TLDR
Historic 1892 landmark in Downtown Brooklyn. Revived chophouse known for its stunning velvet-and-brass atmosphere, expert martinis, and iconic Baked Alaska.
Reddit Sentiment for GAGE & TOLLNER(based on 161 Reddit opinions)
Step back in time at Gage & Tollner, a beautifully revived Brooklyn institution serving classic American dishes like steaks, chops, seafood towers, and sensational fried chicken.
Time Out reviews Gage & Tollner, a historic Downtown Brooklyn steakhouse revitalized by new owners, praising its timeless decor, sharp cocktails, and standout dishes like Clams Kimisino and Edna Lewis-inspired fried chicken.
Willa Moore reviews Gage & Tollner, a historic Downtown Brooklyn steakhouse that blends old-world charm with a modern feel, highlighting its martinis, raw bar, and special occasion appeal.
Details
A masterfully revived 1892 landmark in Downtown Brooklyn, this restaurant blends historical grandeur—featuring crimson velvet and brass chandeliers—with a contemporary American chophouse menu [3], [6]. While the dining experience is widely celebrated for its atmosphere and sharp cocktail program, consistency remains a point of debate among diners, particularly regarding steak execution [1], [5], [7]. The venue is consistently recommended for special occasions, offering a polished, time-traveling aesthetic that stands out in the Brooklyn dining scene [3], [8].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American chophouse classics, with standouts including fried chicken inspired by Edna Lewis, she-crab soup, and extensive raw bar selections [3], [4], [6]. While the Parker house rolls, butter-roasted hash browns, and Baked Alaska are frequently cited as must-order items, some diners have noted that the steaks can be hit-or-miss at this price level [1], [5], [7].
Highlights / Recommended
"The Baked Alaska, Parker house rolls, and butter-roasted hash browns are consistently highlighted as standout, must-try items [1], [3], [5]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •baked alaska(20)
- •steak(6)
- •fried chicken(6)
- •parker house rolls(6)
- •creamed spinach(4)
- •ny strip(3)
- •seafood tower(3)
- •steak frites(3)
- •parker rolls(3)
- •baked alaska for two(2)
- •butter roasted hash browns(2)
- •oysters rockefeller(2)
- •caesar salad(2)
- •house rolls(2)
- •martini(2)
- •wedge salad(2)
- •clams kimisino(2)
Customer Sentiment
Overall, the restaurant is frequently recommended for its classic, elegant atmosphere and suitability for special events [1], [3]. However, opinions are polarized, with some patrons praising the experience while others report concerns over inconsistent food quality and value relative to the price point [5], [6].
Caveats
Some visitors note that the immediate street location can be gritty due to construction or demolition nearby [1]. Additionally, reservations are highly recommended, as the space is popular for special occasions [2], [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About GAGE & TOLLNER
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Recommendations For The Best Savoury Pot Pies In
"Regarding Gage and Tollner, their menu offers several standout dishes beyond steak."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For The Best Savoury Pot Pies In
"The pork pot pie at Gage and Tollner is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Does Gage Tollners Dessert Menu Still Hold Up
"This user visited Gage & Tollner a few months ago and highly recommends the Baked Alaska, but found the steaks to be mediocre for a steakhouse."
PositiveFrom post: Does Gage Tollners Dessert Menu Still Hold Up
"This user believes that the dessert recipes at Gage & Tollner likely remained the same after Caroline Schiff's departure, as it's improbable she was the sole creator of all prior desserts."
NeutralFrom post: Does Gage Tollners Dessert Menu Still Hold Up
"This user recently visited Gage & Tollner and found the desserts enjoyable, though they cannot offer a comparison to the menu during Caroline Schiff's tenure as they did not experience it."
PositiveFrom post: Whats One Fine Dining Restaurant That
"Gage and Tollner is recommended as a fine dining steakhouse option."
PositiveFrom post: Spacious Restaurants Anywhere In Manhattan Or
"Gage and Tollner is mentioned as a restaurant that could potentially offer spacious seating."
NeutralFrom post: I Won A 250 Gift Card To The Restaurant Of My
"Gage and Tollner was recommended as a dining option."
PositiveFrom post: New York Times Top 100 Restaurants X Michelin
"This user expressed surprise that Gage & Tollner made the list, stating that the place has "really gone downhill" in the past couple of years."
NegativeFrom post: Romantic Nyc Dinner Recommendations That Arent
"The original poster thanked the commenter for the recommendations."
PositiveFrom post: Romantic Nyc Dinner Recommendations That Arent
"Gage & Tollner was recommended as a high-end steakhouse option for a nice room and ambiance without experimental food, suitable for a romantic dinner."
PositiveFrom post: New York Times Top 100 Restaurants X Michelin
"Gage & Tollner is listed on the NYT top 100 list for 2023, 2024, and 2025, with a Michelin selection."
NeutralFrom post: Nice Venue For Dinner With Work Clients Brooklyn
"This user agreed that Gage and Tollner is the definitive answer for the original post's request."
PositiveFrom post: Nice Venue For Dinner With Work Clients Brooklyn
"This user recommended Gage and Tollner as a great steakhouse in downtown Brooklyn, highlighting its landmarked space."
PositiveFrom post: Post Wedding Dinner Suggestions
"Gage and Tollner in Brooklyn Heights received high praise for its delicious food and drinks, particularly its steak and raw bar. The overall experience is consistently amazing."
PositiveFrom post: Steak Frites
"Gage and Tollner is listed as one of several good and easily accessible restaurants for steak frites."
PositiveFrom post: Steak Recs
"This commenter specifically endorses Gage & Tollner as perfect for a steak and martini birthday dinner."
PositiveFrom post: Steak Recs
"Gage & Tollner is noted for having a nice bar area, suitable for drinks after a meal."
PositiveFrom post: Steak Recs
"Gage & Tollner is recommended as a top Brooklyn restaurant, particularly fitting the vibe for a steak and martini birthday dinner."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Crab Dish In Nyc
"Recommended the She-crab soup at Gage & Tollner."
Positive