TLDR
Classic brick-oven pies served in a breathtaking, historic church setting. A go-to spot for families and groups visiting Times Square.
Instagram Posts References
John's Pizza of Times Square is recommended by both Creator 1 and Creator 2 as a dining choice near the theatre district, suitable for pre-show or late-night meals.
Details
Located within a stunning converted old church, this iconic spot offers a unique atmosphere that elevates the dining experience [5]. It is widely recognized as a reliable, spacious destination for families and large groups looking for quality pizza in the heart of the theater district [3], [7], [19]. While some diners appreciate its consistent value and convenience [22], [27], others note that the overall quality may have fluctuated over time [25].
Food Overview
The restaurant specializes in classic, coal-oven, and brick-oven pizza that is widely considered a solid sit-down option in Midtown [7], [12]. While the menu is praised by many as a reliable crowd-pleaser, it is occasionally noted that better specialty pizza options may exist elsewhere in Manhattan [7], [17].
Caveats
The space can be quite loud, which may disrupt conversation if you are seated near the bar or entrance [6]. Some guests have also expressed concerns regarding the consistency of the food quality [25].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About JOHN'S PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Hole In The Wall Restaurants In The Theatre
"A brief recommendation for this specific location."
NeutralFrom post: Hole In The Wall Restaurants In The Theatre
"Recommended as a classic NYC food option for the visitor's mother."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For An Old School Red Sauce Joint Similar
"The commenter believes this restaurant has suffered from a decline in quality."
NegativeFrom post: Thoughts On Carmines For A Dinner During A Short
"Explicitly recommended as a better option than Carmine's."
PositiveFrom post: How Often Do You Eat Big Name Pizza Papa Johns
"Ordered occasionally when exhausted late at night due to the convenience of it being in the building."
Neutral