TLDR
Cozy, reliable late-night neighborhood bar serving iconic patty melt specials; perfect for casual dates and after-shift drinks.
Details
A cozy Brooklyn neighborhood staple, this spot is celebrated as an ideal destination for late-night bites and first dates alike [1]. The menu is anchored by American bar fare, most notably a consistent and long-running signature patty melt special that has garnered a loyal following [2]. While the vibe is widely appreciated for being both welcoming and established in the area, opinions on the food quality can vary among patrons [2], [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic American bar food, highlighted by a signature Tuesday patty melt special featuring griddled toast, sauce, onions, and cheese [2]. While the patty melt is a crowd favorite, some diners critique the use of white toast instead of traditional rye [14]. Sides like the crispy, McDonald’s-style fries are popular, though portion sizes have been noted as inconsistent [2], [3]. A veggie burger alternative is available and well-regarded, while the salad is generally not recommended as a substitute for fries [2], [8].
Highlights / Recommended
"The Tuesday night patty melt special is the most frequently recommended dish, with the veggie patty melt serving as a well-regarded alternative [2], [8]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •patty melt(5)
- •fries(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons generally regard the establishment as a reliable, cozy neighborhood go-to with an inviting atmosphere [2], [6], [11]. While many praise its longevity and status as a solid, affordable bar, some visitors offer mixed feedback regarding the consistency of the food [2], [10], [13], [14].
Caveats
Some patrons have noted recent fluctuations in fry portion sizes and occasional inconsistencies in the preparation of the signature patty melt [2], [3], [5]. Additionally, the use of white bread for the patty melt has drawn criticism from those preferring more traditional preparations [14].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE NARROWS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"The commenter used to go weekly for the patty melt and also enjoyed the salad with chicken when pregnant."
PositiveFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"States that the patty melt is a good deal and the bar is very cozy."
PositiveFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"Briefly notes that it is a solid bar with affordable cocktails."
PositiveFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"Describes it as a fantastic date spot with great cocktails, a backyard, and food."
PositiveFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"The commenter specifically enjoys the veggie version of the patty melt."
PositiveFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"Critiques the use of white toast instead of rye for the patty melt, labeling it a 'transplant' spot."
NegativeFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"Briefly states that the food is not that good."
NegativeFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"The commenter expresses high praise, stating the place has stood the test of time in the area."
PositiveFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"The commenter enjoyed the bar after shifts at a nearby pizza place, noting it rocks."
PositiveFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"The commenter recommends the bar as a great first date spot."
PositiveFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"Recalls a specific instance where the kitchen provided an excessive amount of onions on the patty melt."
NeutralFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"The author suspects they were skimped on fries recently, wondering if it's a bad day or shrinkflation."
NeutralFrom post: The Same Dish 15 Times Over 3 Years Patty Melt
"The author has eaten the Tuesday patty melt special 15+ times over three years, noting price increases and generally consistent quality despite variability in fry portioning and toasting."
PositiveFrom post: Is There Any Bar In This City That Actually Has
"The Narrows is mentioned as the commenter's go-to late-night spot in Brooklyn."
Positive