Iconic NYC deli, known for HUGE pastrami sandwiches & matzo ball soup. Less chaos than Katz's, more authentic vibe.
Sarge's Deli is a classic Jewish deli in Manhattan, often compared to Katz's but with its own loyal following. It's lauded for its generous portions and authentic New York deli experience, offering a less chaotic alternative to its more famous counterpart. Many patrons consider it a go-to for classic deli fare.
Sarge's is celebrated for its traditional Jewish deli fare, with a particular emphasis on its pastrami sandwiches, which are frequently compared to those at Katz's. Patrons also rave about the matzo ball soup, corned beef, latkes, and BLTs. While the majority of feedback is positive, one negative review mentioned dry pastrami and watery coleslaw.
"Sarge's is highly recommended for its pastrami sandwiches, matzo ball soup, corned beef, and BLTs. The latkes and cheesecake also receive positive mentions."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards Sarge's, praising its authentic deli experience, generous portions, and delicious classic dishes, especially pastrami sandwiches and matzo ball soup. While most find it a great alternative to more crowded spots, a few have had negative experiences with specific dishes or service.
Important Note
One user found the pastrami sandwiches to be overpriced and disappointing, while another mentioned that the restaurant is no longer open 24 hours.
"This user recommended Sarges, noting it's a bit further uptown but a personal favorite."
Positive"Sarge's was recommended as a good option for kosher brisket, and also for non-kosher brisket."
Positive"The original poster indicated they would go taste-test Sarge's, having not been there in a long time."
Neutral"In response to a question about brisket quality, this commenter stated that Sarge's has really good brisket and matzo balls, and is generally better for takeout than 2nd Ave Deli."
Positive"The original poster asked for clarification on whether Sarge's brisket is considered better, given the option to not require it to be kosher."
Neutral"This commenter recommended Sarge's Deli, especially if the brisket does not need to be kosher."
Positive"Sarges is mentioned as a restaurant recommendation."
Neutral"The commenter suggested Sarge's."
Neutral"Mentions 'Matzo ball, corner beef' in response to a comment about Sarge's, implying a positive association."
Positive"Enthusiastically describes Sarge's corned beef as 'magical'."
Positive"Lists Sarge's as a notable deli but suggests pastrami might be the better choice there compared to corned beef."
Neutral"Lists Sarge's among other popular delis like Junior's and Katz's."
Neutral"Recommends Sarge's, stating a preference for their corned beef over their pastrami, though both are considered good."
Positive"This user stated that Sarge's Deli still provides generous portions for its sandwiches."
Positive"The user finds Sarge's pricey but particularly enjoys their 'souper soup'."
Positive"The user believes Sarge's Deli has the best NYC cheesecake and confirms they ship via Goldbelly."
Positive"Defends Sarge's as a favorite of long-time New Yorkers and not just a tourist spot, acknowledging Katz's popularity but preferring Sarge's food, sides, and desserts."
Positive"Argues that Sarge's is often recommended by those trying to appear knowledgeable about non-touristy spots, contrasting it with Katz's."
Negative"This user strongly advocates for Sarge's, calling it the absolute best deli in Manhattan for eat-in, pickup, or delivery."
Positive"This user disagrees with Sarge's being a top deli, stating it's overpriced and not as good as Katz's."
Negative
