Historic Brooklyn steakhouse known for its stunning ambiance, exceptional martinis, and decadent desserts like Baked Alaska.
Step back in time at Gage & Tollner, a beautifully revived Brooklyn institution serving classic American dishes like steaks, chops, seafood towers, and sensational fried chicken.
Willa Moore reviews Gage & Tollner, a historic Downtown Brooklyn steakhouse that blends old-world charm with a modern feel, highlighting its martinis, raw bar, and special occasion appeal.
Step into a piece of New York history at Gage & Tollner, a beautifully revived Brooklyn institution that masterfully blends old-world charm with a modern dining experience. From its stunning, landmarked interior to its classic American menu, the restaurant offers a memorable outing, especially for special occasions. While steaks can occasionally be hit-or-miss, standout dishes like the sensational fried chicken and decadent desserts, such as the Baked Alaska, make it a destination worth visiting. Don't forget to enjoy their expertly crafted cocktails and the popular Parker House rolls to complete the experience.
Gage & Tollner offers a classic American steakhouse experience with a focus on well-executed dishes. Customers frequently praise the 'Parker House Rolls', 'Butter Roasted Hash Brown', and desserts like the 'Baked Alaska' and 'Coconut Layer Cake'. The fried chicken, inspired by Edna Lewis, is also a notable highlight. While some reviews mention steak inconsistency, the raw bar, seafood platters, and well-made cocktails are consistently recommended.
"Highly recommended dishes include the 'Parker House Rolls', 'Butter Roasted Hash Brown', 'Baked Alaska for Two', fried chicken, and their martinis. The raw bar and seafood platters are also popular choices."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards Gage & Tollner, often highlighting its historic ambiance, well-executed classic American dishes, and exceptional cocktails and desserts. While some find the steaks can be inconsistent, the overall experience is frequently described as memorable and suitable for special occasions.
Important Note
One commenter noted that the location can be on a 'grim stretch of road' with surrounding demolition and odors, which might be off-putting. Another user felt the restaurant has declined from its former glory, finding the food 'so-so' and the bread quality diminished.
"The original poster indicates they will make a reservation at Gage and Tollner based on the suggestions."
Positive"This commenter believes Gage and Tollner is the best fit and suggests Long Island Bar as a follow-up. They also mention Pitt's in Red Hook for food and cocktails."
Positive"This restaurant is suggested as a good fit for the user's requirements, especially considering a potential issue with bar service and the need for reservations."
Positive"This user strongly recommends Gage and Tollner as the top choice for the user's request."
Positive"While appreciating Gage and Tolner for its history, ambiance, and martinis, the commenter found recent meals to be disappointing, especially considering the price."
Negative"This commenter found both Gramercy Tavern and Gage & Tollner to be mediocre for their price point."
Neutral"This commenter provided context on the changing neighborhood around Gage & Tollner, noting past retail declines and recent developments like City Point, while acknowledging the persistent wealth inequality in NYC."
Neutral"This commenter expressed surprise at the stark contrast in wealth evident from the street view near Gage & Tollner."
Neutral"This commenter dismissively described Gage & Tollner as a "hipster fugazi.""
Negative"This commenter agreed with the assessment of Gage & Tollner's location being grim."
Neutral"This commenter personally disagreed with the sentiment that Gage & Tollner has declined, having had well-done experiences on two separate visits a year apart."
Positive"This commenter had a very positive experience at Gage & Tollner, enjoying everything they ate and finding it a great place for special occasions or with parents."
Positive"While Gage & Tollner is a memorable restaurant, this commenter noted its location is on a grim stretch of road, which might be off-putting for tourists due to surrounding demolition and odors."
Neutral"This commenter noted that Gage & Tollner has been resurrected multiple times with initial energy but fails to sustain it, despite being a historic building."
Neutral"This commenter agreed that Gage & Tollner's location under scaffolding is less appealing than Gramercy Tavern's ambiance and location."
Negative"This commenter felt Gage & Tollner used to be very good but is no longer what it once was, finding the food so-so and the bread having declined in quality."
Negative"Gage and Tollner was recommended as a good option for a nice dinner in Brooklyn."
Positive"This user recommended Gage and Tollner for a bachelor party dinner in Brooklyn."
Positive"Gage & Tolner in Brooklyn is mentioned as being pretty good for a steakhouse."
Positive"This commenter recommends Gage & Tollner for dinner, highlighting its great vibe for solo diners."
Positive
