Historic Brooklyn steakhouse w/ a stunning interior. Known for classic American dishes, amazing martinis, raw bar, & desserts. Perfect for special occasions.
Step back in time at Gage & Tollner, a beautifully revived Brooklyn institution serving classic American dishes like steaks, chops, seafood towers, and sensational fried chicken.
Willa Moore reviews Gage & Tollner, a historic Downtown Brooklyn steakhouse that blends old-world charm with a modern feel, highlighting its martinis, raw bar, and special occasion appeal.
This historic Brooklyn institution, reborn in 2021, offers a captivating blend of old-world charm and modern sophistication. Its landmarked interior, adorned with vintage mirrors and velvet booths, sets a stunning stage for a menu that pays homage to classic American fare with a Southern twist. From perfectly executed martinis and a lavish raw bar to indulgent desserts, Gage & Tollner provides a memorable dining experience worthy of any special occasion.
Gage & Tollner offers a classic American menu with Southern influences, excelling in its martinis, raw bar selections (including oysters and shrimp cocktail), and a variety of desserts like the Baked Alaska and coconut cake. While some diners note steak can be inconsistent, dishes like the fried chicken, she-crab soup, and butter-roasted hash browns receive high marks. The restaurant is also noted for having good vegetarian options.
"Highlights include the Baked Alaska for two, Parker House rolls, butter-roasted hash browns, she-crab soup, oysters Rockefeller, and their fried chicken. The martinis are also frequently praised."
Customers generally praise Gage & Tollner for its beautiful ambiance, excellent cocktails, and standout desserts. While some have found the steaks inconsistent, many consider it a top choice for special occasions and a uniquely charming dining experience.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that while the ambiance and certain dishes like the Baked Alaska are exceptional, the steaks can be inconsistent, and the overall experience might not always justify the high price point. The surrounding area's construction has also been noted as potentially off-putting.
"This user agreed that Gage and Tollner is the definitive answer for the original post's request."
Positive"This user recommended Gage and Tollner as a great steakhouse in downtown Brooklyn, highlighting its landmarked space."
Positive"Gage and Tollner in Brooklyn Heights received high praise for its delicious food and drinks, particularly its steak and raw bar. The overall experience is consistently amazing."
Positive"Gage and Tollner is listed as one of several good and easily accessible restaurants for steak frites."
Positive"This commenter specifically endorses Gage & Tollner as perfect for a steak and martini birthday dinner."
Positive"Gage & Tollner is noted for having a nice bar area, suitable for drinks after a meal."
Positive"Gage & Tollner is recommended as a top Brooklyn restaurant, particularly fitting the vibe for a steak and martini birthday dinner."
Positive"Recommended the She-crab soup at Gage & Tollner."
Positive"Gage & Tollner is listed as a recommendation, described as a Chop House."
Neutral"The Baked Alaska at Gage+Tollner in Brooklyn is highly recommended for including cherry ice cream and being very good."
Positive"Gage and Tollner is listed as a recommendation."
Neutral"The coconut cake at Gage + Tollner is recommended."
Positive"This user enthusiastically endorsed Gage & Tollner and suggested having drinks at Sunken Harbor, a tiki bar upstairs, beforehand."
Positive"This commenter highlighted Gage & Tollner as the best option, also suggesting the tiki bar upstairs. They also mentioned Bamonte's for red sauce and Laser Wolf for Mediterranean, and Theodora or Miss Ada as other great choices."
Positive"This user simply recommended Gage & Tollner as a birthday dinner option."
Positive"The original poster found Gage and Tollner to be too fussy for their preference."
Negative"A suggestion for a steak restaurant."
Neutral"This user suggested reaching out to the pastry chef at Gage & Tollner, as she created a beautiful and delicious cake for a friend's celebration in a style similar to what the original poster is seeking."
Positive"The user recommends the Baked Alaska at Gage and Tollner."
Positive"The user mentions that the Baked Alaska at Gage & Tollner in Brooklyn is supposedly iconic."
Positive
