Old-school pizza joint in a former church, serving whole pies that are a hit w/ families & groups. Not your typical Times Sq. tourist trap!
Experience the classic New York pizza scene at this beloved establishment, housed in a former church, offering a unique dining atmosphere. While known for its whole pies and traditional Italian-American fare, it's a popular choice for families and group gatherings, especially pre-theater. It's noted that while the pizza is good, other excellent options might be a short trip away.
This restaurant is primarily known for its pizza, with many recommendations for whole pies. It offers a classic Italian-American experience and is situated in a distinctive setting within a converted church. While generally well-regarded for pizza, some suggest exploring other options if seeking the absolute best.
"The restaurant is highly recommended for its whole pies, offering a classic New York pizza experience."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, often recommending it for its unique atmosphere and suitability for families and large groups, though some note it can be noisy.
Important Note
Some users have noted that the restaurant can be quite loud due to its acoustics, which might be a concern for those seeking a quieter dining experience or engaging in lengthy conversations.
"John's of Times Square is noted as a restaurant with a price range from low to high, and it's possible to have a conversation there if seated away from the bar and entrance."
Positive"John's of Times Square is mentioned as a good pizza option, noted for being located in an old church which gives the space an elevated feel."
Positive"The commenter recommends "Johns pizza in times square" specifically mentioning its location in an old church."
Positive"John's of Times Square is suggested as a kid-friendly option with a large dining room, suitable for families."
Positive"This user suggested John's Pizza on West 44th Street as a possible dining option."
Neutral"This pizza place in Times Square is listed as a good bet for dining."
Positive"Johns is listed as a good Italian option."
Neutral"The user mentioned John's on 44th is not bad at all, but clarified that they only serve whole pies."
Positive"The user found John's of Times Square to be acceptable but suggested better pizza options are available with a short travel time within Manhattan."
Neutral"For a classic NYC pizza experience with kids, John's in Times Square is recommended. It's a sit-down coal oven pizza place located in a converted church."
Positive"John's is recommended for pizza."
Positive"Alternative_Impact11 agrees that John's pizza is the best in Times Square but notes it lacks a tavern atmosphere, still considering it the best bet for the area."
Neutral"DetectiveOk3902 suggests John's pizza in Times Square as a place to sit down and have a drink, acknowledging it may not be the best but is a fine choice."
Neutral"The commenter reiterates their experience that John's of Times Square has loud acoustics, expressing a desire for a venue where conversations with family would be easier."
Negative"The commenter clarifies their concern about John's of Times Square, specifically mentioning that the acoustics of the building itself make it loud, which could hinder conversation during a family event."
Negative"In response to a concern about noise, the commenter points out that any venue hosting 60-80 people is likely to be loud."
Neutral"The commenter inquires about the noise level at John's of Times Square, stating they personally find the acoustics of the building to be loud."
Negative"The commenter inquires if John's of Times Square was excessively loud for a large party, as they personally find the restaurant to be loud."
Negative
