Massive, old-school Italian-American sandwiches w/ huge portions & quality cured meats. A must-try deli experience!
Step into Pisillo Italian Panini and prepare for a sandwich experience unlike any other. This Financial District gem is celebrated for its colossal, old-school Italian-American sandwiches, offering a true taste of tradition. Expect generous portions packed with high-quality cured meats and flavorful cheeses, making each bite a satisfying journey.
Pisillo Italian Panini is renowned for its enormous, traditional Italian-American sandwiches. Customers rave about the quality of the cured meats and the sheer size of the portions, with many suggesting they can feed two people. Specific recommendations include the 'Roma' with porchetta and the 'Cagliari' with soppressata, though the '26' sandwich is also a standout. While generally loved, some note the sandwiches are very filling and perhaps best shared.
"Highly recommended are the 'Roma' sandwich featuring porchetta, smoked mozzarella, arugula, and roasted peppers, and the 'Cagliari' with soppressata, artichokes, provolone, and hot spread. The '26' sandwich is also singled out as a top-tier option."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the restaurant for its massive, high-quality Italian sandwiches, with many noting the generous portions and authentic flavors. The value and taste make it a highly recommended spot.
Important Note
Some customers find the sandwiches to be very large and filling, potentially being too much for one person. Additionally, one older comment mentioned it used to be cash-only.
"The existence of a Pissilos Panini location on Nassau Street is mentioned."
Neutral"The commenter recommends Pisillo in Fidi, stating that while Faicco's is good, Pisillo holds a special place in their heart."
Positive"Pisillo's is highly recommended for huge, authentic Italian panini by this user."
Positive"Pisilo is recommended for deli subs by this user."
Positive"Pisillo's is recommended for getting rolls and deli items that can be individually packaged to assemble later, with options for dressing."
Positive"The commenter expressed strong approval for Pisillo's, describing their sandwiches as amazing and very large."
Positive"Pisillo's, located at Nassau and Ann, was recommended."
Neutral"Pisillo is mentioned as having multiple locations, including Midtown, Chelsea, and FiDi."
Positive"Pisillo's sandwiches are described as massive and very good, and the commenter noted it used to be cash only."
Positive"This commenter noted that Pisillo has a location on 38th Street in addition to others."
Neutral"Pisillo is recommended as a top choice for Italian sandwiches, particularly if the user is near Wall Street."
Positive"This user created a Google Maps list of recommended Italian sandwich spots, including Pisillo."
Positive"Pisillo is recommended as a top spot for Italian sandwiches."
Positive"The user listed Pisillo's '26' sandwich as one of the best they've tried."
Positive"This commenter stated that the restaurant's sandwiches are very good and large, often lasting for multiple meals."
Positive"The user found the website for this restaurant and expressed that the sandwiches look delicious."
Positive"This user provided a link to the restaurant's website and encouraged others to enjoy it."
Positive"Psillios is listed among several establishments in the Bronx that offer an authentic Italian deli experience."
Positive"The user recommended Psillios as a sandwich spot in NYC."
Neutral"Sharing a giant sandwich from Pisillo with a friend is highly recommended as a 10/10 experience."
Positive
