TLDR
Classic NYC bagels w/ traditional prep. Known for everything bagels, though fillings can be overpowering.
Details
This establishment offers a classic New York bagel experience, with a strong emphasis on traditional preparations. While some patrons find the bagels to be a good foundation, others have noted that certain fillings can overwhelm the bagel itself. Despite mixed reviews on freshness and quality compared to its past reputation, it remains a notable spot for bagels in the area.
Food Overview
The focus is on traditional bagels, particularly the everything bagel, which is often recommended. However, there are recurring comments about the fillings being too generous, detracting from the bagel itself. Some users have expressed that the quality has declined compared to its earlier days, with one user describing the bagels as 'dogshit'.
Caveats
Some customers feel the quality has declined significantly from its past reputation, and fillings can be overwhelming.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About H&H MIDTOWN BAGELS EAST
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Bagels On The Upper West Side
"This user described H&H bagels as 'dogshit'."
NegativeFrom post: Bagels On The Upper West Side
"This user stated that H&H is a pale shadow of its former self."
NegativeFrom post: Where To Go After Absolute Bagels Closed
"The commenter mentions H&H on Columbus as a bagel option."
NeutralFrom post: One Week In Nyc
"Everything bagel with club filling had a good bagel but too much filling."
Neutral