Iconic NYC Jewish deli w/ huge pastrami sandwiches & matzo ball soup. A true taste of the city, minus the crowds.
This classic Jewish deli offers an authentic New York experience, reminiscent of iconic establishments but with its own unique charm. It's a go-to for hearty sandwiches, comforting soups, and traditional deli fare, providing a satisfying meal in a no-frills setting. The generous portions and classic flavors make it a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike.
This establishment is celebrated for its traditional Jewish deli fare, with a particular emphasis on its pastrami sandwiches, which are frequently compared to, and often preferred over, those at more famous delis. Other highly recommended items include matzo ball soup, corned beef, latkes, and cheesecake. While most feedback is positive, one negative review found the pastrami dry and the coleslaw watery.
"Pastrami sandwiches are a standout, with many recommending them as comparable or superior to other famous delis. Matzo ball soup, corned beef, latkes, and cheesecake also receive frequent praise."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards this deli, frequently praising its authentic New York feel, generous portions, and high-quality classic dishes like pastrami sandwiches and matzo ball soup.
Important Note
One review mentioned pastrami sandwiches being overpriced and disappointing, and another noted that the restaurant is no longer open 24 hours.
"The commenter suggested Sarge's."
Neutral"Mentions 'Matzo ball, corner beef' in response to a comment about Sarge's, implying a positive association."
Positive"Enthusiastically describes Sarge's corned beef as 'magical'."
Positive"Lists Sarge's as a notable deli but suggests pastrami might be the better choice there compared to corned beef."
Neutral"Lists Sarge's among other popular delis like Junior's and Katz's."
Neutral"Recommends Sarge's, stating a preference for their corned beef over their pastrami, though both are considered good."
Positive"This user stated that Sarge's Deli still provides generous portions for its sandwiches."
Positive"The user finds Sarge's pricey but particularly enjoys their 'souper soup'."
Positive"The user believes Sarge's Deli has the best NYC cheesecake and confirms they ship via Goldbelly."
Positive"Defends Sarge's as a favorite of long-time New Yorkers and not just a tourist spot, acknowledging Katz's popularity but preferring Sarge's food, sides, and desserts."
Positive"Argues that Sarge's is often recommended by those trying to appear knowledgeable about non-touristy spots, contrasting it with Katz's."
Negative"This user strongly advocates for Sarge's, calling it the absolute best deli in Manhattan for eat-in, pickup, or delivery."
Positive"This user disagrees with Sarge's being a top deli, stating it's overpriced and not as good as Katz's."
Negative"Mentions Sarge's alongside 2nd Ave Deli as a recommended option."
Positive"Sarges is mentioned as a dining option."
Positive"Sarges is recommended as a place to eat."
Positive"Sarge's Deli was recommended, and the commenter also praised their pastrami, corned beef, chicken soup, bagels, challah, and cheesecake."
Positive"This commenter recommends Sarge's pastrami sandwich on rye with mustard, and also mentions their chocolate mousse cake."
Positive"This commenter recommends Sarge's pastrami sandwich on rye with mustard, and also mentions their chocolate mousse cake."
Positive"The commenter enjoys Sarge's Deli for its pastrami, coleslaw, and pickles, appreciating the lack of crowds compared to Katz's."
Positive
