In Upper West Side
"Considered a common "nice" meal choice nearby the Natural History museum."
Positive