Last Updated: 8 days ago
Phone: (212) 767-1123
Address: 1240 AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS 10020
Iconic American bakery famed for its legendary banana pudding & classic cupcakes. A must-visit sweet treat destination.
This iconic American bakery is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. Renowned for its delectable cupcakes and, most famously, its signature banana pudding, it offers a quintessential New York dessert experience. While some debate its
This American bakery is celebrated for its classic desserts, with the banana pudding being a standout and frequently recommended item. While many rave about the pudding's creamy texture and fresh ingredients, some find it to be overhyped or not as good as homemade versions. The cupcakes also receive praise, though some opinions suggest they are not as impressive as the banana pudding. Other baked goods like cakes and brownies are also available and generally well-received.
"The banana pudding is consistently highlighted as a must-try, with many users recommending it over other desserts. Some also praise the Key Lime Cheesecake and carrot cake."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the iconic banana pudding and cupcakes, though opinions are divided on whether it lives up to the hype.
Important Note
Some customers feel the banana pudding is overhyped or not as good as homemade versions. Opinions on cupcakes are also divided, with some finding them mediocre.
"The author stated that the banana pudding from Magnolia Bakery is worth the hype, indicating a positive experience with this specific item."
Positive"This commenter expressed a negative opinion of Magnolia Bakery's banana pudding, stating it 'sucks and tastes like fuckjng whipped cream'."
Negative"This bakery is known for its great cupcakes, and there are multiple locations in Manhattan."
Positive"The commenter tried the popular Oreo Banana Pudding from Magnolia Bakery."
Neutral"The commenter finds the banana pudding from Magnolia to be a classic comfort food that always hits the spot."
Positive"The user states that Magnolia's banana pudding was one of their favorites during a trip to NY."
Positive"The user recommends trying the banana pudding from Magnolia."
Positive"Banana pudding from Magnolia is recommended."
Positive"This user mentioned that there is a Magnolia Bakery located in Grand Central."
Neutral"The commenter dislikes Magnolia cupcakes and cake."
Negative"Magnolia's is mentioned as a place for cakes."
Neutral"Magnolia's cupcakes and cake slices are mentioned, with a particular preference for their Key Lime icebox bar."
Positive"This commenter reports that a friend recently bought a whole chocolate cake from Magnolia and found it to be delicious."
Positive"Magnolia Bakery was mentioned, though the user's vote was negative."
Negative"The author believes Magnolia's carrot cake and hummingbird cakes are better than their banana pudding, which they find overrated."
Positive"The user finds Magnolia's banana pudding to be good but not exceptionally noteworthy or deserving of its fame, suggesting other items are better."
Neutral"The user believes Magnolia's banana pudding is overrated compared to Southern versions, finding it average and a pale imitation of a Southern staple."
Negative"The user enjoyed Magnolia's banana pudding, especially in the context of a pleasant day in Central Park."
Positive"This user mentioned Magnolia Bakery in response to a request for cake delivery recommendations. The original post was looking for celebration cakes."
Neutral"Magnolia Bakery is mentioned as a potential recommendation for dessert."
Positive
