UWS Italian fave w/ outstanding house-made pastas & salumi. Cozy spot, expert craft, worth the visit.
This Italian gem on the Upper West Side is celebrated for its exquisite selection of meats and cheeses, alongside house-made pastas and daily specials that consistently impress. Diners rave about the quality and authenticity of the food, with standout dishes like the rigatoni carbonara and fresh mozzarella earning high praise. While the cozy atmosphere is charming, it's worth noting that the small space can get busy, making reservations a good idea, especially around nearby events.
The culinary experience centers around authentic Italian cuisine, with a strong emphasis on high-quality salumi, cheeses, and expertly crafted house-made pastas. Standout dishes include the rigatoni carbonara and fresh mozzarella, though the entire pasta selection is frequently lauded. The eatery also offers delicious appetizers like house-stuffed bleu cheese olives and a variety of tempting desserts.
"Customers highly recommend the house-made pastas, with the rigatoni carbonara being a standout. The fresh mozzarella and house-stuffed bleu cheese olives are also frequently praised as must-try items."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the outstanding quality of the food, particularly the house-made pastas and salumi. While the intimate setting is part of its charm, it can lead to waits, so planning ahead is advised.
Important Note
The restaurant is noted to be small and can become very busy, especially when there are events at the nearby Beacon Theatre. Reservations are recommended, and there's a possibility of being turned away if it's too crowded.
"The commenter expresses that Salumeria Rosi is very good."
Positive"This user recommended Osteria Accademia and also mentioned Salumeria Rosi as a good option."
Positive"This user mentioned Salumeria Rosi as a place they like, alongside Spiga and Lucciola."
Positive"The user recommends Salumeria Rosi, noting its specific address near the Beacon Theatre and that Anthony Bourdain was a fan."
Positive"This commenter recommends Salumeria Rosi, noting it's a restaurant with a deli component that serves delicious fresh mozzarella."
Positive"The author states Salumeria Rosi is great and one of their two favorite restaurants on the UWS."
Positive"The author lists Salumeria Rosi as one of the good places on the UWS, while suggesting downtown might have better options overall."
Positive"The author expresses love for Salumeria Rosi."
Positive"User SadCombination7535 clarifies Salumeria Rosi sometimes books up and they were turned away when Bono was playing at the Beacon."
Neutral"User Mofrdo reiterates Salumeria Rosi is their go-to walk-in spot, having never waited, though they go more for lunch than dinner."
Positive"User SadCombination7535 notes that Salumeria Rosi can have a big wait, especially due to concerts at the Beacon Theatre."
Neutral"User Mofrdo names Salumeria Rosi on the UWS as a go-to spot."
Positive"Recommends Salumeria Rosi for dinner near Beacon Theatre."
Positive"Considers Salumeria Rosi the right choice but notes it's small and popular, so reservations are recommended. They specifically enjoy the house-stuffed bleu cheese olives."
Positive"Recommends Salumeria Rosi as their favorite Italian on the UWS. They love the pastas and find the food quality outstanding."
Positive"Lists Salumeria Rosi as a medium upscale Italian option on the UWS."
Positive
