Next.js logo

POP'S EAT-RITE

Updated

Phone: (415) 425-1579

Address: 123 SAINT MARKS PLACE 10009

TLDR

Authentic, Tokyo-style Neapolitan pizza featuring signature charred, airy crusts and unique topping combinations. A must-visit for pizza lovers, despite the intense hype and challenging reservation process.

Reddit Sentiment for POP'S EAT-RITE(based on 52 Reddit opinions)

35% Positive42% Neutral23% Negative

Tags

japanese 52italian 15neapolitan 5pizza 56neopolitan 3sausage 2View All

Neighborhoods

East Village

Instagram Posts References

The author visited PST.NYC specifically to try their Tokyo-Neapolitan pizza and found the experience to be highly rewarding, even braving a thunderstorm to get there. They managed to get two bar spots and were seated together. The restaurant offers a Wagyu Meatball appetizer, which was described as tender and flavorful, though the author suggests skipping it to focus on more pizza next time. The highlight of the meal was the pizza, particularly the signature Tamaki pie, praised for its simple yet perfect combination of tomatoes, smoked mozzarella, and basil, with a delightful pop from the fresh tomatoes. The Arrabbiata pizza was a personal favorite, noted for being saucier with the addition of nduja, garlic, and pepper. A standout feature for all the pizzas was the crust, described as 'to die for.' The author strongly recommends PST.NYC, suggesting that while tables are hard to get, bar seats are more accessible.

This post features Pizza Studio Tamaki, a pizzeria that originated in Tokyo and has recently opened in NYC's East Village. The reviewer was highly impressed, awarding it a 10/10 rating. They specifically noted the "butter chicken pizza" as a secret off-menu special, describing the chicken as perfectly spiced and the crust as heavenly and bubbly-charred. Additionally, the restaurant offers a selection of beers from the Michelin-starred Moody Tongue Brewery. The "Tamaki pizza" is likened to a margarita with smoked mozzarella, calling it a perfectly executed take on a classic.

Pizza Studio Tamaki, also referred to as Pizza PST, has recently opened its doors in New York City's East Village, bringing a unique Japanese take on Neapolitan-style pizzas. The establishment prides itself on its meticulous preparation, with everything being a "labor of love," notably their pizza dough which undergoes a fermentation process of over 30 hours. The review highlights the quality of their pizzas, specifically mentioning the 'Tamaki' pizza, which features San Marzano tomatoes and smoked mozzarella, and the 'Five Fromaggi' pizza, served with honey, both of which are described as excellent. Beyond pizzas, the restaurant also offers impressive desserts, including a Tiramisu and a distinctive Okinawa Salt Ice Cream with olive oil. The post emphasizes that the New York location maintains the same high standard as its Japanese counterpart, as attested by those who have experienced the brand in Japan.

Pizza Studio Tamaki (PST) is a new Neapolitan-style pizza restaurant in New York City's East Village, described as bringing some of Tokyo's best pizza to the city. The restaurant offers 10 different Neapolitan style pizzas and a selection of appetizers, emphasizing the use of the freshest and highest quality ingredients imported from around the world. It has quickly become a spot with difficult-to-snag reservations, indicating its rising popularity. While the meatballs, which were highly anticipated, were not available during the visit, a delicious mushroom soup was served as a pleasant alternative. The overall experience was very positive, though the reviewer noted it might not be their absolute number one favorite Neapolitan pizza in New York, it is certainly among the best.

Featured Articles

Dedicated reviews and comprehensive features focusing directly on this restaurant.

neutral

An NYC outpost of a renowned Tokyo pizzeria, Pizza Studio Tamaki brings a science-driven approach to pizza that generates significant hype, though the results provide a mixed, if fascinating, experience.

Jul 29, 2026
Read More →
Grubstreet
Pizza Studio Tamaki
positive

Will Hartman reviews Pizza Studio Tamaki in the East Village, praising its distinctive Neapolitan pizzas and lively atmosphere. Discover why this spot is worth the reservation for its unique crust and standout pies.

