TLDR
Legendary NYC deli serving iconic, massive pastrami sandwiches. A must-try classic experience located right inside MSG.
The legendary Carnegie Deli is signaling a return to its historic Midtown block, sparking excitement among New York deli enthusiasts about the potential comeback of this classic institution.
Will Hartman reviews Carnegie Deli, a beloved Jewish deli with a presence at Madison Square Garden, praising its classic pastrami sandwich.
Details
This legendary institution, now famously located within Madison Square Garden, continues to serve its signature, oversized pastrami sandwiches to crowds of hungry New Yorkers and visitors [1]. Known for keeping the tradition of classic Jewish delis alive, it offers an authentic experience that anchors its place in the city's culinary history [1], [3]. Beyond the arena, the brand remains a sought-after staple, with discussions about its potential full-scale revival keeping fans hopeful for a return to its roots [3].
Food Overview
Specializing in traditional Jewish deli fare, the menu is defined by its massive, high-quality pastrami and corned beef sandwiches [3], [5]. While the pastrami on rye is considered an essential, must-try item [1], the deli is also celebrated for its knishes, chopped liver, and iconic cheesecake [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CARNAGIE DELI - FB8150
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Gotos For Cheesecake In The Upper East Sideupper
"Mentioned the reopening of the deli."
NeutralFrom post: Can Someone Explain The Difference Between A
"A patron's Jewish father was denied mayonnaise for his pastrami sandwich at Carnegie Deli by the waitress, highlighting a perceived taboo."
NegativeFrom post: Can Someone Explain The Difference Between A
"Carnegie Deli is listed as a famous Jewish deli in NYC, comparable to Katz's, known for its expensive but large pastrami sandwiches."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Restaurants I Miss
"This user lists Carnegie Deli as a missed restaurant."
NeutralFrom post: Food At Madison Square Garden
"States that the Carnegie Deli pastrami inside MSG is a good deal and priced similarly to a standard pastrami sandwich outside, based on a late 2023 visit."
PositiveFrom post: Food At Madison Square Garden
"Recommends the Carnegie Deli pastrami inside MSG as legit good and a good value, especially if arriving an hour before the event."
Positive