TLDR
Elevated pub fare & craft drinks. Casual yet refined spot, great for dates or a chill night out.
The chicken confit is frequently recommended as a must-try dish if it is available on the menu.
Customers consistently recommend this establishment for its great food and drinks, suggesting it's a reliable choice for a quality dining experience.
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01chicken confit2 mentions
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About HAYMAKER BAR & KITCHEN
Haymaker is highly recommended by multiple users for its great food and drinks, with a specific mention of the chicken confit being a standout dish.
This spot is suggested as an appropriately casual and great option for a first meeting, indicating a welcoming and relaxed atmosphere.
Haymaker Bar is recommended as a superior alternative to options directly within Penn Station, noted for being a better choice located on 29th street.
The restaurant is highlighted for its excellent draft beer selection, making it a noteworthy spot for those who appreciate craft brews.
Haymaker is recommended as a place to eat in the Penn Station area, suggesting it's a convenient and good option for a meal.
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Quick Lunch In Penn Station Area
"Haymaker is recommended as a place to eat."
PositiveFeb 4, 2026View Comment →
From post: Help Me Find A Plan C
"Suggests Haymaker, highlighting its excellent draft list near MSG."
PositiveDec 26, 2025View Comment →
From post: Best Eats Near Msg
"Haymaker is recommended for its great food and drinks."
PositiveNov 12, 2025View Comment →
From post: Best Eats Near Msg
"Haymaker is described as amazing, with a specific recommendation for the chicken confit."
PositiveNov 11, 2025View Comment →
From post: Best Eats Near Msg
"Haymaker is listed as a recommendation."
NeutralNov 11, 2025View Comment →