Old-school Italian-American red sauce joint, celebrated for its classic ambiance and arguably the city's best meatballs.
Step into a timeless East Village gem that transports you to old-school New York with its classic Italian-American red sauce fare. This beloved spot is renowned for its authentic atmosphere and consistently praised dishes, including some of the city's best meatballs. Don't leave without trying their exceptional chocolate cheesecake, a delightful end to a truly traditional dining experience.
This establishment is highly recommended for its classic Italian-American cuisine, particularly its red sauce dishes. The meatballs are singled out as exceptional, and the chocolate cheesecake is noted as a standout dessert. It's described as a no-frills, old-school experience that appeals to those seeking traditional flavors.
"Customers highly recommend the meatballs and the chocolate cheesecake. The general consensus is to go for the classic red sauce Italian dishes."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, frequently recommending the restaurant for its classic Italian-American atmosphere and food. Some comments touch upon its history and authenticity, with one mention of a past cash-only policy being resolved.
Important Note
One user inquired about a past cash-only policy, which was later clarified as no longer being the case.
"This establishment was recommended as a red sauce joint similar to Bamonte's."
Neutral"This establishment was recommended as a red sauce joint similar to Bamonte's."
Neutral"Favors John's of 12th for its chocolate cheesecake, stating it surpasses Veniero's."
Positive"John's of 12th is described as excellent, a traditional red sauce spot with great ambiance due to its age."
Positive"A commenter expresses surprise that John's on 12th Street is still open."
Neutral"John's on 12th street is recommended as a dining option."
Neutral"The original poster is looking for a restaurant with a private room for approximately 55 people that can accommodate both vegan and non-vegan diners. They are considering Johns of 12th Street but are open to other suggestions."
Neutral"John's of 12th St is recommended."
Neutral"John's of 12th St is highly recommended as having the best meatballs in the city, emphasized as not being a touristy spot."
Positive"Johns of 12th is recommended as a classic American-Italian 'red sauce' restaurant."
Positive"Recommends John's of 12th St as an Italian dining option."
Positive"States that John’s of 12th St is no longer cash only, addressing a previous concern."
Neutral"Inquires if John’s of 12th St is still cash only, noting it was their only complaint. This implies the food/experience was otherwise good."
Neutral"Recommends John’s of 12th St in the East Village for its great food, atmosphere, and being non-touristy and not overpriced."
Positive"Recommends John's."
Positive"A commenter suggested John’s of East 12th St as a fun option that offers super-basic Italian dishes alongside more traditional ones, suitable for a picky eater."
Positive"The commenter recommends John’s of 12th Street as an old-school New York Italian restaurant, noting that Anthony Bourdain once visited."
Positive"Recommended as a tasty, no-frills southern Italian restaurant with a good old-school atmosphere."
Positive"if you want a classic old school red sauce place, John's of 12th Street."
Neutral"John ’s of 12th st mentioned."
Neutral
