TLDR
Iconic coal-oven pies served in a breathtaking converted church setting. Perfect for group gatherings and family-friendly dining in the heart of the theater district.
Details
Housed within a stunning former church, this Times Square landmark offers a spacious and atmospheric setting for classic, coal-oven fired pizza [10], [13]. It is widely recognized as a top-tier destination for families and groups, known for its ability to accommodate large parties conveniently near the theater district [12], [14], [24]. While some diners argue that more specialized pizza options exist elsewhere in Manhattan, many guests find the food consistently better than expected for such a high-traffic area [1], [23].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic, coal-oven fired pizza that receives high marks for consistency [13], [17]. While visitors generally enjoy the pizzas, some occasional diners have mentioned trying other menu items like 'cupcake sized things' with satisfaction [26]. Despite local health concerns regarding produce, the kitchen maintains rigorous food-safety protocols [27].
Caveats
Dining here is strictly a whole-pie experience, as they do not offer individual slices [2]. It is also recommended to time your arrival carefully around theater show curtains to avoid the largest crowds [15].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About JOHN'S PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: How Often Do You Eat Big Name Pizza Papa Johns
"Ordered occasionally when exhausted late at night due to the convenience of it being in the building."
NeutralFrom post: How Often Do You Eat Big Name Pizza Papa Johns
"The user argues it is a better value than price-gouging local pizzerias and eats it just as often as L'industrie."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Pizza Tonight For Family Of 5 Would
"John's Pizzeria Times Square was directly recommended as what the user was seeking for pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Group Of 10 In Midtown Manhattantheater District
"This user recommended John's Pizza of Times Square and Carmines as options conveniently located near the theaters in Times Square."
PositiveFrom post: Whats The Nontouristy Cheesecake Factory Of Nyc
"This user corroborated the positive experience at John's of Times Square, stating it was a big hit for a group lunch and the food was better than expected."
PositiveFrom post: Whats The Nontouristy Cheesecake Factory Of Nyc
"This user recommended John's of Times Square for its architecture and mass appeal, suggesting a balcony table for people-watching. They noted that even after living in NYC their whole life, they tried it recently and it was a big hit with a group from the suburbs."
PositiveFrom post: Need Help With Good Dinner Places
"This user recommended John's Pizzeria as a good pizza option."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza With Ambience Around Midtown East
"John's of Times Square was recommended for pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Have A Conference In Times Square
"John's Pizza in Times Square is described as a solid sit-down pizza spot that uses brick ovens for cooking."
PositiveFrom post: Times Square Food Suggestions
"John's on 44th street is mentioned as a fine dining option in the Times Square area, comparable to other established restaurants."
PositiveFrom post: Times Square Recs Food Services Etc
"This user mentioned John's of Times Square as a place with very good pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Great Eats For A Picky Teen
"John's of Times Square is a sit-down restaurant known for full pies, and it's always busy."
PositiveFrom post: Best Iconic Times Squaretouristycant Miss
"John's Pizzeria on 44th street is suggested, with a note to time the visit for after show curtains."
PositiveFrom post: Best Iconic Times Squaretouristycant Miss
"John's of Times Square is suggested for pizza, with a note to time the visit after show curtains."
PositiveFrom post: Best Iconic Times Squaretouristycant Miss
"John's of Times Square is described as great for kids due to its size and being easy to manage with out-of-towners, with the food also being not bad."
PositiveFrom post: Best Iconic Times Squaretouristycant Miss
"This user recommended John's of Times Square, noting it serves similar pizza to John's of Bleecker Street and has a cool interior that would appeal to kids."
PositiveFrom post: Any Current Conversationfriendly Quieter
"John's of Times Square is noted as a restaurant with a price range from low to high, and it's possible to have a conversation there if seated away from the bar and entrance."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Daughters 13th Birthday Dinner
"John's of Times Square is mentioned as a good pizza option, noted for being located in an old church which gives the space an elevated feel."
PositiveFrom post: Visiting For A Day Between Xmas And Nye Looking
"The commenter recommends "Johns pizza in times square" specifically mentioning its location in an old church."
Positive