TLDR
Iconic Manhattan bakery famous for viral, creamy banana pudding and classic American sweets. A polarizing tourist staple where opinions swing from 'must-try' to 'overrated'.
Reddit Sentiment for MAGNOLIA BAKERY(based on 119 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The Milk and Cookies flavor was loved even more than the original by the reviewer, who found it creamy with a good amount of cookies in every bite. The medium size cost $10 something.
The post specifically highlights Magnolia Bakery and their famous banana pudding. The author's verdict is 'Worth It', with the caveat that the experience is location dependent. Despite this, the pudding is described as delicious.
Magnolia Bakery is known for its famous banana pudding, which has a strong following. The pudding itself is silky and creamy with banana pieces and soft vanilla wafers. However, the reviewer felt the flavor was one-dimensional and lacked contrast, not quite living up to the hype.
The video features the iconic banana pudding from Magnolia Bakery, showing it being opened and a person enjoying it with a very positive expression. The text rates it 10/10, emphasizing its deliciousness.
Magnolia Bakery is famous for its New York style cheesecake and viral banana pudding, securing its place as a top dessert spot in the city.
This establishment is recommended as part of the GoCity New York Mini Guide for its famous cupcakes and banana pudding.
Details
Famous for its viral banana pudding and classic American desserts, this bakery remains a major staple for visitors in Manhattan [1]. While its signature pudding and cupcakes draw long lines and consistent recommendations as a quintessential New York treat [2], [3], opinions on the quality are notably polarized [4]. Many long-time fans praise their carrot cake as top-notch [5], though frequent critics argue that several items, particularly the cupcakes, have become overly sweet and inconsistent [6].
Food Overview
The bakery is best known for its banana pudding, which many find satisfying and creamy [1], though it is often criticized for being too sweet or having a texture closer to whipped cream than traditional pudding [2], [3]. While cupcakes are a signature offering, feedback on them is mixed, with frequent complaints about dry textures and excessive icing sweetness [4], [5]. Other items like the carrot cake [6], cheesecake [7], and cheesecake brownies [8] are often recommended as high-quality alternatives to the more famous menu staples.
Caveats
Many patrons advise against ordering delivery for items like the banana pudding, suggesting the quality is better when picked up in person [1]. Additionally, several reviewers note that the intense sweetness of the desserts may not be suitable for all palates [2], [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MAGNOLIA BAKERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Gotos For Cheesecake In The Upper East Sideupper
"Strongly recommended Magnolia Bakery for cheesecake."
PositiveFrom post: Gotos For Cheesecake In The Upper East Sideupper
"Noted for good, individual-sized cheesecakes."
PositiveFrom post: Best Lemon Bars In The Citythe Tangier The Better
"The user suggests that Magnolia offers a decent lemon bar."
PositiveFrom post: Best Lemon Bars In The Citythe Tangier The Better
"The user notes Magnolia has a key lime icebox bar that is tangy, even though it is technically a lime bar."
PositiveFrom post: Best German Chocolate Cake In Nyc Thanks Sos Much
"The user concurs that the bakery offers a very good version of the cake."
PositiveFrom post: Best German Chocolate Cake In Nyc Thanks Sos Much
"The user states that this bakery prepares a high-quality German chocolate cake."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Buy Some Bussin Pastries Near
"Mentioned as having a branch near Rockefeller Center."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Some Bakeriescakes That You Would
"The user reports that a work celebration with their cakes led to a sugar-induced food coma."
NegativeFrom post: What Are Some Bakeriescakes That You Would
"The commenter felt the banana pudding was over-the-top sweet and overhyped."
NegativeFrom post: What Are Some Bakeriescakes That You Would
"The commenter describes the cupcakes as nasty sweet and often stale."
NegativeFrom post: What Are Some Bakeriescakes That You Would
"The user found the cake to be pure sugar with no other flavor."
NegativeFrom post: What Are Some Bakeriescakes That You Would
"The user confirms Magnolia is definitely too sweet."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Some Bakeriescakes That You Would
"The user states Magnolia's is very sweet."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Cupcakes In Ktown Or Soho For Today
"The user advises against visiting, claiming the cupcakes are too dry."
NegativeFrom post: Whats The Best Red Velvet Cake Slice In The City
"This user agrees that they don't get cake from Magnolia Bakery anymore, although they still like the brownies."
NegativeFrom post: Whats The Best Red Velvet Cake Slice In The City
"This user humorously questions if the Viet Cong owns Magnolia Bakery."
NeutralFrom post: Whats The Best Red Velvet Cake Slice In The City
"This user had a disappointing experience at Magnolia Bakery recently, finding the cake dry and the frosting not good."
NegativeFrom post: Whats The Best Red Velvet Cake Slice In The City
"This user believes Magnolia Bakery is a solid bakery despite potential downvotes, noting they like the cake flavor but have to scrape off the icing."
PositiveFrom post: Whats The Best Red Velvet Cake Slice In The City
"This user comments on the downvotes received, possibly related to the previous comment about Magnolia Bakery."
NeutralFrom post: Whats The Best Red Velvet Cake Slice In The City
"This user states that Magnolia Bakery is now VC owned and not what it used to be."
Negative