TLDR
A historic, Sopranos-approved red sauce joint with a unique vegan menu. Perfect for those seeking old-school NYC nostalgia over trendy dining.
Reddit Sentiment for JOHN'S OF 12TH STREET(based on 92 Reddit opinions)
Details
Operating since 1908, this iconic East Village institution is beloved for its authentic, old-school mob-movie atmosphere and historic charm [13], [23], [24]. While many diners cherish the restaurant for its nostalgic ambiance, affordable pricing, and status as a classic red sauce destination [13], [24], [25], it has become a polarizing establishment. Critics frequently note that the culinary experience can be inconsistent, with some suggesting it is best enjoyed for the vibe rather than the food itself [40], [48], [54].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic Italian-American comfort food, notably featuring a separate vegan menu that includes creative plant-based options like seitan marsala and seitan parmesan [6], [10], [21]. While some diners enjoy staples like the lasagna and calamari [37], [47], [52], others warn against butter-based dishes and note that certain pastas can be underwhelming, suggesting the quality is best when sticking to traditional classics [47], [48], [50].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About JOHN'S OF 12TH STREET
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For An Old School Red Sauce Joint Similar
"Highly praised as a classic red sauce joint with a long history and good gravy."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For An Old School Red Sauce Joint Similar
"Recommended as a fitting old school Italian spot."
PositiveFrom post: Thoughts On Carmines For A Dinner During A Short
"A classic, good red sauce place recommended as an alternative to Carmine's."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian Recommendations Midtown East
"Does not think the food is good."
NegativeFrom post: Red Sauce Italian Recommendations Midtown East
"Fantastic and exactly what is needed for old school; great value."
Positive