TLDR
Iconic, social media-famous burgers meet unique, non-traditional pizza at this beloved Brooklyn neighborhood staple.
Details
Renowned for its iconic, social media-famous burger and distinctive pizza offerings, this Clinton Hill institution became a staple of the local food scene [8]. While some fans adore its unique culinary identity, others note that the pizza deviates from traditional NYC-style slices [1]. The original Fulton Street location is a well-regarded destination near Barclays Center, frequently praised as a go-to spot for food and drinks in the neighborhood [5][3].
The Emily burger is widely considered an iconic, must-try dish, though its generous size makes it a perfect candidate for sharing [4].
Overall sentiment is largely positive, with many diners hailing the burger as a must-try experience [4][8]. However, opinions on the pizza are mixed, as some purists find it distinct from classic NYC-style expectations [1][12].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01emily burger (brooklyn)3 mentions
- 02burger3 mentions
Caveats
Some visitors note that the restaurant's unique pizza style is not representative of traditional NYC-style pizza [1]. Additionally, the popular burger is quite large and often recommended to be shared [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EMMY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Based On Taste Alone Which Of These Food Options
"It is noted that the original location of this restaurant in Clinton Hill is closing soon."
NeutralFrom post: Based On Taste Alone Which Of These Food Options
"The reviewer mentions having tried the burger there, noting it was not a double stack."
NeutralFrom post: The Original Emily Location In Clinton Hill Is
"A dissenting opinion stating that the restaurant has always been overrated."
NegativeFrom post: The Original Emily Location In Clinton Hill Is
"The commenter remembers the restaurant as an early "instagrammable" spot that felt like a spiritual successor to Franny's. They note that the restaurant was successful despite being in a quiet part of Fulton street."
PositiveFrom post: The Original Emily Location In Clinton Hill Is
"The user reports a positive experience with the burger from a 2022 visit and inquires about the pizza quality."
Positive