Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (212) 227-3104
Address: 97 NASSAU STREET 10038
Authentic, enormous Italian sandwiches that redefine value and flavor.
Pisillo Italian Panini is a hidden gem in New York City, serving up some of the most authentic and generously portioned Italian sandwiches you'll find. Nestled in the Financial District, this spot is a favorite among locals looking for a hearty and delicious lunch. Their sandwiches are renowned for their sheer size, often requiring sharing, and are packed with high-quality cured meats and fresh ingredients. Fan favorites like the 'Roma' and 'Cagliari' showcase their commitment to traditional Italian flavors, making Pisillo a must-visit for any sandwich aficionado.
Pisillo Italian Panini is celebrated for its massive and authentic Italian sandwiches, featuring cured meats and Italian ingredients. Standout options include the 'Roma' with porchetta and smoked mozzarella, and the 'Cagliari' with soppressata and provolone. While the quality is consistently high, customers often note that the sandwiches are so large that they are best shared.
"The 'Roma' sandwich, featuring porchetta, smoked mozzarella, arugula, and roasted peppers, is a recommended simpler option. The 'Cagliari,' with soppressata, artichokes, provolone, and hot spread, is also a frequently cited favorite."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Pisillo Italian Panini for its authentic Italian sandwiches, often describing them as enormous and a great value. Many consider it a top-tier sandwich spot in NYC, with some even comparing it favorably to Italian delis in other major cities.
Important Note
The sandwiches are exceptionally large, often too much for one person to finish, making them ideal for sharing. Some customers find them a bit pricey if not sharing.
"Psillios is listed among several establishments in the Bronx that offer an authentic Italian deli experience."
Positive"The user recommended Psillios as a sandwich spot in NYC."
Neutral"Sharing a giant sandwich from Pisillo with a friend is highly recommended as a 10/10 experience."
Positive"A giant sandwich from Pisillo costs $20, and while delicious, it's so heavy that one person can typically only eat half, making it potentially costly if not shared."
Neutral"The user highly recommends Pisillo on Nassau Street for a "real NY lunch," specifically suggesting their giant sandwiches, which are noted as being more expensive than meals in Taipei."
Positive"Pistillo is described as a well-known old-school Italian sandwich shop located right by Fulton Street in FiDi."
Positive"Pisillo sandwiches are described as massive and very filling, even if split."
Neutral"A commenter likes Pisillo but doesn't find it notable or a destination spot for tourists, suggesting it's good and satisfying if convenient, like near a workplace."
Negative"The user highly recommends Pisillo's, located on Nassau Street near Wall Street, for its Italian sandwiches. They believe the quality surpasses any Italian sandwich shop found in the Greater Toronto Area."
Positive"Known for large, affordable Italian sandwiches. The "Roma" with porchetta, smoked mozzarella, arugula, and roasted peppers is a simpler option, while the "Cagliari" with soppressata, artichokes, provolone, and hot spread is a favorite."
Positive"Recommends Pisillo as a great spot for huge, old-school Italian-American sandwiches, mentioning they have 2 locations. Notes that American-Italian sandwiches may differ from those in Italy."
Positive"A user recommended Pisillo's located in FiDi as a potential 'best kept secret' spot."
Positive"Commenter recommends getting a sandwich from Pisillo."
Positive"Recommended for Italian sandwiches, with a warning that the portions are enormous."
Positive"Pisillo is phenomenal but they’re more cold/cured Italian meats than chicken parm and the like."
Positive"There’s Pisillo near the Brooklyn bridge Manhattan side"
Neutral
