Next.js logo

VILLAGE SQUARE PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (917) 369-0184

Address: 147 WEST 35 STREET 10001

View on Google Maps

TLDR

High-quality, no-wait pizza alternative to NYC's most crowded spots. Featuring signature slices like vodka and hot honey pepperoni.

Reddit Sentiment for VILLAGE SQUARE PIZZA(based on 8 Reddit opinions)

75% Positive25% Negative

Tags

italian 5american 3pizza 2pizza 7View All

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Instagram Posts References

For a quick and easy lunch, the author visited Village Square Pizza. They found the pepperoni pizza to be a bit too greasy for their liking, stating that one slice was sufficient.

Village Square Pizza is described as the author's 'drunk eats mecca' and is consistent with their Prince Street-style pizza. They recommend the vodka or pepperoni with hot honey.

Village Square Pizza is listed among the premier pizza places in NYC, recognized as a spot that is 'worth the hype' for pizza enthusiasts.

Details

Village Square Pizza is widely recognized as a top-tier destination for pizza enthusiasts, often celebrated for its ability to deliver quality slices without the excessive wait times associated with other popular NYC spots [1], [5]. While many patrons view it as a must-visit for classic and creative styles alike [6], [7], some guests have expressed concerns regarding value and consistency [2], [8]. Overall, it remains a go-to for those seeking a convenient, high-quality pizza experience [4], [5].

Food Overview

The menu focuses on classic New York-style pizza, with popular choices including the plain pie and specialty slices [3], [6]. While the vodka and pepperoni with hot honey are highly recommended by fans [7], others have noted that some slices can lean towards the greasier side [8].

Highlights / Recommended

The vodka pizza and the pepperoni pizza with hot honey are frequently highlighted as standout menu items [7].

Customer Sentiment

Sentiment is generally positive, with many diners appreciating the efficient service and consistent quality [1], [5]. However, some critics feel the pricing is high for the experience provided [2], [8].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About VILLAGE SQUARE PIZZA

https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1p6g0qe/i_asked_this_sub_for_the_best_pizza_rec_and_got/
This post highlights the restaurant as a great option for those looking to avoid long waits found at other popular pizzerias.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1vzfd60/mamas_too_in_nyc_has_some_of_my_favorite_slices/
The shop is recommended here as a superior, line-free alternative to other trendy pizza spots.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1wgca8x/pizza_options_for_a_group_of_25_in_a_week_and_a/
The commenter specifically endorses the plain pie as a great choice.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Pizza Options For A Group Of 25 In A Week And A

"The commenter notes that the plain pie at this restaurant is great."

Positive
Sep 14, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Pizza On The Upper East Side Just Moved To

"Recommended as a pizza option."

Positive
Sep 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: Mamas Too In Nyc Has Some Of My Favorite Slices

"The user recommends this shop as a cheaper, line-free alternative to Mama's Too."

Positive
Aug 30, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of

"This user felt The Village Pizza was overpriced for the quality, with a slice costing $6 and not living up to the hype."

Negative
May 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: I Asked This Sub For The Best Pizza Rec And Got

"The user recommended Village Square Pizza as a good option without a long wait, in contrast to other popular but time-consuming places."

Positive
Nov 25, 2025View Comment →

Often mentioned with Village Square Pizza

More in Midtown

See all

More Italian in NYC

See all