Last Updated: 4 days ago
Phone: (212) 767-1123
Address: 1240 AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS 10020
Famous banana pudding & classic American baked goods. A beloved NYC institution.
This iconic bakery is celebrated for its quintessential New York desserts, particularly its legendary banana pudding and classic American baked goods. While often drawing crowds for its sweet treats, many visitors find the experience worthwhile for a taste of a beloved NYC institution.
The star of the show is undoubtedly the banana pudding, which garners widespread acclaim for its unique texture and flavor. While cupcakes receive mixed reviews, with some finding them overrated and others loving their fluffy icing, the bakery's overall selection of American baked goods is generally well-regarded.
"The banana pudding is almost universally recommended, with many calling it a must-try. The Key Lime Cheesecake also receives high praise, and some users enjoy the carrot cake and hummingbird cake."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the banana pudding, though opinions are divided on other items like cupcakes. Many acknowledge its iconic status and find it a worthwhile treat.
Important Note
Some customers find the banana pudding to be overhyped or not as good as homemade versions. Cupcakes also receive mixed reviews, with some considering them mediocre.
"The author tried the banana pudding on a whim at a train station on their way out of town and agreed it was delicious, despite potentially being overhyped."
Positive"The author states they make the bakery's banana pudding recipe at home, finding it surprisingly easy and a guaranteed hit at parties. They list the ingredients: Nilla Wafers, sweetened condensed milk, instant vanilla pudding mix, heavy cream, and bananas."
Positive"The author confirms that the online recipe for banana pudding is very good and comparable to what's sold in the store. They also mention it's good with gluten-free wafers for those with celiac disease."
Positive"This user confirms the previous comment, stating that it's not real pudding but banana-flavored whipped cream and expresses significant disappointment."
Negative"The author made the banana pudding at home following the online recipe precisely and was very happy with the results, stating it was very similar to the bakery's version."
Positive"The author tried the banana pudding and found it to be incredible."
Positive"This comment suggests that while the banana pudding is good, the bakery itself is over-hyped and most of their other offerings are mediocre."
Neutral"The author acknowledges a recommendation for Sugar Sweet Sunshine and states they will take note of it."
Neutral"Responding to a recommendation, the author encourages trying the banana pudding, calling it the best."
Positive"Responding to a recommendation for blueberry cheesecake, the author expresses enthusiasm to try it on their next visit."
Positive"A short, positive comment simply stating the banana pudding is "so good!""
Positive"The author expresses their fondness for Magnolia Bakery's blueberry cheesecake."
Positive"The author recommends trying banana pudding in the South, suggesting that any random BBQ joint in Texas makes it just as well or better than Magnolia Bakery."
Neutral"The author asks if anyone has tried making the banana pudding at home using the free online recipe and if it tastes the same as the bakery's version."
Neutral"The author states that the banana pudding sold in grocery stores by Magnolia is also very good, highlighting the wafer bits."
Positive"The author finds the banana pudding incredibly good, sharing an instance where they finished a large container by themselves and consider it their favorite dessert ever."
Positive"A humorous comment implying the banana pudding is a perk of flying United Airlines business class."
Neutral"A comment expressing general appreciation for New York City."
Neutral"The author warns against ordering Magnolia's banana pudding via Doordash, stating it's inferior to the in-store version and should be picked up in person."
Negative"A short, enthusiastic comment simply stating that Magnolia's banana pudding is their favorite."
Positive
