Renowned pastrami sandwiches and comforting matzo ball soup, serving as a relaxed alternative to more bustling delis.
This classic deli is a beloved spot for traditional Jewish fare, especially its highly-rated pastrami sandwiches that rival more famous counterparts. Visitors often find it a more relaxed and equally satisfying alternative to busier, iconic delis. It's also a go-to for comforting dishes like matzo ball soup and hearty latkes.
The restaurant is highly praised for its deli offerings, particularly its pastrami sandwiches, which are frequently compared to and recommended as a strong alternative to those at Katz's Deli. Other standout items include matzo ball soup and latkes. While overwhelmingly positive, one review mentioned pastrami sandwiches being overpriced and disappointing.
"The pastrami sandwich is a highly recommended signature dish, often praised as being on par with or better than more famous delis. Matzo ball soup and latkes are also frequently mentioned as favorites."
Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, often recommending it as a great alternative to more crowded establishments like Katz's Deli. The pastrami sandwich and matzo ball soup are frequently highlighted as favorites.
Important Note
One customer found the pastrami sandwiches to be overpriced and disappointing.
"Sarge's Deli is mentioned as a place that offers good pastrami, alongside Second Avenue Deli."
Positive"Sarge's Deli is mentioned as a top choice for Corned Beef."
Neutral"Sarge's, another previously 24-hour establishment, has changed its hours to be open from 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM."
Neutral"Sarge's Deli is suggested as a place worth stopping by for lunch."
Positive"Pastrami sandwiches from Sarge's Deli were considered overpriced at over $60 for two and ultimately disappointing, with a cheaper pastrami breakfast bagel from a corner shop tasting better."
Negative"Sarge's Delicatessen is recommended for great pastrami sandwiches, which are considered similar to and on the same tier as Katz's, making them potential picnic material."
Positive"This deli is recommended as a dining option located within a 20-minute walk of Gramercy Park."
Neutral"Sarge's Deli is recommended specifically for its pastrami."
Positive"Sarge's pastrami is described as good, specifically noting its thin-cut style."
Positive"Sarge's Deli is recommended as a good place for pastrami on rye in Manhattan."
Positive"Sarge's Deli is recommended for pastrami as a good option if one needs to stay in Manhattan. Its pastrami is noted for being thin-cut, but still good."
Positive"The commenter plans to try Sarge's, indicating an interest in trying traditional deli regional favorites."
Neutral"Sarge's Deli is suggested as an alternative option to Katz's Deli."
Positive"User mentions Sarge's Delicatessen as a 'decent' alternative when they are unable to go to Katz's."
Positive"Suggests Sarge's Deli as a convenient midtown option for a Jewish deli experience."
Positive"The author recommends Sarge's as an alternative deli, particularly when discussing options like Pastrami Queen and Katz's."
Positive"Recommends Sarge's."
Positive"Mentions Sarge's as a deli they have yet to try."
Neutral"Mentioned hearing good things about Sarge's."
Positive"Suggests Sarge's as a good alternative spot to Katz's for a pastrami sandwich."
Positive
