Classic NYC Jewish deli w/ huge pastrami sandwiches & no long lines. Your go-to for authentic deli comfort food.
Sarge's Deli is a classic New York Jewish deli that offers a less chaotic alternative to iconic spots like Katz's. It's praised for its generous portions and a menu filled with traditional deli staples. Whether you're craving a perfectly crafted pastrami sandwich, comforting matzo ball soup, or delicious latkes, Sarge's delivers a satisfying and authentic deli experience. It stands out as a reliable go-to for classic deli fare.
Sarge's is a beloved Jewish deli known for its hearty and traditional offerings. The pastrami sandwich is a standout, often compared favorably to Katz's, with some finding Sarge's to be a more pleasant experience. Other highly recommended items include matzo ball soup, latkes, and BLTs. While generally well-regarded, one negative review mentioned pastrami sandwiches being overpriced and disappointing.
"Sarge's is highly recommended for its pastrami sandwiches, matzo ball soup, latkes, and BLTs. Customers often suggest it as a superior or comparable alternative to more crowded delis for these classic dishes."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Sarge's, frequently recommending it as a great alternative to more crowded delis for classic dishes like pastrami and matzo ball soup.
Important Note
One reviewer found the pastrami sandwiches to be overpriced at over $60 for two and ultimately disappointing compared to a cheaper option from a corner shop.
"This commenter suggested Sarge's, noting they have 'pirogen' with a deep-fried option that are described as 'evil but magical, soft and gooey inside'."
Positive"Sarge's Deli was recommended as a breakfast spot."
Neutral"Sarge's Deli was listed as a recommendation."
Neutral"Sarge's Deli in Midtown is preferred by the commenter over Katz's."
Positive"The user prefers 2nd Avenue Deli over Katz's and notes its proximity to Sarge's."
Neutral"The user acknowledges the distinction in pastrami slicing between Sarge's and Katz's."
Neutral"The user clarifies that Sarge's offers thinly sliced pastrami, while Katz's offers thick-sliced, appealing to different preferences."
Neutral"The user compares Sarge's pastrami to Katz's, stating Sarge's is a solid alternative if one wants to avoid the long queues at Katz's, though they personally find Katz's slightly better."
Neutral"The user asks if Sarge's pastrami sandwich is better than Katz's."
Neutral"The user recommends Sarge's pastrami sandwich."
Positive"This user recommended Sarge's as a potential option for the original poster if they are in midtown Manhattan, also mentioning soups and knishes."
Positive"This user suggested Sarge's as a place to try Pastrami on rye, an old Jewish cuisine, which the original poster mentioned they may try."
Positive"Sarge's was mentioned as having good matzo ball soup and cheesecake, along with good service. The user found Katz's meat slices preferable to Sarge's."
Positive"The user inquired about Sarge's in comparison to Katz's, noting a picture of Sarge's looked good and expressing interest if it was a good experience."
Neutral"Sarge's Deli is mentioned as a place that offers good pastrami, alongside Second Avenue Deli."
Positive"Sarge's Deli is mentioned as a top choice for Corned Beef."
Neutral"Sarge's, another previously 24-hour establishment, has changed its hours to be open from 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM."
Neutral"Sarge's Deli is suggested as a place worth stopping by for lunch."
Positive"Pastrami sandwiches from Sarge's Deli were considered overpriced at over $60 for two and ultimately disappointing, with a cheaper pastrami breakfast bagel from a corner shop tasting better."
Negative
