Details
A popular pizza spot in Manhattan, this establishment is noted for its delicious pizza, with one commenter specifically mentioning the basil plate and paper as seen in a picture, indicating a memorable dining experience [1]. While praised for its offerings, it's worth noting that some suggest even better pizza might be found nearby [2].
Caveats
While this spot is noted for its pizza, there's a prevailing opinion that even better pizza might be available a short distance away [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CARNEGIE PIZZA
A commenter suggests this restaurant by referencing a specific basil plate and paper, implying it's a recognizable detail associated with their pizza.
One user notes that the best pizza might be located up the street from this restaurant, offering a comparative perspective on the local pizza scene.
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter suggests Carnegie's, mentioning the same basil plate and paper as seen in the picture."
NegativeJun 11, 2026View Comment →
From post: Can You Help Me Narrow Down My List
"Notes that the best pizza is available up the street from L'Industrie."
PositiveJul 4, 2025View Comment →