Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (212) 861-2434
Address: 1559 2 AVENUE 10028
Old-school Italian pizza with a modern twist; known for its authentic flavors and a unique, albeit polarizing, gnocchi dish.
This Italian eatery offers a taste of classic Italian flavors with a contemporary edge, making it a noteworthy spot for pizza lovers. The star of their menu appears to be the pizza, which has been recommended for its authentic yet updated style. However, a daring culinary experiment, a gnocchi dish served in a pizza bread bowl, has become a viral sensation on Reddit. While many commenters humorously critique its perceived high price and unconventional presentation, the dish has also garnered a few defenders who appreciate its unique, albeit carb-heavy, nature. For those seeking a more traditional experience, the pizza is a safe and highly regarded bet, embodying the restaurant's commitment to quality Italian cooking.
The restaurant is praised for its Italian cuisine, particularly its pizza, which is described as old-school with modern twists. One specific dish, gnocchi served in a pizza bread bowl, has generated significant online discussion. While many find it overpriced and visually unappealing, some users humorously embrace it as a unique culinary experience. However, the general consensus leans towards the pizza being a more reliable and recommended choice.
"The pizza is consistently recommended for its old-school Italian style with modern twists."
Customers generally have positive feedback for this Italian restaurant, with specific praise for its pizza. There are some mixed opinions and humorous commentary surrounding a particular gnocchi dish, with some finding it overpriced and unappealing, while others appreciate the novelty.
Important Note
The $15 gnocchi dish served in a pizza bread bowl has received significant negative feedback for its perceived high price and unappealing appearance, though some users humorously acknowledge its novelty.
"San Matteo is recommended for pizza."
Positive"Recommends San Matteo on the UES."
Positive"User thinks the dish sounds gross and contains too many carbs."
Negative"User believes the dish contains only "$3 of food"."
Negative"User states they'd be in a "carb coma" after this meal."
Neutral"The user jokes about the meal being served with British "Chip Bitty" and rocks."
Neutral"User expresses that although there's much judgement for this dish, they'd still order it, enjoying "culinary folly"."
Positive"User questions the value proposition of paying $15 for pasta in "cooked bland dough"."
Negative"User sarcastically questions if the bread bowl is fully baked."
Negative"Expresses disgust at the look of the dish."
Negative"The user humorously refers to the combination of gnocchi and a bread bowl as a "big back" thing."
Neutral"Sarcastically asks if the dish is carb-free."
Neutral"The user expresses that $15 is too expensive for this dish, referring to it as a "$6 snack" and "crazy"."
Negative"States the dish looks like "crap"."
Negative"The user jokingly asks if the dish comes with mashed potatoes."
Neutral"San Matteo for old school Italian style with modern twists"
Neutral
