Coal-fired pizza in a former church! Great for groups & families. Classic NYC slice.
Nestled in a former church, this Times Square pizza joint offers a unique dining experience with its distinctive ambiance. Patrons praise the classic, coal-fired pizza, often recommending it as a great option for families and groups seeking a sit-down meal in a bustling area. While some note it can be a bit noisy, the overall consensus points to a satisfying and memorable pizza outing.
This establishment is highly regarded for its classic, coal-fired pizza, with many recommendations for whole pies. It's frequently suggested as a solid pizza choice in the Times Square area, though some reviews indicate that while acceptable, other pizza options might exist with a bit more travel.
"The coal-fired pizza is highly recommended, particularly the whole pies. It's often suggested as a great option for families and groups."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, appreciating the unique setting and good pizza, especially for families and larger groups. Some acknowledge it can be noisy, but consider it a worthwhile experience.
Important Note
The restaurant is noted to be located in a building with acoustics that can make it loud, potentially impacting conversation during busy times. It is also exclusively a whole pie establishment.
"This user recommended John's Pizzeria as a good pizza option."
Positive"John's of Times Square was recommended for pizza."
Positive"John's Pizza in Times Square is described as a solid sit-down pizza spot that uses brick ovens for cooking."
Positive"John's on 44th street is mentioned as a fine dining option in the Times Square area, comparable to other established restaurants."
Positive"This user mentioned John's of Times Square as a place with very good pizza."
Positive"John's of Times Square is a sit-down restaurant known for full pies, and it's always busy."
Positive"John's Pizzeria on 44th street is suggested, with a note to time the visit for after show curtains."
Positive"John's of Times Square is suggested for pizza, with a note to time the visit after show curtains."
Positive"John's of Times Square is described as great for kids due to its size and being easy to manage with out-of-towners, with the food also being not bad."
Positive"This user recommended John's of Times Square, noting it serves similar pizza to John's of Bleecker Street and has a cool interior that would appeal to kids."
Positive"John's of Times Square is noted as a restaurant with a price range from low to high, and it's possible to have a conversation there if seated away from the bar and entrance."
Positive"John's of Times Square is mentioned as a good pizza option, noted for being located in an old church which gives the space an elevated feel."
Positive"The commenter recommends "Johns pizza in times square" specifically mentioning its location in an old church."
Positive"John's of Times Square is suggested as a kid-friendly option with a large dining room, suitable for families."
Positive"This user suggested John's Pizza on West 44th Street as a possible dining option."
Neutral"This pizza place in Times Square is listed as a good bet for dining."
Positive"Johns is listed as a good Italian option."
Neutral"The user mentioned John's on 44th is not bad at all, but clarified that they only serve whole pies."
Positive
