Classic Brooklyn red-sauce Italian & pizza, revivied for a new era. A neighborhood gem w/ iconic pizza oven & cocktails.
After nearly a century, Sam's pizzeria, a beloved Brooklyn institution, is being revitalized by Georgia Fulton. The new owner aims to preserve the classic red-sauce Italian experience while updating the space and menu.
Sam's, a Brooklyn institution since 1930, is undergoing a revitalization led by Georgia Fulton. While preserving its classic red-sauce Italian roots and iconic pizza oven, Fulton is updating the space and streamlining the menu. This beloved neighborhood gem aims to continue its legacy with a renewed focus on great food and classic cocktails.
Sam's is celebrated for its traditional Italian-American fare, with pizza and chicken parm being highly recommended. While the menu has been streamlined, classic dishes are expected to remain a focus, though customers have noted that the unpredictable opening hours can make it difficult to enjoy them.
"Customers frequently recommend the pizza and chicken parm. Other noted favorites include baked clams and a pepperoni garlic pie."
Customers have high praise for the classic Italian-American offerings, particularly the pizza and chicken parm, though the restaurant is known for its unpredictable hours.
Important Note
The restaurant is known for its unpredictable opening and closing hours, which can be a source of frustration for potential customers. There is also a mention of the restaurant potentially not accepting credit cards.
"This commenter responded to a query about Lou's involvement, stating the article does not mention it but agreeing that Lou was a significant factor in the restaurant's positive dining experience."
Positive"The commenter inquired if Lou would be involved in the reopening of Sam's, expressing affection for him as a host."
Positive"The commenter believes the place was barely open under prior ownership, suggesting the changes are for the best as long as they stay true to some of the restaurant's roots."
Neutral"The commenter enjoyed Sam's and Lou when they lived in the area, and personally always went for the pizza. They seem to think the announced changes are positive."
Positive"The commenter liked Sam's when they visited but hopes they will start accepting credit cards, as they don't want to deal with carrying cash or using an ATM with children."
Neutral"This commenter is generally wary of revamping classic restaurants but is glad to hear that Sam's is not changing too much and that the old pizza oven is staying. They also mention that the article doesn't specify if Lou will be involved, but he was a huge part of what made the restaurant great."
Neutral"Mentions Sam's as part of a potential crawl around Carroll Gardens while waiting for a Lucali reservation."
Neutral"States that Sam's appears to be never open."
Negative"Comments on the difficulty of determining when Sam's is open."
Neutral"Briefly mentions Sam's on Court Street as a pizza option."
Positive"The commenter recommends Sam's in Cobble Hill, giving it a positive endorsement with an emoji."
Positive"A long-time neighborhood resident described Sam's as their favorite pizza in the area, noting its random hours and summer closure. They mentioned a Manhattan (pizza), baked clams, and a pepperoni garlic pie from Sam's as part of their ideal last NYC meal."
Positive"Recommends Sam's on Court St for its great pizza and food, but notes that the owner operates with unpredictable opening hours."
Positive
