TLDR
Art Deco landmark serving top-tier martinis and a signature tavern-style burger in a classic, relaxed Brooklyn atmosphere.
Reddit Sentiment for THE LONG ISLAND BAR(based on 59 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The Long Island Bar is known for its Fried Cheese Curds, a classic and crowd-pleasing bar snack.
Long Island Bar, a beloved Brooklyn cocktail bar, has gained recognition for its dry-aged-style tavern burger, which has become a destination in itself.
The Long Island Bar is featured as a prime spot in NYC for enjoying a high-quality burger and martini, embodying the classic New York dining experience.
Details
Located in an Art Deco landmark in Cobble Hill, this beloved spot is widely recognized for its diner-casual atmosphere and status as a quintessential "bartender's bar" [3]. It features a concise food menu highlighted by a signature double-patty tavern burger [3], [7] and high-quality cocktails, including an acclaimed frozen cosmo [1], [5], [6]. While many diners flock here for the nostalgic vibe and excellent martinis [3], [7], opinions are divided regarding the atmosphere and the value of certain menu items [5].
Food Overview
The concise menu centers on American bar fare, with the dry-aged-style tavern burger receiving both high praise and criticism for its value and texture [3], [5], [7]. Popular starters include the fried cheese curds [5] and heavily breaded, mustard-paired fries [4], while the drink menu is anchored by expertly crafted martinis and creative frozen cocktails like the piña colada [3], [5], [6].
The double-patty burger [3], fried cheese curds [5], and the signature martinis or frozen cocktails [3], [5] are frequently highlighted as must-orders.
Feedback is polarized; while many patrons praise the nostalgic ambiance and standout cocktails [3], [5], others find the venue overcrowded, rushed, and expensive for the quality offered [5].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01burger12 mentions
- 02cheese curds5 mentions
- 03frozen cosmo2 mentions
- 04piña colada2 mentions
- 05long island gimlet2 mentions
- 06martinis2 mentions
Caveats
Some visitors report that the space can become loud, crowded, and occasionally feel like an "absolute finance bro shit show" during peak hours [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE LONG ISLAND BAR
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Restaurants You Keep Going Back To Any
"Brief recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Some Restaurants And Bars That Tony
"Suggested for its old-school vibe and good martinis."
PositiveFrom post: The Long Island Bar Brooklyn
"This commenter suggests Inga's burger is superior and closer than Swoony's for a better burger experience."
NegativeFrom post: The Long Island Bar Brooklyn
"This commenter criticized the burger at The Long Island Bar for having a mushy bottom bun and a pale, uncrusted patty."
NegativeFrom post: The Long Island Bar Brooklyn
"This user suggested a dining strategy: have a four-course meal at Lillo's for dinner and then move to The Long Island Bar for drinks, highlighting the comparative cost-effectiveness."
Neutral