Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (212) 227-3104
Address: 97 NASSAU STREET 10038
Huge, old-school Italian sandwiches w/ quality cured meats. Portions are massive—easily shareable!
This Italian sandwich shop is renowned for its enormous, old-school Italian-American sandwiches. Reviewers frequently praise the generous portions, with many noting that a single sandwich can easily feed two people. While some see it as a satisfying and convenient lunch option, others highlight specific favorites like the 'Roma' with porchetta and the 'Cagliari' with soppressata, both lauded for their quality ingredients.
This establishment specializes in large, old-school Italian-American sandwiches, with a particular focus on cured meats. Popular choices include the 'Roma' with porchetta, smoked mozzarella, arugula, and roasted peppers, and the 'Cagliari' featuring soppressata, artichokes, provolone, and hot spread. The sandwiches are consistently described as massive, often large enough for two people to share.
"The 'Roma' sandwich, featuring porchetta, smoked mozzarella, arugula, and roasted peppers, and the 'Cagliari' with soppressata, artichokes, provolone, and hot spread are frequently recommended."
Customers rave about the enormous portions and quality of Italian cured meats used in their sandwiches. While the sandwiches are generally well-loved for their size and taste, some note they can be pricey if not shared.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that the sandwiches can be quite expensive if not shared, and one older comment mentioned it might have been cash only.
"Pisillo's is highly recommended for huge, authentic Italian panini by this user."
Positive"Pisilo is recommended for deli subs by this user."
Positive"Pisillo's is recommended for getting rolls and deli items that can be individually packaged to assemble later, with options for dressing."
Positive"The commenter expressed strong approval for Pisillo's, describing their sandwiches as amazing and very large."
Positive"Pisillo's, located at Nassau and Ann, was recommended."
Neutral"Pisillo is mentioned as having multiple locations, including Midtown, Chelsea, and FiDi."
Positive"Pisillo's sandwiches are described as massive and very good, and the commenter noted it used to be cash only."
Positive"This commenter noted that Pisillo has a location on 38th Street in addition to others."
Neutral"Pisillo is recommended as a top choice for Italian sandwiches, particularly if the user is near Wall Street."
Positive"This user created a Google Maps list of recommended Italian sandwich spots, including Pisillo."
Positive"Pisillo is recommended as a top spot for Italian sandwiches."
Positive"The user listed Pisillo's '26' sandwich as one of the best they've tried."
Positive"This commenter stated that the restaurant's sandwiches are very good and large, often lasting for multiple meals."
Positive"The user found the website for this restaurant and expressed that the sandwiches look delicious."
Positive"This user provided a link to the restaurant's website and encouraged others to enjoy it."
Positive"Psillios is listed among several establishments in the Bronx that offer an authentic Italian deli experience."
Positive"The user recommended Psillios as a sandwich spot in NYC."
Neutral"Sharing a giant sandwich from Pisillo with a friend is highly recommended as a 10/10 experience."
Positive"A giant sandwich from Pisillo costs $20, and while delicious, it's so heavy that one person can typically only eat half, making it potentially costly if not shared."
Neutral"The user highly recommends Pisillo on Nassau Street for a "real NY lunch," specifically suggesting their giant sandwiches, which are noted as being more expensive than meals in Taipei."
Positive
