Next.js logo

THE MERMAID INN

Updated

Phone: (917) 640-3667

Address: 335 COLUMBUS AVENUE 10023

TLDR

Top-tier oyster bar and iconic happy hour spot featuring $1 oysters and stellar martinis. A local favorite for a reliable and lively seafood meal.

Reddit Sentiment for THE MERMAID INN(based on 21 Reddit opinions)

90% Positive10% Neutral

Tags

american 7seafood 5seafood 7oysters 5american 2View All

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Details

Known for a bustling atmosphere and an exceptional seafood-forward menu, this Columbus Avenue staple is a premier choice for those visiting the nearby Natural History museum [4]. Guests consistently praise the high-quality oyster bar and well-crafted martinis, which anchor a versatile dining experience [3]. With multiple locations and a reputation for solid, crowd-pleasing American fare, it remains a consistent favorite for both group gatherings and solo outings [3], [4].

Food Overview

This restaurant specializes in American-style seafood with a heavy emphasis on fresh raw bar offerings [1], [3]. Customers frequently highlight the $1 oysters, shrimp cocktail, Old Bay fries, and sliders as standout items [1], [2], [3]. While the menu is extensive, the happy hour remains the most popular way to sample a variety of dishes including crab cakes, fish tacos, and clam chowder [3].

Customer Sentiment

Patrons overwhelmingly favor the establishment for its excellent happy hour deals and efficient service, noting that even solo diners can enjoy a full meal quickly [1], [2]. The atmosphere is frequently described as welcoming and versatile, making it a go-to for casual dinners and celebratory group events [3].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About THE MERMAID INN

This post provides a comprehensive list of popular happy hour seafood items available at the restaurant, such as oysters, crab cakes, and fish tacos.
Multiple commenters praise the restaurant's happy hour, specifically noting the value of the $1 oysters and the quality of the martinis.
Useful information regarding the restaurant's capacity for groups and the logistical process for hosting events at their various locations.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: What Are Good Restaurant Recommendations Near

"Described as very solid with a menu that has something for everyone."

Positive
Aug 3, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Are Good Restaurant Recommendations Near

"Recommended as a great option on Columbus Avenue."

Positive
Aug 3, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Are Good Restaurant Recommendations Near

"Recommended for visitors."

Positive
Aug 3, 2026View Comment →

From post: Solo Dining Recommendations In Upper West Side

"Considered a common "nice" meal choice nearby the Natural History museum."

Positive
Jul 18, 2026View Comment →

From post: Any Suggestions For A Manhattan Seafood Lunch

"Amazing happy hour with a variety of seafood options."

Positive
Jul 5, 2026View Comment →

More in Upper West Side

See all

More American in NYC

See all