TLDR
Massive, thinly-sliced pastrami and traditional Jewish deli comforts in a classic, no-fuss Midtown setting.
Instagram Posts References
The post features a visit to Sarges Delicatessen, evidenced by an interior shot displaying a deli counter and a menu, as well as an exterior view from the street. The main culinary highlight from this stop is a massive pastrami sandwich, generously piled high, indicative of a classic New York deli experience. The implied sentiment is very positive, showcasing a quintessential NYC food stop.
Sarge's Deli showcases a classic, generously portioned deli sandwich. The sandwich, cut in half, reveals layers of sliced meat, melted cheese, and green peppers, wrapped in traditional deli paper, emphasizing its authentic New York deli experience and substantial size.
Details
Renowned for its massive, thinly sliced pastrami sandwiches [8], [16], this classic NYC deli is often championed as a superior, less crowded alternative to more tourist-heavy competitors [12], [17], [21]. Beyond the meat, diners frequently praise the comforting matzo ball soup and rich cheesecake [3], [18], [28]. It is widely regarded as a staple for a traditional Jewish deli experience in Midtown [5], [24].
Food Overview
The menu centers on high-quality Jewish deli staples, with the pastrami being the most discussed and debated item; supporters love the thin, generous slices, though some find it dry compared to other icons [8], [9], [21], [25]. Other highly recommended items include the matzo ball soup, corned beef, and cheesecake [3], [16], [21], [28], [41]. Avoidance of specific items is minimal, though preferences between thick and thin-sliced meats remain a point of subjective debate [9], [21].
Highlights / Recommended
"The pastrami on rye is the definitive recommendation, often enjoyed with pickles and mustard [18], [28], [47]. Other highly regarded choices include the matzo ball soup, corned beef, and their classic cheesecake [3], [21], [28], [41]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •pastrami(14)
- •pastrami sandwich(9)
- •pickles(6)
- •pastrami on rye(3)
- •corned beef(2)
- •matzo ball soup(2)
- •cheesecake(2)
- •deli wellington(2)
- •coleslaw(2)
- •pastrami sandwich on rye with mustard(2)
- •chocolate mousse cake(2)
Customer Sentiment
Feedback is largely positive, with many diners appreciating the generous portions and authentic, non-touristy atmosphere [17], [21], [23]. While most celebrate the deli as a reliable local favorite, a minority of customers have reported inconsistent quality, specifically noting dry pastrami or flavorless sides in rare instances [25], [34].
Caveats
The establishment is no longer open 24 hours, which some long-time patrons find disappointing compared to its historical status [16], [19]. Additionally, it can be viewed as pricey by some visitors who prioritize value [32], [45].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SARGE'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Listed as a casual option."
NeutralFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Mentioned as a restaurant in the area."
NeutralFrom post: Iso Best Medium Budget Dinner Near Hotel 50 Bowery
"Mentioned as another classic deli spot for a pastrami sandwich."
PositiveFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"This user lists Sarge's Deli as a place that exceeded expectations."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter simply recommended 'Sarge's'."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter recommended Sarge's as a sandwich option."
PositiveFrom post: Any Typical Americanstyle Breakfast Recommendation
"Sarges is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Some Great Potato Or Macaroni Salad
"The commenter tried Sarge's Deli's macaroni salad and found it to be a positive experience (4/5). The pasta was not mushy, with minimal, well-seasoned mix-ins, and a creamy, not overly mayo-heavy sauce. They plan to try other delis and diners."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can A Guy Get A Pastrami For Some Athome
"The commenter personally likes Sarge's Deli."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can A Guy Get A Pastrami For Some Athome
"Sarge's is mentioned as a place to buy whole pastrami for at-home sandwiches."
NeutralFrom post: Seeking Restaurants Near 34th And Broadway
"Sarge's Deli offers various food types, and customization for dietary restrictions might be possible. Second Avenue Deli nearby is also suggested."
PositiveFrom post: Seeking Restaurants Near 34th And Broadway
"Sarge's Deli is recommended, located between 36th and 37th on 3rd Avenue."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user recommended Sarge's Deli for its large pastrami sandwiches."
PositiveFrom post: Im On A Soft Food Diet For A Couple Weeks It
"Sarge's Deli was listed as a place for soup."
NeutralFrom post: Whats The Nontouristy Cheesecake Factory Of Nyc
"Sarge's was listed among other diner recommendations."
NeutralFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"This user listed Sarge's as a place to start for hot dogs."
PositiveFrom post: Another Pancake Question I Know Dont Hate Me
"Sarges is mentioned as a place that has 'it all'."
NeutralFrom post: Sabrett Natural Casing Hotdogs
"This user recommended Sarge's deli as a place to get a kosher hot dog, suggesting it as an alternative to street carts."
PositiveFrom post: Whats A Restaurant Youve Eaten At Recently That
"This user gave Sarge's in Murray Hill an honorable mention for lunch, in addition to recommending Suhk in Fort Greene."
NeutralFrom post: Whats A Restaurant Youve Eaten At Recently That
"This user gave Sarge's in Murray Hill an honorable mention for lunch, in addition to recommending Suhk in Fort Greene."
Neutral