TLDR
Authentic, old-school Italian red sauce joint in the Village. Reliable, historic, and non-touristy staple since 1918.
Reddit Sentiment for MONTE'S TRATTORIA(based on 37 Reddit opinions)
Details
A quintessential Greenwich Village institution, this restaurant has been serving classic Italian-American red sauce fare since 1918 [4]. It offers a nostalgic, old-school atmosphere that many diners find to be a refreshing, non-touristy choice for a reliable meal [14], [20]. The establishment is frequently praised for its authentic heritage, often drawing comparisons to other legendary family-run spots [25], [26].
Food Overview
This restaurant specializes in traditional, well-executed Italian-American red sauce dishes that diners describe as solid and dependable [4], [13]. While the menu is widely celebrated for its classic appeal, reviewers have highlighted specific standouts like their pasta and desserts [29].
Diners specifically recommend the Paglia e Fieno, the chicken cacciatore, and the pitch-perfect Zabaglione for dessert [29].
Patrons consistently laud the restaurant for its welcoming, classic atmosphere and authentic feel that manages to avoid being a tourist trap [14], [20]. While the vast majority of feedback is highly positive, some diners occasionally note that the food quality is merely average compared to other city recommendations [9].
Caveats
A small minority of diners have suggested that the food is not quite as impressive as other top-tier local Italian options, and one reviewer specifically advised against the restaurant [9], [36].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MONTE'S TRATTORIA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For An Old School Red Sauce Joint Similar
"The commenter strongly dislikes the restaurant and advises against it."
NegativeFrom post: Looking For An Old School Red Sauce Joint Similar
"A restaurant located in the Village that was suggested to the user."
NeutralFrom post: Thoughts On Carmines For A Dinner During A Short
"Suggested as a dining alternative."
NeutralFrom post: The Perfect Ontes Day Defontes Bamontes And
"Mentioned as part of a list of potential establishments to fit the themed challenge."
NeutralFrom post: The Perfect Ontes Day Defontes Bamontes And
"Suggested as a potential restaurant for the themed 'onte' crawl."
Neutral