Next.js logo

SAM'S RESTAURANT

Updated

Phone: (718) 596-3458

Address: 238 COURT STREET 11201

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Underrated pizza & chicken parm, a true neighborhood gem with classic Italian-American eats. Be mindful of its famously unpredictable hours!

Reddit Sentiment for SAM'S RESTAURANT(based on 7 Reddit opinions)

57% Positive29% Neutral14% Negative

Tags

italian 6italian-american 4american 2pizza 5View All

Neighborhoods

Cobble Hill

Details

A beloved neighborhood classic, this Italian-American spot is celebrated for its outstanding pizza and chicken parm. While the food receives high marks, it's important to note that the restaurant is known for its unpredictable opening hours, with some patrons experiencing unexpected closures. Despite this quirk, many consider it a go-to for classic Italian-American fare and a nostalgic dining experience.

Food Overview

The food at this Italian-American establishment is a major draw, with particular praise for its pizza and chicken parm. Many consider these dishes to be some of the best in the area. While the menu generally receives positive attention, the primary caveat revolves around the restaurant's notoriously inconsistent operating schedule.

Highlights / Recommended

"Customers highly recommend the pizza and chicken parm, with specific mentions of a Manhattan pizza, baked clams, and a pepperoni garlic pie."

Customer Sentiment

Customers rave about the delicious pizza and chicken parm, often calling it a standout in the neighborhood. However, a recurring theme in feedback is the restaurant's unpredictable opening hours, which can be a point of frustration.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About SAM'S RESTAURANT

Hole in the wall restaurants in Brooklyn?
A commenter highly recommends this restaurant on Court Street for its underrated pizza and chicken parm, stating that the rest of the food is also great.
Lucali
A long-time resident describes this place as their favorite pizza spot in the area, mentioning a Manhattan pizza, baked clams, and a pepperoni garlic pie as part of their ideal last NYC meal.
Best unpretentious classic Italians (pasta or pizza)?
A recommendation for this Court Street restaurant specifically highlights its great pizza and food, while also noting the owner's unpredictable operating hours.
Hole in the wall restaurants in Brooklyn?
A Brooklyn local lists this Court Street establishment among their personal top 10 favorite regular spots.
Historic Food Tour of NYC
A commenter suggests this Court Street restaurant as another solid, classic option in the neighborhood.
My brother wants to eat like Tony Soprano in NYC
This Cobble Hill spot receives a positive endorsement from a commenter.
Hole in the wall restaurants in Brooklyn?
Multiple commenters point out that the unpredictable opening hours of this restaurant are a significant issue.
Pizza suggestions Boerum Hill
This Court Street restaurant is mentioned as a pizza option, though another comment suggests it appears to be never open.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Pizza Suggestions Boerum Hill

"Mentions Sam's as part of a potential crawl around Carroll Gardens while waiting for a Lucali reservation."

Neutral
Feb 25, 2026View Comment →

From post: Pizza Suggestions Boerum Hill

"States that Sam's appears to be never open."

Negative
Feb 23, 2026View Comment →

From post: Pizza Suggestions Boerum Hill

"Comments on the difficulty of determining when Sam's is open."

Neutral
Feb 21, 2026View Comment →

From post: Pizza Suggestions Boerum Hill

"Briefly mentions Sam's on Court Street as a pizza option."

Positive
Feb 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: My Brother Wants To Eat Like Tony Soprano In

"The commenter recommends Sam's in Cobble Hill, giving it a positive endorsement with an emoji."

Positive
May 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Lucali

"A long-time neighborhood resident described Sam's as their favorite pizza in the area, noting its random hours and summer closure. They mentioned a Manhattan (pizza), baked clams, and a pepperoni garlic pie from Sam's as part of their ideal last NYC meal."

Positive
May 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Unpretentious Classic Italians Pasta Or Pizza

"Recommends Sam's on Court St for its great pizza and food, but notes that the owner operates with unpredictable opening hours."

Positive
May 12, 2025View Comment →