Beloved Brooklyn spot known for its incredible pizza & chicken parm. A classic Italian-American experience, but check hours!
Nestled in Brooklyn, Sam's Restaurant is a beloved neighborhood gem that has garnered a loyal following for its classic Italian-American fare. Patrons consistently rave about their pizza, with specific mentions of a 'Manhattan pizza' and a 'pepperoni garlic pie' that make it a go-to spot for many. The chicken parm also receives high praise. While the food consistently impresses, be aware that Sam's is known for its rather unpredictable operating hours, with the owner sometimes closing early due to slow nights or even for summer breaks. Despite this caveat, many consider it a top-tier spot for authentic flavors.
Sam's Restaurant is highly recommended for its Italian-American cuisine, with particular highlights being their pizza and chicken parm. Several patrons have specifically mentioned the pizza as a favorite, with one even listing a 'Manhattan pizza' and 'pepperoni garlic pie' as part of their ideal last meal. Baked clams are also mentioned positively. The food is generally described as great, with one commenter noting it as a solid classic spot.
"The pizza and chicken parm are highly recommended, with specific mentions of a 'Manhattan pizza' and 'pepperoni garlic pie' as standout dishes."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Sam's Restaurant, frequently praising its pizza and chicken parm. However, a recurring concern is the restaurant's unpredictable opening hours, which have led to disappointment for some patrons.
Important Note
The restaurant is known for its unpredictable opening hours. Patrons have reported instances of the owner closing early due to slow business or even for summer breaks, which can be a point of frustration.
"The commenter recommends Sam's in Cobble Hill, giving it a positive endorsement with an emoji."
Positive"A long-time neighborhood resident described Sam's as their favorite pizza in the area, noting its random hours and summer closure. They mentioned a Manhattan (pizza), baked clams, and a pepperoni garlic pie from Sam's as part of their ideal last NYC meal."
Positive"Recommends Sam's on Court St for its great pizza and food, but notes that the owner operates with unpredictable opening hours."
Positive"A commenter recommends Sam's Restaurant on Court Street (near Court Pastry Shop) as another solid classic spot."
Positive"A commenter recounts a recent experience where the owner of Sam's closed early due to a slow night, highlighting the issue of unpredictable hours."
Neutral"A Brooklyn native lists Sam 's on Court St as one of their personal top 10 regular spots."
Positive"A commenter confirms that Sam's unpredictable opening hours are indeed a problem."
Negative"A commenter points out that Sam's unpredictable opening hours can be a problem."
Negative"A commenter highly recommends Sam's on Court Street for its underrated pizza and chicken parm, noting the rest of the food is great too."
Positive
