Next.js logo

JOHN'S PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (212) 391-7560

Address: 260 WEST 44 STREET 10036

TLDR

Classic brick-oven pies served in a breathtaking, historic church setting. A go-to spot for families and groups visiting Times Square.

Reddit Sentiment for JOHN'S PIZZA(based on 27 Reddit opinions)

81% Positive15% Neutral4% Negative

Tags

italian 17american 10italian-american 6pizza 24italian 2View All

Neighborhoods

Theater District

Instagram Posts References

John's Pizza of Times Square is recommended by both Creator 1 and Creator 2 as a dining choice near the theatre district, suitable for pre-show or late-night meals.

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
New York Restaurants Are Bracing for the Cyclospora Outbreak
neutral

John's Pizzeria is maintaining rigorous health standards while expressing concern over the outbreak, leading some staff to jokingly suggest sticking to pizza.

• Jul 16, 2026
Read More →
Grubstreet

Details

Located within a stunning converted old church, this iconic spot offers a unique atmosphere that elevates the dining experience [5]. It is widely recognized as a reliable, spacious destination for families and large groups looking for quality pizza in the heart of the theater district [3], [7], [19]. While some diners appreciate its consistent value and convenience [22], [27], others note that the overall quality may have fluctuated over time [25].

Food Overview

The restaurant specializes in classic, coal-oven, and brick-oven pizza that is widely considered a solid sit-down option in Midtown [7], [12]. While the menu is praised by many as a reliable crowd-pleaser, it is occasionally noted that better specialty pizza options may exist elsewhere in Manhattan [7], [17].

Customer Sentiment

Feedback is generally positive, with guests frequently praising the spacious, family-friendly environment and consistent food quality [7], [8], [17]. However, some patrons have noted concerns regarding loud acoustics and a perceived decline in quality compared to the past [6], [25].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About JOHN'S PIZZA

This post highlights why the restaurant is a fantastic choice for families and out-of-towners, noting its cool interior and reliable pizza.
A highly-rated recommendation that emphasizes the restaurant's impressive architecture and its ability to please groups visiting from out of town.
This recommendation specifically points out the restaurant's unique location inside an old church.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Hole In The Wall Restaurants In The Theatre

"A brief recommendation for this specific location."

Neutral
Sep 21, 2026View Comment →

From post: Hole In The Wall Restaurants In The Theatre

"Recommended as a classic NYC food option for the visitor's mother."

Neutral
Sep 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Looking For An Old School Red Sauce Joint Similar

"The commenter believes this restaurant has suffered from a decline in quality."

Negative
Sep 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: Thoughts On Carmines For A Dinner During A Short

"Explicitly recommended as a better option than Carmine's."

Positive
Aug 30, 2026View Comment →

From post: How Often Do You Eat Big Name Pizza Papa Johns

"Ordered occasionally when exhausted late at night due to the convenience of it being in the building."

Neutral
Jul 15, 2026View Comment →

Often mentioned with John's Pizza

More in Theater District

See all

More Italian in NYC

See all