UWS Italian gem w/ outstanding house-made pastas & salumi. A must-try for quality Italian food & unique appetizers like stuffed olives.
This Italian eatery on the Upper West Side is a beloved neighborhood spot, renowned for its exceptional quality meats and cheeses, alongside delicious homemade pastas and daily specials. It's considered a top Italian choice by many, offering a medium upscale dining experience that's perfect for pre-theater meals or a satisfying dinner. The restaurant also boasts a deli component, serving up delights like fresh mozzarella and stuffed olives.
This Italian restaurant is celebrated for its high-quality meats, cheeses, and homemade pastas. Standout dishes include their pastas, house-stuffed bleu cheese olives, and fresh mozzarella. While most feedback is positive, one comment mentioned a disappointing lasagna at a new location.
"Customers highly recommend the house-stuffed bleu cheese olives and the various pastas. Fresh mozzarella and salumi/charcuterie boards are also frequently praised."
Customers overwhelmingly praise this Italian restaurant for its outstanding food quality, particularly its pastas and salumi. While generally very positive, some note that the space can be small and popular, so reservations are recommended.
Important Note
The restaurant is noted to be small and popular, so reservations are recommended, especially during events at the nearby Beacon Theatre. There's a mention of a potentially disappointing experience with lasagna at a new East Village location.
"This user recommended Salumeria Rosi, mentioning the original location on 73rd and Amsterdam and a new location on the LES."
Negative"This user recommended Salumeria Rosi, mentioning the original location on 73rd and Amsterdam and a new location on the LES."
Negative"Salumeria Rosi on the Upper West Side is recommended for a good mushroom risotto."
Positive"This user visited the new East Village location of Salumeria Rosi and was disappointed with their meal, specifically noting the noodle seemed dried out and potentially reheated, though service was excellent."
Negative"This user asked what was wrong with working at Salumeria Rosi."
Neutral"This user, who hated working at Salumeria Rosi, still finds their food, including lasagna, to be on point."
Positive"Salumeria Rossi was mentioned."
Positive"Salumeria Rosi is highly recommended as an excellent small Italian place located conveniently near the Beacon Theatre."
Positive"Salumeria Rossi is mentioned as a spot that Anthony Bourdain visited, though it may not have been on par with other experiences."
Neutral"The commenter expresses that Salumeria Rosi is very good."
Positive"This user recommended Osteria Accademia and also mentioned Salumeria Rosi as a good option."
Positive"This user mentioned Salumeria Rosi as a place they like, alongside Spiga and Lucciola."
Positive"The user recommends Salumeria Rosi, noting its specific address near the Beacon Theatre and that Anthony Bourdain was a fan."
Positive
