Last Updated: ~2 months ago
Phone: (212) 861-2434
Address: 1559 2 AVENUE 10028
Authentic Italian pies & classic pasta dishes. Modern twists on old-school faves.
Experience authentic Italian flavors with a modern twist at this beloved New York City pizzeria and trattoria. Known for its classic Neapolitan pizzas and hearty pasta dishes, it offers a cozy atmosphere perfect for any occasion. While many rave about the pizza, some dishes have sparked humorous and critical debate online.
This Italian restaurant is celebrated for its authentic pizzas, with a specific nod to Neapolitan style. While many dishes are well-received, a recent $15 gnocchi dish served in a bread bowl has become a point of humorous online debate, with some questioning its value and appearance, while others playfully embrace its "culinary folly."
"The restaurant is frequently recommended for its authentic pizzas, especially Neapolitan style, and also offers pasta dishes."
Customers generally praise the authentic Italian offerings, particularly the pizza, though some recent dishes have humorously drawn mixed reactions and discussions about value.
Important Note
Some online commentary humorously critiques the value and presentation of specific dishes, such as the $15 gnocchi in a bread bowl.
"San Matteo had a unique but good burger the last time the commenter visited, suggesting it's worth trying even though it's not primarily a burger place."
Positive"This user recommended San Mateo, mentioning its two locations on 2nd Ave and stating the local hype is real."
Positive"This commenter has historically enjoyed their experiences at San Mateo."
Positive"San Mateo on the Upper East Side offers pasta tossed in a cheese wheel."
Positive"San Matteo is mentioned as a suggestion."
Positive"San Matteo is recommended for pizza."
Positive"Recommends San Matteo on the UES."
Positive"User thinks the dish sounds gross and contains too many carbs."
Negative"User believes the dish contains only "$3 of food"."
Negative"User states they'd be in a "carb coma" after this meal."
Neutral"The user jokes about the meal being served with British "Chip Bitty" and rocks."
Neutral"User expresses that although there's much judgement for this dish, they'd still order it, enjoying "culinary folly"."
Positive"User questions the value proposition of paying $15 for pasta in "cooked bland dough"."
Negative"User sarcastically questions if the bread bowl is fully baked."
Negative"Expresses disgust at the look of the dish."
Negative"The user humorously refers to the combination of gnocchi and a bread bowl as a "big back" thing."
Neutral"Sarcastically asks if the dish is carb-free."
Neutral"The user expresses that $15 is too expensive for this dish, referring to it as a "$6 snack" and "crazy"."
Negative"States the dish looks like "crap"."
Negative"The user jokingly asks if the dish comes with mashed potatoes."
Neutral
