TLDR
Fresh-caught seafood meets a laid-back, market-style vibe. Ideal for lobster rolls, oysters, and seasonal bites in the heart of Brooklyn.
Reddit Sentiment for GREENPOINT FISH & LOBSTER CO.(based on 12 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co. serves a "really good lobster roll," which is a highlight for the reviewer. The post also notes a debate between 'Team Mayo' (Parker, the boyfriend) and 'Team Butter' (the reviewer) regarding lobster rolls. The restaurant also appears to serve raw fish/sashimi. The outdoor seating with string lights adds to the ambiance.
This establishment offers a very large portion of lobster roll, served with a pickle spear and a side of fries. While the meat quantity was impressive, the roll lacked sufficient salt in both the butter and the meat itself, diminishing the flavor balance. A clever workaround was to combine the lobster claw with a French fry to add saltiness and crunch.
Greenpoint Fish Co. collaborated with Chambers NYC and Raf's NYC for a dining event that the author found spectacular. The menu showcased various seafood preparations.
Details
This dual-purpose fish market and restaurant offers a convivial atmosphere perfect for casual dining [1]. Guests enjoy a variety of high-quality seafood, ranging from fresh oysters to expertly prepared lobster rolls and seasonal specialties [2], [3]. While some diners view it as an authentic local staple rooted in its origins as a market, others characterize it as a stylish destination for those exploring Brooklyn [4], [5].
Food Overview
The menu features fresh, American-style seafood including oysters [5], lobster [4], and sashimi [2]. Diners have highly recommended the soft crab and ramp sandwich [2], the flaky fish sandwich [1], and the lobster roll [2]. While the lobster roll is noted for its generous portion size, some diners feel it occasionally lacks proper seasoning [3].
Caveats
Some patrons find the restaurant to be a bit overpriced for the value provided, and others feel the "fish market" aspect is more decorative than functional [5]. Additionally, those seeking saltier flavors might find the seasoning on items like the lobster roll to be subtle [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About GREENPOINT FISH & LOBSTER CO.
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Should We Go For An Oystercentric Date Night
"Described as fantastic with a variety of good food options."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find Whole Oysters For Shucking In
"In response to a critique of Greenpoint Fish & Lobster, this user points out that the establishment started as a market before adding a restaurant."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Find Whole Oysters For Shucking In
"This commenter describes Greenpoint Fish & Lobster as a "hipster spot" with a "faux fish market" as window dressing."
NegativeFrom post: Where Can I Find Whole Oysters For Shucking In
"This user expresses enthusiasm for Greenpoint Fish & Lobster, noting they weren't aware of a fish market component."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find Whole Oysters For Shucking In
"This commenter suggests Greenpoint Fish & Lobster as a place to obtain oysters."
Neutral