TLDR
Authentic Neapolitan pizza & unique cheese wheel pasta. Local hype is real for this UES Italian gem.
Reddit Sentiment for SAN MATTEO PIZZERIA E CUCINA(based on 11 Reddit opinions)
Details
This Italian spot on the Upper East Side is praised for its Neapolitan pizza and its unique cheese wheel pasta dishes [1], [2]. While many enjoy the pizza, one user found the crust too dry and the mushrooms canned, noting it wasn't a perfect match for their desired Neapolitan style [3]. However, the restaurant is considered a strong contender for authentic Neapolitan pizza in the area [4].
Food Overview
Known for its authentic Neapolitan pizza and a unique cheese wheel pasta dish, San Matteo is a popular Italian eatery. While most reviews are positive, one diner found the pizza crust to be too dry and the mushrooms canned [3]. Despite this, it's frequently recommended for its pizza, with some suggesting it's one of the closest matches for Neapolitan style on the Upper East Side [4]. The restaurant also reportedly offers a unique burger [5].
Highlights / Recommended
"The restaurant is highly recommended for its pizza, particularly the Neapolitan style, and also offers a unique pasta dish tossed in a cheese wheel."
Customer Sentiment
Customers generally have positive experiences, highlighting the quality of the pizza and pasta, though some specific critiques regarding pizza crust and mushroom toppings have been noted [3].
Caveats
One reviewer experienced issues with the pizza crust being too dry and noted the use of canned mushrooms, suggesting it may not be a perfect match for all seeking authentic Neapolitan style [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SAN MATTEO PIZZERIA E CUCINA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Napolitanostyle Pizza On Ues Similar
"This user recommended San Matteo (specifically the Cucina location at 1559 2nd Ave) along with Donna Margherita."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For Napolitanostyle Pizza On Ues Similar
"This user stated that if limiting options to the Upper East Side (UES), San Matteo is likely one of the closest matches to what the original poster is seeking. They haven't found anything on the UES that truly satisfies the same craving as Motorino."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For Napolitanostyle Pizza On Ues Similar
"The user tried San Matteo and found it to be good and close to what they were looking for, but not quite the perfect match. The crust was too dry and not chewy enough, and the mushrooms were canned."
NegativeFrom post: Looking For Napolitanostyle Pizza On Ues Similar
"This user simply mentioned San Matteo."
NeutralFrom post: Walkin Only For Valentines
"This Neapolitan pizza and Italian restaurant on the UES is suggested as a walk-in option for Valentine's Day. The commenter notes that it's a family-owned 'mom & pop' establishment."
PositiveFrom post: Best Burger In The Ueseast Harlem Not Looking For
"San Matteo had a unique but good burger the last time the commenter visited, suggesting it's worth trying even though it's not primarily a burger place."
PositiveFrom post: Sit Down Pizza Restaurants
"This user recommended San Mateo, mentioning its two locations on 2nd Ave and stating the local hype is real."
PositiveFrom post: This Is So Dumb But I Kind Of Want Pasta Thats
"This commenter has historically enjoyed their experiences at San Mateo."
PositiveFrom post: This Is So Dumb But I Kind Of Want Pasta Thats
"San Mateo on the Upper East Side offers pasta tossed in a cheese wheel."
PositiveFrom post: Italian Restaurants Near The Met
"San Matteo is mentioned as a suggestion."
PositiveFrom post: White Pizza Recommendation That Uses Buffalo
"San Matteo is recommended for pizza."
Positive