TLDR
Massive, authentic Italian deli sandwiches; huge portions perfect for sharing. Real NY lunch spot.
Details
This Italian deli is celebrated for its massive and delicious sandwiches, often described as authentic and large enough to share [1]. While praised for quality and value, some find the price point high if not sharing, and it's noted more as a local gem than a tourist hotspot [2].
Food Overview
Pisillo Italian Panini is renowned for its incredibly large and authentic Italian sandwiches and deli items. Multiple reviews highlight that one sandwich is substantial enough to serve two people, making it a great value, though some find the price point high if not shared [1], [2]. The '26' sandwich has been specifically recommended [3].
Highlights / Recommended
"The '26' sandwich is specifically recommended as one of the best. Generally, their authentic Italian panini and deli sandwiches are highly praised for their size and quality."
Customer Sentiment
Customers overwhelmingly praise the large, delicious Italian sandwiches and deli items, with many finding them to be excellent value, especially when shared. Some opinions suggest the sandwiches can be pricey if not split, and it's not considered a primary tourist destination [1].
Caveats
While highly praised for size and quality, some users find the sandwiches to be on the pricier side if not shared. There has also been some confusion regarding the correct spelling of the restaurant's name.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PISILLO ITALIAN PANINI
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Cheap Eats Financial District Near Whitehall St
"Jersey Mike's coupons can make their cold subs around $9-$10."
PositiveFrom post: Cheap Eats Financial District Near Whitehall St
"The sandwiches are highly recommended and can be easily shared, making them a practical option for colleagues."
PositiveFrom post: Cheap Eats Financial District Near Whitehall St
"The sandwiches at Pisillo Italian Panini are recommended and easy to share."
PositiveFrom post: Cheap Eats Financial District Near Whitehall St
"The sandwiches are highly recommended and can be easily shared, making them a practical option for colleagues."
PositiveFrom post: Cheap Eats Financial District Near Whitehall St
"Subway footlongs are available for around $6.99 with promo codes."
PositiveFrom post: Cheap Eats Financial District Near Whitehall St
"This Italian deli offers large panini sandwiches that are suggested to be split between two people, making them a good value despite the $17-$18 price point."
PositiveFrom post: Cheap Eats Financial District Near Whitehall St
"Pisillo Italian Panini offers large sandwiches around $17-$18 that are suitable for splitting."
PositiveFrom post: Cheap Eats Financial District Near Whitehall St
"This deli offers large panini sandwiches that are suggested to be split between two people, making them a good value despite the $17-$18 price point."
PositiveFrom post: Cheap Eats Financial District Near Whitehall St
"Jubilee on John Street offers deli sandwiches, like pastrami on a roll, for $7."
PositiveFrom post: Best Italian Sandwich Below 14th Street Hopefully
"This commenter confirmed that the correct spelling is Pisillo, and it is located in Chelsea."
PositiveFrom post: Best Italian Sandwich Below 14th Street Hopefully
"This user questioned whether they were mistaken about the name 'Pisillo', as multiple people had spelled it 'Pasillo'."
NeutralFrom post: Best Italian Sandwich Below 14th Street Hopefully
"This commenter stated that while they respect Faicco's, they now believe Pisillo makes a better sandwich and prefer its bread."
PositiveFrom post: Best Italian Sandwich Below 14th Street Hopefully
"This user identified Pisillo as one of the best options in FiDi for an Italian sandwich, given the original poster's location constraint."
PositiveFrom post: Best Italian Sandwich Below 14th Street Hopefully
"This user pointed out that the original poster had already excluded Pisillo's from their request."
NeutralFrom post: Best Italian Sandwich Below 14th Street Hopefully
"This commenter suggested Pisillo's Italian panini in FiDi. However, the original poster explicitly excluded this restaurant."
NeutralFrom post: Lunch Spots Near Freedom Tower Battery Park
"This user seconded the recommendation for Pisillo's, suggesting eating there in the park on a nice day."
PositiveFrom post: Lunch Spots Near Freedom Tower Battery Park
"Pisillo's was mentioned as a place to get great Italian panini in Zucotti Park."
PositiveFrom post: Lunch Spots Near Freedom Tower Battery Park
"Pisillo's was praised for its large Italian sandwiches, with one sandwich being equivalent to two meals."
PositiveFrom post: Lunch Spots Near Freedom Tower Battery Park
"Pisillo's was highly recommended for Italian sandwiches, suggesting one sandwich could be shared."
PositiveFrom post: Breakfastlunch Carts And Coffee In Fidi
"The existence of a Pissilos Panini location on Nassau Street is mentioned."
Neutral