Last Updated: 20 days ago
Phone: (212) 767-1123
Address: 1240 AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS 10020
Famous for its iconic banana pudding, this bakery offers classic American comfort desserts with mixed reviews on cupcakes.
Magnolia Bakery is a beloved New York City institution, renowned for its classic American baked goods, with its banana pudding being the undisputed star. While many flock to experience this iconic dessert, reviews are mixed on other offerings like cupcakes, with some finding them overrated. Nonetheless, it remains a popular destination for those seeking a sweet taste of New York.
Magnolia Bakery is primarily celebrated for its legendary banana pudding, which receives widespread acclaim for its taste and texture. While many customers highly recommend it, some find it to be overhyped or prefer homemade versions. The cupcakes, on the other hand, have mixed reviews, with some enjoying them and others finding them to be overrated or mediocre compared to other baked goods.
"The banana pudding is the most highly recommended dish, consistently praised by many. The Key Lime Cheesecake and carrot cake have also received positive mentions."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Magnolia Bakery, with many specifically praising their iconic banana pudding. However, some find the cupcakes to be overrated or mediocre, and a few express that the banana pudding is not as good as homemade versions.
Important Note
Some customers find the banana pudding to be overhyped or not as good as homemade versions, and the cupcakes also receive mixed reviews, with some considering them overrated.
"This commenter reports that a friend recently bought a whole chocolate cake from Magnolia and found it to be delicious."
Positive"Magnolia Bakery was mentioned, though the user's vote was negative."
Negative"The author believes Magnolia's carrot cake and hummingbird cakes are better than their banana pudding, which they find overrated."
Positive"The user finds Magnolia's banana pudding to be good but not exceptionally noteworthy or deserving of its fame, suggesting other items are better."
Neutral"The user believes Magnolia's banana pudding is overrated compared to Southern versions, finding it average and a pale imitation of a Southern staple."
Negative"The user enjoyed Magnolia's banana pudding, especially in the context of a pleasant day in Central Park."
Positive"This user mentioned Magnolia Bakery in response to a request for cake delivery recommendations. The original post was looking for celebration cakes."
Neutral"Magnolia Bakery is mentioned as a potential recommendation for dessert."
Positive"The commenter suggests Magnolia Bakery's banana pudding as a good dessert choice, despite it being a stereotypical option."
Positive"Magnolia Bakery sells its characteristic cupcakes."
Neutral"The user expresses a personal love for Magnolia Bakery's banana pudding, acknowledging that it might be a controversial opinion."
Positive"The user lists the cupcakes at Magnolia Bakery as a personal favorite, anticipating it might be an unpopular opinion."
Positive"A Magnolia Bakery location is noted to be available in the lower floor of the Grand Central mini food hall, making it convenient."
Neutral"The user informed others that there is a post-TSA Magnolia Bakery location at LGA Terminal B for those needing to transport pudding."
Neutral"The user humorously speculated that TSA agents might have eaten the original poster's banana pudding."
Neutral"The user agreed that Little Cupcake Bakeshop's banana pudding is better than Magnolia Bakery's."
Negative"The user humorously explained that they ate half of Magnolia Bakery's banana pudding outside of security, after a TSA agent advised it could pass if below the liquid limit, so their fiancé could try it at home."
Neutral"The user humorously asked if the original poster ate the banana pudding from Magnolia Bakery in front of TSA as a power move."
Neutral"The user advised taping the lid and placing Magnolia Bakery's banana pudding in a zip-lock bag for transport, noting that the lid can loosen and whipped cream doesn't stay solid."
Neutral"The user expressed gratitude for the timely heads-up regarding Magnolia Bakery's banana pudding and TSA rules, stating they now plan to check their pudding for an upcoming flight."
Neutral
