Authentic NYC Jewish deli w/ huge pastrami sandwiches, no crazy lines. Great matzo ball soup & BLTs too!
This classic New York deli is a go-to for many seeking an authentic and less chaotic alternative to more famous establishments. Known for its generous portions and traditional Jewish deli fare, it offers a satisfying experience for lunch or any time of day. The atmosphere is often described as welcoming, making it a comfortable spot for a hearty meal.
This establishment excels in traditional Jewish deli fare, with pastrami sandwiches being a frequent highlight and often compared favorably to more famous counterparts. Other popular items include matzo ball soup, latkes, and BLTs. While most feedback is positive, one reviewer found the pastrami dry and overpriced.
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, often recommending it as a solid alternative to more crowded delis, praising the quality and portion sizes of their classic sandwiches and soups.
"Sarges is proposed as another option for a more chill, sit-down Jewish deli or diner experience, similar to 2nd Ave Deli."
Positive"Suggests not visiting both Sarge's Deli and Katz's Deli in the same trip, as one pastrami sandwich from either would be sufficient."
Neutral"Sarge's was recommended as an option for chicken noodle soup."
Positive"Sarge's Deli in Midtown was mentioned as a comparable option to Katz's, suggesting it is a traditional deli."
Neutral"This user mentions Sarge's as a preferred deli, alongside Yonah Schimmel's for knishes."
Positive"This comment recommends Sarge's Deli."
Positive"Sarge's Deli is recommended."
Positive"Sarge's Deli on 3rd Ave is recommended."
Positive"This commenter had a very negative experience at Sarge's, describing their pastrami sandwich as dry and flavorless, and citing rude service and watery coleslaw as further drawbacks."
Negative"The author loves Sarge's for its delicious food and lack of Katz's upcharge."
Positive"The author states Sarge's is not as good as Katz's but still very good and delivers more easily."
Neutral"This Texan commenter preferred Sarge's over Katz's during their NYC trips and is looking forward to returning."
Positive"This commenter recommends Pastrami Queen for a pastrami sandwich with chopped liver and coleslaw, finding it delicious and avoiding the lines at other establishments."
Neutral"This commenter affirms that Sarge's is authentic and not a tourist trap."
Positive"While preferring Katz's for pastrami, the author finds Sarge's to be a solid all-around place with good food, particularly recommending their apple strudel with vanilla ice cream."
Positive"After living in NYC for 20 years, this commenter finds Sarge's pastrami good and less hectic than Katz's, also mentioning Liebmans as another great option."
Positive"This commenter mentions 'Deli Wellington' and 'souper soup' as items from Sarge's."
Neutral"The author recommends the pastrami sandwich with cherry peppers at S&P."
Neutral"This commenter, along with other locals, prefers Sarge's over Katz's, praising their pastrami and corned beef, and also recommends their soup and stuffed cabbage."
Positive"The author finds Sarge's pastrami on rye delicious and appreciates being able to get seated quickly, especially noting the quality of their pickles."
Positive
