Next.js logo

HARTLEY'S

Updated

Phone: (347) 799-2877

Address: 14 PUTNAM AVENUE 11238

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Cozy Clinton Hill pub w/ lively atmosphere, must-try popcorn with Irish cheddar, and Guinness stew.

Reddit Sentiment for HARTLEY'S(based on 12 Reddit opinions)

67% Positive25% Neutral

Tags

irish 2View All

Neighborhoods

Clinton Hill

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
The Best Irish Pubs in NYC
positive

A small but lively Clinton Hill pub where groups gather for Guinness, known for its delicious, mountain-sized popcorn with Irish cheddar.

Bryan Kim • Date unknown
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

Hartley's is a cozy Clinton Hill pub renowned for its lively atmosphere and Irish cuisine [1]. While small in size, it frequently accommodates large groups enjoying Guinness and offers a low-key setting perfect for dates or quiet evenings [1]. A unique standout is their mountain-sized popcorn, generously topped with Irish cheddar, which pairs perfectly with a pilsner [1].

Food Overview

Hartley's offers Irish cuisine with standout dishes like a 'mountain-sized' popcorn generously topped with Irish cheddar, described as expertly salted and a must-order [1]. They also serve Guinness stew, recommended for sharing, and a simple yet satisfying grilled cheese [1].

Highlights / Recommended

"The popcorn with Irish cheddar is a must-order, described as a mountain of expertly salted kernels generously topped with finely grated Irish cheddar [1]. The Guinness stew and grilled cheese are also recommended as satisfying options [1]."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally recommend Hartley's, describing it as a cozy and lively pub with an impeccable vibe [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7]. However, it's noted that the establishment can become quite crowded, especially due to its popularity [3], [4], [5], [6].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About HARTLEY'S

Where are your favorite cozy, quaint NYC pubs/bars?
Several users recommend Hartley's as a cozy and quaint pub, noting its good vibes and suitability for quiet evenings. Some mention it can get crowded, possibly due to its popularity.
Welcome to the Irish Pub-aissance: The New Irish
One user identifies Hartley's as a top-tier Irish pub, noting its popularity and tendency to be crowded.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars

"Hartleys immediately came to mind for the commenter when thinking of cozy bars."

Positive
Jun 19, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars

"Hartleys is recommended."

Positive
Jun 18, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars

"The commenter notes that Hartleys has become very crowded, possibly due to social media, and misses when it was easier to get a seat."

Neutral
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars

"Hartleys in Brooklyn is recommended for its cozy vibe, though it can get crowded."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars

"The commenter states they started going to Hartleys when it opened and found the vibes impeccable, though it can be crowded now."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars

"The commenter notes that Hartley's used to be a proper neighborhood bar but is now often crowded, possibly due to popularity."

Neutral
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars

"Hartleys in Clinton Hill is recommended."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars

"Hartleys is identified as the bar that fits the description."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars

"Hartleys is recommended."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Welcome To The Irish Pubaissance The New Irish

"In response to a comment about Hartley's, this user notes that Hartley's also tends to be "crazy crowded.""

Neutral
Jan 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: Welcome To The Irish Pubaissance The New Irish

"This user identifies Hartley's as possibly the best Irish pub they've been to recently and notes that Grace's is always very crowded."

Positive
Jan 15, 2026View Comment →

More in Clinton Hill

See all

More irish in NYC

See all