MAGNOLIA BAKERY
Updated
Phone: (212) 767-1123
Address: 1240 AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS 10020
TLDR
Legendary NYC banana pudding and classic American sweets. A polarizing must-visit for sugar-seekers.
Reddit Sentiment for MAGNOLIA BAKERY(based on 114 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The Milk and Cookies flavor was loved even more than the original by the reviewer, who found it creamy with a good amount of cookies in every bite. The medium size cost $10 something.
The post specifically highlights Magnolia Bakery and their famous banana pudding. The author's verdict is 'Worth It', with the caveat that the experience is location dependent. Despite this, the pudding is described as delicious.
Magnolia Bakery is known for its famous banana pudding, which has a strong following. The pudding itself is silky and creamy with banana pieces and soft vanilla wafers. However, the reviewer felt the flavor was one-dimensional and lacked contrast, not quite living up to the hype.
The video features the iconic banana pudding from Magnolia Bakery, showing it being opened and a person enjoying it with a very positive expression. The text rates it 10/10, emphasizing its deliciousness.
Magnolia Bakery is famous for its New York style cheesecake and viral banana pudding, securing its place as a top dessert spot in the city.
Magnolia Bakery will be part of the Law & Order pop-up, contributing their famous desserts to the limited-edition menu.
Details
Famous for its iconic banana pudding and classic American desserts, this bakery remains a staple for visitors and locals alike [1]. While many celebrate its consistent quality and viral treats [2], others find the offerings, particularly the banana pudding, to be overly sweet or inconsistent depending on the location [3]. Despite some polarizing reviews, the bakery continues to be highly regarded for its carrot cake and individual cheesecakes [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American bakery staples, led by the viral banana pudding [1]. While highly praised by many [2], some diners find the pudding more like whipped cream than custard and complain that the cupcakes and cakes can be overly sweet or dry [3]. Recommended alternatives for those seeking variety include their high-quality carrot cake, German chocolate cake, and individual-sized cheesecakes [4].
The carrot cake is widely cited as top-notch [4], and the individual-sized cheesecakes, including the key lime variety, are frequently recommended [4].
Feedback is deeply divided; while many cherish the bakery as a classic NYC institution [4], others frequently criticize the intense, cloying sweetness of the desserts and occasional concerns over quality control [3].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01banana pudding48 mentions
- 02cupcakes10 mentions
- 03cheesecake3 mentions
- 04carrot cake3 mentions
- 05key lime cheesecake2 mentions
- 06cupcake2 mentions
Caveats
Many reviewers warn that the bakery is often over-hyped, and some items can be excessively sweet or stale if not fresh [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MAGNOLIA BAKERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: If You Could Only Pick One What Is Your Favorite
"The user enjoys their chocolate cake for special occasions and is a fan of their banana pudding."
PositiveFrom post: Gotos For Cheesecake In The Upper East Sideupper
"Strongly recommended Magnolia Bakery for cheesecake."
PositiveFrom post: Gotos For Cheesecake In The Upper East Sideupper
"Noted for good, individual-sized cheesecakes."
PositiveFrom post: Best Lemon Bars In The Citythe Tangier The Better
"The user suggests that Magnolia offers a decent lemon bar."
PositiveFrom post: Best Lemon Bars In The Citythe Tangier The Better
"The user notes Magnolia has a key lime icebox bar that is tangy, even though it is technically a lime bar."
Positive