Iconic Jewish deli known for its legendary pastrami on rye, a must-try NYC culinary experience.
Will Hartman reviews Carnegie Deli, a beloved Jewish deli with a presence at Madison Square Garden, praising its classic pastrami sandwich.
This classic Jewish deli is renowned for its generous portions and a standout pastrami sandwich, often hailed as the 'platonic ideal'. While some diners have had less savory experiences, like a memorable unappetizing cheeseburger, the overall sentiment leans positive, especially for its iconic offerings.
This Jewish deli is celebrated for its classic American fare, with the pastrami sandwich on rye being a standout, often described as the pinnacle of its kind. While most feedback centers on the quality of the pastrami, one recollection mentions an unappetizing, oversized cheeseburger. Despite the latter, the deli's traditional offerings are generally well-received.
"The pastrami on rye sandwich is highly recommended, with one user describing it as the 'platonic ideal' of such a dish."
Customer sentiment is mixed, with strong praise for classic deli items like pastrami, but some negative memories of other dishes. Overall, the nostalgic and iconic nature of the establishment garners significant positive attention.
Important Note
The original Carnegie Deli location has closed, but a presence remains within Madison Square Garden.
"This user lists Carnegie Deli as a missed restaurant."
Neutral"States that the Carnegie Deli pastrami inside MSG is a good deal and priced similarly to a standard pastrami sandwich outside, based on a late 2023 visit."
Positive"Recommends the Carnegie Deli pastrami inside MSG as legit good and a good value, especially if arriving an hour before the event."
Positive"The commenter expresses anger and sadness that Carnegie Deli has closed."
Negative"User fondly remembers the thinly sliced and griddled pastrami on rye at Carnegie Deli, describing it as the 'platonic ideal' of its kind."
Positive"User recalls a childhood experience at Carnegie Deli where they found it 'kinda gross.' They specifically remember an unappetizing cheeseburger that was large, unseasoned, and had an excessive amount of American cheese."
Negative"User recounts a past conversation at Carnegie Deli where fellow diners, visiting NYC, commented that their sandwich meal was surprisingly one of the cheapest they'd had in the city. This was despite acknowledging that other, even cheaper, food options exist."
Neutral
