TLDR
Burgers & cheesesteaks galore! Known for legit Philly cheesesteaks & peanut butter burgers. Great fries too.
Details
Whitman's is a popular American eatery known for its bar food vibes and sit-down dining experience. Customers frequently praise their delicious burgers, especially the peanut butter burger, and highly recommend their Philly cheesesteaks, with some even calling them the best in the city [1], [2]. The fresh-cut fries are also a notable highlight, complementing the overall relaxed atmosphere [3].
Food Overview
Whitman's offers a menu of American bar food, with burgers and cheesesteaks being standout items. The peanut butter burger and the Philly cheesesteak have garnered significant praise, with some users declaring the latter as the best in NYC. Fresh-cut fries are also frequently mentioned as a positive aspect of the dining experience.
Caveats
While Whitman's is frequently praised, one user noted that their cheesesteaks, despite being excellent, don't receive enough attention [1]. Another commenter mentioned the original location on 9th Ave between 1st and A.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About WHITMANS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Burgers Should I Eat During A Week Off From
"Mentioned Whitmans as having interesting burgers."
PositiveFrom post: Peanut Butter Burger Does Any Restaurant Have A
"This comment also suggests Whitmans."
PositiveFrom post: Peanut Butter Burger Does Any Restaurant Have A
"This user agrees and likes the peanut butter burger from Whitmans."
PositiveFrom post: Peanut Butter Burger Does Any Restaurant Have A
"This commenter recommends Whitmans near Hudson Yards for a good peanut butter burger."
PositiveFrom post: Help Need Dinner Recs Near Javits For Party Of 8
"Whitman's was listed as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Help Need Dinner Recs Near Javits For Party Of 8
"Whitman's was mentioned as a cheap dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Cheese Steaks
"Replying to a comment, this user stated that Whitman's cheesesteaks receive 'no love' but are great."
PositiveFrom post: Cheese Steaks
"This commenter mentioned the original Whitman's location on 9th Ave between 1st and A."
NeutralFrom post: Cheese Steaks
"This commenter confirmed they had the cheesesteak at Whitman's the previous night and enjoyed it."
PositiveFrom post: Cheese Steaks
"This commenter recommended Whitmans in Hudson Yards for cheesesteaks."
PositiveFrom post: Is Danny Coops The Best Sandwich In Nyc
"This user identified Whitman's as the best cheesesteak in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Is Danny Coops The Best Sandwich In Nyc
"This user enthusiastically agreed about Whitman's, specifically mentioning the Hudson Yards location and positive experience with the bar and staff."
PositiveFrom post: Is Danny Coops The Best Sandwich In Nyc
"This user highlighted Whitman's for their cheesesteaks, stating it's one of the best they've ever had and surprisingly not talked about often."
PositiveFrom post: Good Place For Takeout In Manhattan On A Sunday
"User was considering takeout from Whitmans."
NeutralFrom post: Casual Solo Eats West Chelseahudson Yards
"Fresh cut fries are specifically mentioned as a positive aspect of Whitman's."
PositiveFrom post: Casual Solo Eats West Chelseahudson Yards
"The commenter loved everything at Whitman's, specifically mentioning the Philly cheesesteak as legit."
PositiveFrom post: Casual Solo Eats West Chelseahudson Yards
"Whitman's is praised for its great burgers and chill atmosphere."
PositiveFrom post: Casual Solo Eats West Chelseahudson Yards
"Whitman's is recommended for its bar food vibes in a sit-down setting."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Decent Food Options Near The Javits
"Whitmans was listed as a dining option near the Javits Center."
Neutral