TLDR
Classic Italian bakery serving legendary cookies and authentic pastries. The neighborhood go-to for top-tier sweets and Italian ice.
Details
This beloved neighborhood bakery is a go-to spot for authentic Italian treats and classic desserts in Brooklyn. Customers rave about the high quality of their traditional pastry offerings [1] and stellar cookie selection [14]. Whether you are hunting for the perfect cheesecake [28] or a quick Italian ice, this shop consistently hits the mark for locals [2].
Food Overview
Specializing in traditional Italian baked goods, the menu features standout items like sfogliatelle [1], ricotta cookies [14], and lemon drops [29]. Customers also highly recommend their cheesecake [28] and Italian ice [2], [3]. While rainbow cookies are a popular choice [6], [13], patrons have noted that they can be heavier than expected when purchasing by weight [9].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended treats include the sfogliatelle, ricotta cookies, lemon drops, and classic Italian ice [1], [2], [14], [29]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •italian ice(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons hold this bakery in high regard, frequently praising the authentic quality of its treats and the accommodating nature of the staff regarding custom orders [4], [14], [29]. The consensus is that it is a welcoming place to purchase even small quantities of cookies without any pressure [4], [7], [20].
Caveats
Newcomers to traditional Italian bakeries should be aware that rainbow cookies can be heavier than they appear, which may impact the price when paying by weight [9].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About COURT PASTRY SHOP
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Can I Find Good Italian Bakery Cookies In
"The commenter strongly prefers this shop, highlighting specific cookies."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Classic Cheesecake In Nyc
"This user listed Court Pastry Shop as one of several recommended cheesecake places."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter advised that customers can ask for any number of cookies, specifying quantities for each type if they are priced differently, or requesting a single cookie."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter mentioned that one can order by the quarter pound and that tipping is not necessary when purchasing cookies."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter advises that if unsure about ordering at bakeries, it's polite to ask about minimums or if items can be mixed. They noted that staff deal with various issues and appreciate reasonable questions."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter shared a personal anecdote about learning that rainbow cookies can be heavier than expected when ordering them for the first time."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter stated that they usually buy about three cookies from Regina's bakery."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter expressed surprise that someone would ask Reddit for advice on buying a few cookies from a bakery."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"In response to a comment about using clear language when ordering, this user simply agreed."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter suggested stating a desired total weight (e.g., 'about a pound') to help the staff choose a box size, then listing specific cookies and their quantities. They recommend continuing to add cookies and asking for the current weight until the desired amount is reached."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter humorously suggested using clear language when ordering, implying that bakery staff are accustomed to customer interactions."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter expressed that while initial anxiety about ordering is understandable, bakeries are accustomed to customers who may not know the process, encouraging learning for future visits."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter reassured that customers can order a few cookies without issue, as they are either priced individually or weighed and are very inexpensive."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter confirmed that customers can order the desired number of cookies and stated that tipping is always recommended, suggesting 10-15% for takeout and at least 20% for appreciation."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter jokingly suggested using the phrase 'Whatever works' when ordering."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter advised that customers can simply ask for the specific number of cookies they want, such as one of a particular type and two of another."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter explained that customers can request specific quantities of each cookie type (e.g., two of one, three of another), and the bakery will weigh them all together in a box."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter suggested announcing the number of cookies to help staff with bag/box selection, then pointing out desired types and quantities, and finally asking about the total weight. Tipping well is recommended for recognition."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter mentioned that they typically buy about five cookies for themselves from Court Street Bakery without any problems."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter stated they always order by the piece without issues and that the cookies at Court Street Bakery are amazing, with ricotta cookies being their favorite."
Positive