Will HartmanFeb 5, 2026
Read More →
Infatuation

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is mentioned alongside others.

Mentioned In
NYC’s Hit List: The Best New Restaurants, Dishes, and Drinks
positive

Willa Moore highlights the Bismarck pizza at Pizza Studio Tamaki as a standout, praising the successful combination of mozzarella, sausage, mushrooms, egg, and black pepper on a smoky, charred crust.

Bryan KimMay 29, 2026
Read More →
Infatuation
Mentioned In
NYC’s Best Neapolitan (and Neapolitan-ish) Pizzerias
positive

Will Hartman discusses Pizza Studio Tamaki's East Village location, known for its uniquely charred, asteroid-like crust that, surprisingly, doesn't taste burnt. He recommends the Bismarck pizza.

Will HartmanMay 15, 2026
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

Bringing acclaimed Tokyo-style Neapolitan pizza to the East Village, this spot offers visually striking pies with a deeply charred, airy crust [1], [3]. While reservations are notoriously difficult to secure, the atmosphere remains buzzy and casual, making it a popular choice for those seeking unique Japanese-influenced flavors [3]. Diners praise the quality of the ingredients [3], [4], though some caution that the hype and high pricing may not align with everyone's expectations [1], [2].

Food Overview

The menu focuses on Tokyo-style Neapolitan pizza, noted for a dough fermentation process exceeding 30 hours and a distinct 'salt punch' technique [4], [5]. Standout recommendations include the Bismarck, featuring sausage, mushrooms, and a runny egg [1], [2], [3], [4], and the Tamaki pie, which highlights fresh San Marzano tomatoes and smoked mozzarella [3], [5]. While many enjoy the airy crust [3], [6], some diners found certain pizzas to be quite rich or heavy [3], and others suggested skipping appetizers like meatballs to focus on the main event [3], [5].

Highlights / Recommended

Mentioned Dishes:

  • pizza(6)
  • tamaki pizza(3)
  • bismarck(2)
  • bismarck pizza(2)

Customer Sentiment

Feedback is polarized between diners who celebrate the unique, high-quality Japanese-Neapolitan style and those who feel the experience is overhyped and overpriced [1], [2], [3]. Many customers find the reservation system difficult and the wait times for walk-ins substantial, though bar seating is often suggested as a more accessible alternative [1], [3].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About POP'S EAT-RITE

This thread serves as the primary hub for discussions regarding reservation difficulty, long walk-in wait times, and debates over whether the restaurant lives up to its hype.
This post clarifies booking logistics, such as how to secure bar seats for solo diners and reservation timing, while including feedback on the quality of the Neapolitan dough.
A practical discussion confirming that the airy, light crust makes it manageable for solo diners to enjoy multiple pies in a single sitting.
This discussion addresses the lack of formal takeout options and notes that the pizza's quality does not lend itself well to being eaten outside the restaurant.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Pizza Studio Tamaki Are 2 Pizzas Too Much For One

"The commenter observed solo diners at the bar successfully finishing two pizzas each, encouraging the original poster to do the same."

Positive
Jul 10, 2026View Comment →

From post: Pizza Studio Tamaki Are 2 Pizzas Too Much For One

"The commenter confirms they managed to eat three pizzas by themselves during a recent visit."

Positive
Jul 9, 2026View Comment →

From post: Pizza Studio Tamaki Are 2 Pizzas Too Much For One

"The commenter notes that they personally consumed two pizzas easily while visiting a location of this restaurant."

Positive
Jul 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Pizza Studio Tamaki Are 2 Pizzas Too Much For One

"The commenter suggests two pizzas are very doable because the crust is airy, though they advise against ordering additional food or beer."

Positive
Jul 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Pizza Studio Tamaki In Nyc Has Anyone Gotten

"The user advises against takeout because the pizza is expensive and the style does not travel well, noting the restaurant is currently booking up quickly."

Neutral
Jul 4, 2026View Comment →

More in East Village

See all

More Japanese in NYC

See all