Historic Brooklyn steakhouse w/ vintage ambiance. Classic American fare, standout martinis, raw bar, & desserts.
Step back in time at Gage & Tollner, a beautifully revived Brooklyn institution serving classic American dishes like steaks, chops, seafood towers, and sensational fried chicken.
Willa Moore reviews Gage & Tollner, a historic Downtown Brooklyn steakhouse that blends old-world charm with a modern feel, highlighting its martinis, raw bar, and special occasion appeal.
This historic Brooklyn steakhouse, established in 1892, boasts a beautifully revived, landmarked interior with vintage charm. It offers a sophisticated dining experience with a classic American menu, excelling in martinis, raw bar selections, and decadent desserts.
The American cuisine at Gage & Tollner is a highlight, with many diners raving about the Parker house rolls, baked Alaska, and fried chicken, which is inspired by Edna Lewis. The raw bar and seafood towers are also frequently recommended. While steaks are a staple, some reviews note inconsistency, with a preference for other dishes like the pork chop or fried chicken.
"Highly recommended dishes include the Parker house rolls, butter-roasted hash browns, fried chicken, she-crab soup, and the Baked Alaska for dessert. The raw bar selections and classic steak cuts are also frequently mentioned."
Overall, customers have a positive sentiment, frequently praising the restaurant's classic ambiance, excellent cocktails, and standout dishes like the baked Alaska and Parker house rolls. Some occasional critiques mention steak inconsistency or price, but the general consensus leans towards a highly recommended experience.
Important Note
Some reviewers noted that the steak can be inconsistent or overcooked, and the restaurant can be quite expensive, with a dinner for two potentially costing around $400. The immediate location has also been described as a 'grim' stretch of road.
"Gage and Tollner is listed as a steakhouse option for a birthday celebration in NYC."
Neutral"This user confirmed that Gage and Tollner was suggested by an AI for serving the requested items, and also mentioned a diner in Queens as a possibility."
Neutral"Gage & Tollner is recommended."
Positive"This user agreed that Gage and Tollner is a great suggestion for the original post's request."
Positive"This commenter suggested Gage and Tollner as a possible restaurant that might serve foie gras, fried prawns, and piña coladas."
Neutral"Gage & Tollner is recommended and has an incredible cocktail program."
Positive"Gage & Tollner is recommended."
Positive"Gage and Tollner has pretty good desserts."
Positive"This user simply listed Gage and Tollner as a recommendation."
Positive"Gage and Tollner is recommended as a suitable option for the solo dining theme, offering martinis and fries."
Positive"This commenter suggested Gage and Tollner as an alternative for a classic steakhouse vibe with quality meats."
Positive"This user recommended Gage & Tollner."
Positive"The user confirms their wife had the same negative experience at Gage & Tollner, leading them to not visit."
Negative"The user states Gage & Tollner was their biggest regret, citing tough steak, mediocre food, and high prices."
Negative"This commenter recommended Gage and Tollner, mentioning it in conjunction with Sunken Harbor Club and Strange Delight."
Neutral"The user clarifies they meant 'Classic NYC steakhouse' and acknowledges the mistake regarding Manhattan."
Neutral"The user questions the term 'Manhattan' when referring to restaurants across different boroughs."
Neutral"The commenter points out that Gage & Tollner is located in Brooklyn, not Manhattan."
Neutral"The commenter had a dinner at Gage & Tollner with a group, sharing large ribeye and porterhouse steaks, finding the porterhouse very good and the sides great."
Positive"Gage & Tollner is recommended as a classic NYC steakhouse, noted for its seafood and dessert selection."
Negative
